The Le Creuset Signature Skillet and the Staub Fry Pan are two of the best enameled cast iron pans you can buy, but they differ in their interior cooking surface, aesthetic, and price. Le Creuset features a smooth, light-colored enamel interior and comes in a wide range of vibrant colors, making it a beautiful statement piece. Staub uses a proprietary matte black enamel interior that excels at browning and searing, offering a more classic, rustic look at a slightly lower price point.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right iconic French skillet for your kitchen.
Le Creuset Signature Skillet
Le Creuset’s Signature Skillet is a kitchen icon, celebrated for its perfect marriage of form and function. Known for its exceptional heat retention and a spectrum of vibrant colors, this skillet features a smooth, sand-colored enameled interior that makes it easy to monitor cooking progress. It's a versatile pan that works for everything from searing steaks to frying eggs and baking cornbread, all while looking stunning on the stovetop.
- What it is: A premium enameled cast iron skillet known for its colorful finish and versatile performance.
- Key features: Smooth, sand-colored enamel interior, helper handle for easy lifting, large hanging loop, spouts on both sides for drip-free pouring.
- Price: $175 (10.25") to $250 (11.75") depending on size.
- Dimensions: Available in sizes from 6.3" up to 11.75". The 10.25" is the most popular size for everyday use.
- Materials/Construction: Heavy-gauge cast iron with a durable, multi-layer porcelain enamel finish on the interior and exterior.
- Style: Modern, timeless, and vibrant. It's designed to be a stovetop-to-table showpiece.
- Pros: Excellent heat distribution and retention. Light interior makes it easy to see fond development. The smoothest enamel surface is great for delicate foods. Huge range of beautiful colors to choose from. Very easy to clean.
- Cons: Higher price point. The light-colored enamel can show stains over time with heavy use. Can be prone to chipping if knocked against hard surfaces.
The Le Creuset skillet is ideal for the home cook who values both elite performance and kitchen aesthetics, wanting a skillet that cooks beautifully and serves as a colorful centerpiece.
Shop this product: lecreuset.com/signature-skillet
Staub Fry Pan
Staub's Fry Pan is a workhorse designed for cooks who are serious about searing. Its signature feature is the matte black enamel interior, which has a slightly textured surface that promotes exceptional browning and develops non-stick properties over time with use. Praised for its durability and more understated, restaurant-like aesthetic, the Staub skillet is a favorite among professional chefs and home cooks focused purely on high-heat cooking performance.
- What it is: A heavy-duty enameled cast iron fry pan with a unique matte black interior made for searing and browning.
- Key features: Textured matte black enamel interior, pour spouts, available with a helper handle on larger sizes, ergonomic handle design.
- Price: $140 (10") to $230 (12") depending on size.
- Dimensions: Commonly available in 9", 10", 11", and 12" sizes.
- Materials/Construction: High-quality cast iron with a multi-coat enamel. The slightly porous black matte interior is designed for better oil adherence and browning.
- Style: Rustic, classic, and professional. It offers an understated heritage aesthetic with more muted exterior color options.
- Pros: Superior browning and searing capabilities due to matte texture. Black interior will not show stains or discoloration. Slightly more affordable than Le Creuset. Extremely durable and resistant to scratching.
- Cons: Black surface makes it harder to judge fond development or spot burnt bits. Limited color selection compared to Le Creuset. The textured surface can feel less non-stick for delicate items like eggs at first.
The Staub Fry Pan is built for cooks who prioritize searing performance on meats and vegetables above all else and appreciate a durable, classic aesthetic.
Shop this product: staub-online.com/fry-pans-grills
Le Creuset vs. Staub Skillet Comparison
Materials & Cooking Surface
Both brands use high-quality enameled cast iron, but the cooking surface is the biggest differentiator. The Le Creuset skillet features a smooth, glossy, sand-colored enamel. This light color is excellent for beginners and meticulous cooks, as it lets you clearly see the 'fond' - the tasty browned bits at the bottom of the pan - and visually monitor your cooking precisely.
Conversely, the Staub Fry Pan has a matte black, slightly textured interior. This surface is engineered to excel at high-heat searing, creating a beautiful crust on steaks, burgers, and vegetables. It's also fantastic at hiding utensil marks and potential stains from searing, maintaining its look for years. Over time, oils polymerize into the textured surface, building up a patina that improves its release properties.
