KraftMaid offers premium, highly customizable cabinetry known for its solid wood construction and professional installation, whereas IKEA provides affordable, ready-to-assemble cabinets with a modern, minimalist style designed for DIY projects. The fundamental difference lies in KraftMaid's bespoke, high-end approach versus IKEA's budget-friendly, mass-market, self-serve model.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right cabinetry brand for your kitchen renovation.
KraftMaid: The Premium Custom Cabinetry Choice
KraftMaid is a leading American cabinetry brand that specializes in high-quality, semi-custom kitchen and bath cabinets. Their brand is built on craftsmanship, offering a massive array of styles, finishes, and organizational features. KraftMaid is sold exclusively through authorized dealers and home improvement stores, where professional designers help customers create a tailored kitchen layout that meets their exact specifications and style preferences.
- Product mix: Semi-custom and custom cabinetry for kitchens and bathrooms with a wide range of storage solutions, decorative enhancements, and hardware.
- Style/vibe: Extremely versatile, covering everything from traditional and rustic to transitional and modern. The emphasis is on personalization to match any home's decor.
- Price point: Mid-range to luxury. Expect to pay between $200 to $1,200 per linear foot. A complete kitchen renovation with KraftMaid cabinetry typically ranges from $15,000 to $50,000+.
- Quality: Known for durability, using solid wood and plywood construction. Features like dovetail joints and soft-close hardware come standard, ensuring cabinets last for decades.
- Customization: This is KraftMaid's main strength. They offer an extensive selection of door styles, wood types, finishes (painted, stained, glazed), and hardware, plus customizable sizes to fit unique spaces perfectly.
- Shopping experience: A hands-on, guided process. Customers work with designers at showrooms to plan their layout, select finishes, and finalize their order. It's a high-touch process focused on expert advice.
- Sustainability: The company promotes responsible sourcing of wood and offers eco-friendly finishes. Their dedication to durability also means a longer product life, reducing waste.
KraftMaid is for homeowners planning a significant renovation who are willing to invest in high-quality, long-lasting cabinetry tailored specifically to their home and style.
Shop KraftMaid: kraftmaid.com
IKEA: The Affordable DIY Cabinetry Solution
IKEA is a global household name recognized for its affordable, stylish, and functional ready-to-assemble (RTA) furniture. Their SEKTION kitchen system offers a modular and flexible approach to cabinetry, making modern design accessible to budget-conscious renovators. The brand's model is centered on DIY assembly, allowing customers to save significantly on labor costs.
- Product mix: Full home furnishings, with a specialization in the modular SEKTION kitchen cabinet system, including frames, doors, drawer fronts, and organizational inserts.
- Style/vibe: Predominantly modern, Scandinavian, and minimalist. They offer clean lines, flat-panel doors, and a selection of neutral and wood-effect finishes.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Individual base cabinets can start around $50 to $200. A complete small to medium-sized IKEA kitchen can often be purchased for under $5,000.
- Quality: Functional and reliable for the price point. Cabinets are made from particleboard and fiberboard with laminate or veneer finishes. While not as robust as solid wood, they hold up well in typical residential use.
- Customization: While not custom in the traditional sense, the SEKTION system is highly modular. You can mix and match boxes, fronts, and hardware to create a personalized layout within their standard sizing.
- Shopping experience: A streamlined self-serve process. Customers can use IKEA's free online planning tool, visit a warehouse-style store to see displays, and then purchase the flat-packed components to take home the same day.
- Delivery & assembly: Designed for an approachable DIY experience. All components are flat-packed with instructions. For those who prefer assistance, IKEA also offers delivery and professional installation services for an additional fee.
- Sustainability: A core brand principle. IKEA invests in responsible wood sourcing, uses renewable and recycled materials, and works toward a goal of being climate positive.
IKEA is the ideal choice for budget-focused renovators, DIYers, landlords, and anyone who loves a clean, modern aesthetic and wants a functional kitchen solution quickly.
Shop IKEA: ikea.com
KraftMaid vs. IKEA Comparison
Price Comparison
The price difference between KraftMaid and IKEA is the most significant factor for most shoppers. KraftMaid operates in the mid-to-luxury market, where a complete kitchen project often exceeds $20,000. This cost reflects the higher-quality materials, extensive customization options, and the inclusion of professional design and installation services through their dealer network.
IKEA, on the other hand, is the clear winner for budget projects. Its affordable RTA model means a full set of cabinets can be acquired for between $2,000 and $7,000. This price advantage makes it possible to completely remodel a kitchen for a fraction of what a semi-custom project would cost, especially for those willing to assemble and install the cabinets themselves.
