Lane Furniture is known for its durable, comfortable, and classic furniture, especially its high-quality recliners, making it a reliable choice for family living. In contrast, Ashley Furniture is a global superstore offering a massive selection of trendy and highly affordable pieces across a wide variety of styles, from modern to rustic farmhouse.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right furniture brand for your home.
Lane Furniture: The Durable Comfort Pioneer
Founded in 1912, Lane Furniture has built a strong reputation as an American brand focused on producing practical, comfortable, and long-lasting home furnishings. While they offer a full range of products, they are especially renowned for their industry-leading recliners and motion furniture. Lane appeals to shoppers who prioritize solid construction and timeless, family-friendly designs over fast-fashion trends.
- Product mix: Specializes in living room furniture like recliners, sofas, sectionals, and motion furniture. Also offers bedroom sets, dining furniture, and accent pieces.
- Style/vibe: Predominantly traditional, classic, and transitional designs. The aesthetic favors plush materials, deep seats, and an overall cozy, casual feel.
- Price point: Affordable to mid-range. Recliners typically cost between $200 and $600, while sofas often start around $399 and go up from there.
- Quality: Emphasizes durable construction with features like hardwood frames, high-density foam cushions, and stain-resistant upholstery, designed to withstand everyday family life.
- Sales: Holds frequent sales events, particularly around major holidays like President's Day, Memorial Day, and Black Friday.
- Delivery & Assembly: Available through its network of retail partners, with options varying by store.
- Return policy: Policies are determined by the third-party retailer where the furniture is purchased.
Lane is an excellent choice for a family room or den where durability and exceptional comfort are the main considerations, offering solid value for long-term use.
Shop Lane Furniture: lanefurniture.com
Ashley Furniture: The Trendy & Affordable Superstore
Ashley Furniture is one of the largest furniture manufacturers in the world, known for its enormous product catalog that covers every room in the home, plus outdoor and decor items. Their business model focuses on providing trend-forward styles at extremely accessible price points. This makes Ashley a go-to choice for first-time homeowners, renters, and anyone looking to furnish a space on a strict budget without sacrificing modern style.
- Product mix: A vast selection of everything from sofas, sectionals, and bedroom sets to dining tables, office furniture, mattresses, outdoor sets, and home decor accessories.
- Style/vibe: Covers a broad spectrum of aesthetics, including modern, contemporary, rustic, industrial, and traditional. Its collections are frequently updated to reflect current design trends.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Sofas can start as low as $299 and full bedroom sets are often available for under $1,000.
- Quality: Quality varies by product line and price. Entry-level pieces often use engineered wood and basic fabrics, while their mid-range and premium collections feature higher-grade materials.
- Sales: Runs near-constant promotions, online-only deals, and big holiday sale events, often featuring bundle deals.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers a range of delivery options, from no-hassle doorstep delivery to in-home assembly services for an additional fee.
- Return policy: Generally offers returns on most items within a specified window, though policies can vary for online vs. in-store purchases.
With its massive selection and low prices, Ashley Furniture makes it easy to furnish an entire home with a stylish, coordinated look on a tight budget.
Shop Ashley Furniture: ashleyfurniture.com
Lane vs. Ashley Furniture Comparison
Price Comparison
Both brands cater to budget-conscious shoppers, but Ashley Furniture generally wins on upfront affordability. Ashley's business model is built around offering some of the lowest prices in the market, with frequent sales, clearance events, and bundle deals that provide exceptional value. You can often find accent chairs, small sofas, and dining sets for just a few hundred dollars.
Lane Furniture is still very affordable but sits at a slightly higher price point. This small premium often reflects their focus on more durable internal construction, such as hardwood frames and more resilient cushioning, positioning them as a better long-term value investment.
Style & Aesthetic
This is a major point of difference. Ashley Furniture is trend-driven, offering a huge variety of styles that align with what's popular in interior design magazines and social media. Whether you’re looking for a sleek modern sofa, a rustic farmhouse dining table, or a glamorous upholstered bed, Ashley likely has an affordable version of it.
