The classic Le Creuset Round Dutch Oven and its counterpart, the Round Wide Dutch Oven, look similar but are designed for different cooking tasks based on one key difference: their shape. The classic Round Dutch Oven is taller with a smaller diameter, making it ideal for soups and stews, while the Round Wide version is shallower with a larger base, excelling at searing large cuts of meat and roasting.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the right piece of Le Creuset cookware for your kitchen.
Le Creuset Classic Round Dutch Oven
The Classic Round Dutch Oven is Le Creuset's most iconic and versatile piece of cookware. Beloved by home cooks and professional chefs alike, its taller profile and balanced proportions make it a kitchen workhorse for everything from slow-simmered sauces and hearty soups to baking artisan bread. Its design prioritizes even heating and excellent moisture retention, making it a reliable choice for everyday cooking.
- What it is: A heavy-duty enameled cast iron pot with high sides, a heavy-fitting lid, and two loop handles.
- Key features: Taller walls minimize evaporation for slow-simmering recipes. The relatively smaller diameter takes up less space on a crowded cooktop. Excellent for deep-frying and boiling.
- Price: Ranges from $250 (3.5 quart) to $460 (7.25 quart), with the popular 5.5-quart size often around $420.
- Dimensions: Sizes range from 3.5 to 9 quarts. The popular 5.5-quart model has a diameter of 10.25 inches.
- Materials/Construction: Premium enameled cast iron that's resistant to chipping, dulling, and staining. The interior enamel is light-colored to make monitoring cooking easy.
- Style: The signature, timeless Le Creuset design, available in dozens of vibrant colors that make it perfect for oven-to-table serving.
- Pros: Excellent heat retention, deep enough for braises and stocks, tight-fitting lid locks in moisture and flavor, easier to store than wider pots, is the quintessential all-purpose pot.
- Cons: Smaller surface area can make searing multiple pieces of meat difficult without crowding the pan.
This classic model is perfect for cooks who need an all-around performer for liquid-heavy dishes, baking, and general-purpose use in small to medium-sized households.
Shop this product: lecreuset.com/round-dutch-oven/
Le Creuset Round Wide Dutch Oven
The Le Creuset Round Wide Dutch Oven offers the same quality and performance as its classic counterpart but with a different geometry. Its wide, shallow design provides a generous cooking surface, making it the superior choice for tasks that require browning, searing, and roasting. Think of it as a hybrid between a Dutch oven and a large braiser, built to handle big roasts and batch cooking with ease.
- What it is: A shorter, broader enameled cast iron pot designed to maximize surface area for searing and roasting.
- Key features: Large, flat base provides ample room for browning meat without crowding. Shorter sides allow for better air circulation when roasting and faster liquid reduction.
- Price: Generally ranges from $300 to $400, with the common 6.75-quart size priced around $430.
- Dimensions: Generally starts at 6.75 quarts, which has a wide 12-inch diameter.
- Materials/Construction: Identical to the classic version - high-quality enameled cast iron with a durable, non-reactive interior.
- Style: Offers the same range of iconic Le Creuset colors but has a lower, broader profile that presents beautifully on a dining table, especially for dishes like paella or roasted chicken.
- Pros: Superior for searing and creates a beautiful crust. Accommodates large cuts of meat or whole poultry. Easier to reach in and stir or flip food. Great for casseroles and shallow frying.
- Cons: Takes up more space on the stovetop and in cabinets. Faster evaporation due to the wider opening can be a disadvantage for some long-simmering dishes. Heavy and can be awkward to handle when full.
The Round Wide model is ideal for anyone who frequently cooks for a crowd, roasts large cuts of meat, or prioritizes a perfect sear on their ingredients.
Shop this product: lecreuset.com/round-wide-dutch-oven/
Round vs. Round Wide Dutch Oven Comparison
Dimensions & Scale
The most critical difference is geometry. For a similar quart capacity, the classic Round Dutch Oven will be taller and narrower, while the Round Wide is shorter and broader. For example, a 6.75-quart Round Wide Dutch Oven has a 12-inch diameter, whereas the 7.25-quart classic Round model has an 11.25-inch diameter.
This affects everything from storage to stovetop space. The classic Round version fits more easily on a packed cooktop and tucks away into deeper cabinets. The Round Wide commands more horizontal real estate, both in use and during storage, which can be a challenge in smaller kitchens.