Performance & Durability
In terms of heat retention and distribution, both pans are top-tier and will perform almost identically. Where they separate is in surface performance. The Staub skillet’s matte interior provides a slightly better grip for searing and achieves a more pronounced crust. Le Creuset’s smooth surface is more forgiving for delicate foods like eggs and fish, acting more like a traditional non-stick from day one.
Both are incredibly durable and built to last a lifetime. Enamel can chip on either pan if dropped or banged against a faucet, but Staub's slightly rougher interior is often viewed as less prone to showing fine scratches from metal utensils compared to Le Creuset's glossy sand-colored finish.
Style & Aesthetics
There's no contest here if bright colors are your priority: Le Creuset wins. With dozens of vibrant, gradient hues from Flame to a soft Meringue, Le Creuset positions its cookware as functional kitchen decor. The design is sleek, iconic, and bright.
Staub's aesthetic is more traditional and rustic. Its color palette is made of deeper, more resonant jewel tones like Grenadine, Basil, and Graphite Grey. Combined with the matte black interior, a Staub skillet feels more like a piece of professional equipment found in a classic French bistro.
Price & Value
While both are premium, investment-level pieces of cookware, Le Creuset consistently prices its skillets about 10-20% higher than comparable sizes from Staub. For cooks focused strictly on function, Staub often represents a better value, delivering arguably better searing performance for less money. For those who place a high value on aesthetics and color choice, the extra cost for a Le Creuset is often seen as worthwhile.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both are exceptional pans that will last a lifetime, but they are engineered for slightly different kitchen priorities.
Choose the Le Creuset Signature Skillet if:
- You want your cookware to be a colorful centerpiece of your kitchen.
- You value a light-colored interior to easily monitor browning and prevent burning.
- You cook a lot of delicate foods like flaky fish or eggs that benefit from a smoother surface.
- You want to build a matching set from the widest range of colors and shapes available.
Choose the Staub Fry Pan if:
- Getting a deep, restaurant-quality sear on meats and vegetables is your top priority.
- You prefer a more professional, understated, or rustic kitchen aesthetic.
- The idea of a pan's surface improving and building patina with use is appealing to you.
- You want top-of-the-line performance and are looking for slightly better value for your money.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Le Creuset and Staub skillets?
The primary difference is the interior cooking surface. Le Creuset uses a smooth, glossy, sand-colored enamel, while Staub uses a slightly textured, matte black enamel designed for superior browning.
Which is better for searing steak?
Staub is generally considered better for searing steak. Its matte black, textured surface promotes a deeper, more even crust and helps develop an impressive char thanks to better oil distribution.
Is Le Creuset or Staub easier to clean?
It's generally a tie. Le Creuset's smooth surface releases food easily, but the light color can show stains over time. Staub's matte black interior hides stains permanently but its texture can occasionally grip food particles more stubbornly, requiring a bit more patience with a nylon brush.
Do you need to season these skillets like raw cast iron?
No. Neither skillet requires traditional seasoning because the enamel coating protects the raw cast iron. However, the performance of the Staub skillet's matte surface does improve with use as cooking oils fill its microscopic pores, creating a semi-seasoned, low-stick patina.
Is it worth spending extra for Le Creuset?
This depends on your priorities. If you value the wide range of iconic colors and a light-colored interior for visual cooking cues, the extra cost is justified. If your sole focus is searing performance and a durable, rustic aesthetic, the Staub offers better value.
Can Le Creuset and Staub skillets go in the oven?
Yes, both are oven-safe. Le Creuset skillets with the standard black phenolic knob are safe up to 500°F. Staub skillets are typically oven-safe to at least 500°F, with many able to withstand much higher temperatures.
Which skillet is heavier?
Both are very heavy, a key trait of quality cast iron that aids in heat retention. Weight is comparable between the two brands for similar-sized skillets, with marginal differences that are not noticeable in everyday use.
What's a better first piece to buy: a skillet or a Dutch oven?
It depends on your cooking style. If you frequently sear, saute, fry, and bake things like skillet cornbread, the skillet is more versatile. If you make a lot of soups, stews, braises, and bake bread, a Dutch oven is the better first investment from either brand.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