Lane leans heavily into traditional, casual, and transitional aesthetics. Their designs prioritize comfort over cutting-edge style, featuring classic silhouettes, rolled arms, and plush upholstery. Lane's furniture is designed to feel inviting and timeless, rather than making a bold fashion statement.
Quality & Construction
Lane has a stronger reputation for consistent quality and durability, particularly in its seating. The brand is known for using solid hardwood frames in its sofas and recliners, as well as high-density foam cushions that resist sagging over time. This makes their furniture a solid choice for high-traffic areas like family living rooms.
Ashley Furniture's quality is more variable and often corresponds directly to the price tag. Their lowest-priced items commonly use engineered wood (like MDF or particleboard) and basic fabrics that may not hold up as well with heavy use. However, their mid-tier collections offer better materials and more robust construction that competes more directly with other mid-range brands.
Product Selection
There's no contest here: Ashley's selection is vast and covers practically every home furnishing category imaginable. From mattresses and rugs to office chairs and patio sets, you can furnish your entire home from their catalog. This one-stop-shop approach is a huge advantage for people who want a convenient and cohesive shopping experience.
Lane offers a more focused product line, with a clear specialization in living room seating. While they sell bedroom and dining furniture, their core strength and widest selection are found in their recliners, motion sofas, and stationary sectionals.
Shopping Experience
Ashley Furniture provides a more streamlined, modern shopping experience with a user-friendly website filled with design tools, customer reviews, and frequent online-only sales. They also operate a massive network of "Ashley HomeStore" showrooms nationwide, making it easy to see products in person.
Lane Furniture is primarily sold through partner retailers, both online and in physical stores across the country. While their website showcases their collections, the final purchase experience - including delivery, returns, and customer service - will depend on the specific retailer you buy from.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right brand comes down to whether you prioritize timeless comfort and durability or trendy styles and rock-bottom prices.
Choose Lane Furniture if:
- You prioritize durability and are willing to pay a little more for a piece that will last for years.
- Comfort is your top priority - you're looking for the perfect cozy recliner or plush sofa for family movie nights.
- Your home decor style is classic, traditional, or transitional.
- You're furnishing a multi-generational home and need furniture that can withstand heavy, daily use by kids and pets.
Choose Ashley Furniture if:
- Your primary concern is staying on a tight budget.
- You enjoy updating your decor with the latest interior design trends.
- You want a huge variety of styles and products to choose from for every room in your house.
- You're furnishing a first home, apartment, or a secondary space like a guest room or playroom.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Lane or Ashley Furniture cheaper?
Ashley Furniture is generally cheaper, offering many items at very low entry-level prices. Lane is also an affordable brand but tends to be priced slightly higher, reflecting its focus on more durable construction.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Lane is widely considered to have more consistent quality and durability, especially regarding its upholstered seating with hardwood frames. The quality of Ashley furniture can vary significantly from its low-cost lines to its more premium collections.
Which is better for families?
For high-traffic family rooms, Lane is often the preferred choice due to its reputation for sturdy construction, durable mechanisms in its recliners, and comfortable, long-lasting cushion support.
What style of furniture does Lane sell?
Lane focuses on classic American styles, including traditional, transitional, and casual designs. Their pieces are built for comfort and timeless appeal rather than following short-term trends.
What style of furniture does Ashley sell?
Ashley offers an extensive variety of styles to suit almost any taste, from contemporary and modern to rustic farmhouse, industrial, and classic. They are known for keeping their catalog current with popular design trends.
Does Lane Furniture make good recliners?
Yes, recliners and motion furniture are Lane's specialty. They are well-regarded in the industry for their comfort, smooth reclining mechanisms, and durable design.
Is Ashley Furniture good for a first apartment?
Absolutely. Ashley's unbeatable affordability, wide range of styles, and various compact furniture options make it an extremely popular and practical choice for furnishing a first apartment or starter home.
Where are Lane and Ashley Furniture sold?
Lane is sold through a national network of furniture retailers and their showrooms. Ashley Furniture is sold online, through third-party retailers, and in their own branded "Ashley HomeStore" locations across the country.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