Cooking Performance & Versatility
The difference in shape directly translates to cooking performance. The Round Wide’s expansive surface area is unmatched for searing. It allows you to brown multiple pieces of meat or vegetables at once without steaming them, creating a deep, flavorful crust. This makes it a better choice for recipes that begin with browning, such as coq au vin or a pot roast.
Conversely, the classic Round Dutch Oven’s taller sides and narrower opening minimize evaporation. This is a huge benefit for slow-simmering soups, stews, stocks, and chili, where you want to retain liquid and lock in moisture over several hours. Its depth also makes it a safer vessel for deep-frying. While you can accomplish all these tasks in either pot, each is optimized for its specific shape.
Materials & Construction
There is no difference here - and that's a good thing. Both the classic Round and Round Wide Dutch Ovens are crafted from the same premium enameled cast iron that Le Creuset is famous for. They offer exceptional heat distribution and retention, a non-reactive and easy-to-clean enamel finish, and feature the same stay-cool knobs and loop handles. Construction quality, durability, and the limited lifetime warranty are identical for both models.
Price & Value
Le Creuset is a premium investment, and both models reflect that. Generally, the Round Wide models are priced slightly higher than classic Round models of a similar capacity. The best value depends entirely on your cooking habits. If you consistently find yourself trying to brown food in batches in a crowded pot, the extra cost for the Round Wide is easily justified. If you primarily cook soups and sauces, the classic Round Dutch Oven offers better performance and versatility for your cooking style at a slightly lower entry price.
Who Each One Works Best For
The classic Round Dutch Oven is the quintessential all-rounder, perfect for small families, apartments, and cooks who want one pot that does a great job at a wide range of tasks - especially those involving liquids. It's the multi-purpose star every kitchen can use.
The Round Wide Dutch Oven is more of a specialist. It’s best for large families, people who enjoy making big roasts, and culinary enthusiasts who prioritize a perfect sear. If your current Dutch oven feels more like a crowded waiting room than a cooking surface when you brown meat, this is the pot for you.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both pots are exceptional tools, but their dimensions are tailored to different culinary strengths.
Choose the Le Creuset Round Dutch Oven if:
- You primarily cook soups, stews, chilis, and sauces.
- You have limited storage or cooktop space.
- You need a versatile, all-purpose pot for everyday cooking.
- You want the best model for baking a rustic, high-rising loaf of bread due to its deeper walls supporting the dough.
Choose the Le Creuset Round Wide Dutch Oven if:
- Your top priority is searing large batches of meat or vegetables without crowding.
- You frequently roast whole chickens or large cuts of beef.
- You cook for a large family or frequently entertain guests.
- You have plenty of kitchen space and want a pot that excels at browning and braising.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Round and Round Wide Dutch Oven?
The primary difference is their shape. The classic Round Dutch Oven is taller with a smaller diameter, ideal for liquids. The Round Wide is shorter with a larger diameter, which provides a bigger surface area for searing and roasting.
Which Le Creuset Dutch oven is better for baking bread?
Most artisan bread bakers prefer the classic Round Dutch Oven. Its tall sides help contain the dough as it rises, encouraging an upward oven spring for a beautiful, round boule. The Round Wide is better suited for flatter breads like focaccia.
Is the Round Wide Dutch Oven harder to store?
Yes, its wider diameter requires more cabinet space. A 12-inch wide pot can be difficult to fit in standard-sized kitchen cabinets, while a taller but narrower pot (around 10-11 inches) is often easier to store.
Can I still sear meat in the classic Round Dutch Oven?
Absolutely. You can get an excellent sear in the classic Round pot, but you will likely need to work in more batches to avoid overcrowding the pan, which can add time to your recipe.
How does the shape affect cooking time?
The Round Wide Dutch Oven has more surface area, which leads to faster evaporation. This means liquids and sauces will reduce more quickly than in the taller, narrower classic Round pot.
Are the quality and materials the same?
Yes, both models are made from Le Creuset's signature enameled cast iron and are built to the same high standards of quality, performance, and durability.
Which size is the most popular for each model?
For the classic Round Dutch Oven, the 5.5-quart size is by far the most popular and versatile for average households. For the Round Wide Dutch Oven, the 6.75-quart capacity is a very common choice as it's large enough for roasts and batch cooking.
Do they both come with a lifetime warranty?
Yes, Le Creuset offers a limited lifetime warranty on all its cast iron cookware, covering defects in material and workmanship for the original owner.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