Quality & Materials
KraftMaid builds its cabinets for longevity. They primarily use solid hardwood and durable plywood for cabinet boxes, features that resist warping and hold up better over decades. You'll find premium details like dovetail drawer construction and robust soft-close mechanisms, which contribute to a sturdier, more premium feel.
IKEA uses particleboard for their cabinet frames - a cost-effective and stable material but one that is more susceptible to water damage and not as durable as plywood. Their doors and drawer fronts are made from various materials, including fiberboard with foil, lacquer, or wood veneer finishes. While perfectly functional for everyday life, they do not possess the same heirloom quality or heft as KraftMaid's products.
Style & Aesthetic
Your design preference plays a huge role here. KraftMaid can cater to virtually any style. Whether you want a classic farmhouse kitchen with intricate Shaker doors, a traditional kitchen with glazed finishes, or a sleek contemporary look, their vast catalog has an option. The ability to customize colors and finishes achieves a truly bespoke look.
IKEA is much more focused, primarily offering modern European and Scandinavian aesthetics. Their designs feature flat-panel or simple Shaker-style doors, sleek lines, and often integrated hardware. While they offer fewer styles, their look is timeless, clean, and incredibly popular in modern interior design. For fans of minimalism, IKEA is a perfect fit.
Fit & Sizing
For kitchens with unusual dimensions, sloped ceilings, or unique layouts, KraftMaid is the superior choice. As a semi-custom brand, they offer cabinets in a much wider range of heights, widths, and depths. This flexibility allows designers to create a seamless, integrated layout that maximizes every inch of space without awkward gaps or fillers.
IKEA's system is based on a set of standard modular sizes. While this works well for most typical rectangular kitchens, it can be challenging to fit into non-standard spaces. Homeowners may need to get creative with fillers or custom trim pieces to make the modular system work in an older or architecturally unique home.
Shopping Experience
The shopping journeys are polar opposites. Choosing KraftMaid involves a partnership with a professional. You'll visit a showroom, touch the materials, and work with a kitchen designer who manages measurements, ordering, and coordinating installation. It’s a full-service experience designed to minimize stress for the homeowner, though lead times can be several weeks to months.
The IKEA model is designed for empowerment and self-service. You plan your kitchen with their 3D tool, travel to a store to see the products, and purchase your flat-packed items. Assembly is done by you, creating a sense of ownership over the project. It's fast and direct but requires more effort and planning from the buyer.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your budget, timeline, desired level of involvement, and design priorities. Both brands are leaders in their respective markets for a reason.
Choose KraftMaid if:
- You have a healthy budget and view your kitchen as a long-term investment.
- You want high-quality solid wood materials and premium construction.
- Your dream kitchen has a specific traditional, transitional, or custom style.
- You prefer to work with a professional designer and have the cabinets installed for you.
Choose IKEA if:
- Your primary concern is sticking to a tight budget.
- You enjoy DIY projects and are comfortable assembling and installing cabinetry.
- You love modern, minimalist, or Scandinavian design.
- You need a quick and functional cabinetry solution for a rental, flip, or secondary space.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is KraftMaid or IKEA cheaper?
IKEA is significantly cheaper than KraftMaid. A full IKEA kitchen can often be purchased for under $5,000, while a KraftMaid kitchen typically starts around $15,000 and can go much higher depending on the scope of customization.
Which has better quality furniture?
KraftMaid has better quality furniture from a materials and construction standpoint. Their use of solid wood and plywood, along with dovetail joinery, makes their cabinets more durable and long-lasting than IKEA's particleboard-based system.
Are KraftMaid cabinets worth the investment?
For homeowners who prioritize durability, high-end materials, and custom design, KraftMaid cabinets are generally considered a worthwhile investment that can increase home value and last for decades.
What are IKEA cabinets made of?
IKEA cabinet boxes are primarily made of particleboard with a melamine foil finish. The doors and drawer fronts come in a variety of materials, including fiberboard with foil or lacquered paint finishes, as well as wood veneers.
Can you DIY a kitchen with KraftMaid?
While technically possible, KraftMaid cabinets are not designed for DIY installation. They are heavier and more complex than RTA cabinets and are intended to be installed by skilled professionals to ensure a proper fit and finish.
How long do IKEA kitchens last?
With proper assembly and care, an IKEA kitchen can last 10 to 15 years or more. While not as durable as solid wood cabinets, they hold up well to normal wear and tear. IKEA also offers a 25-year limited warranty on its SEKTION kitchen system.
How can you customize IKEA cabinets further?
A large market of third-party companies, like Semihandmade and Kitch, specialize in making custom doors and drawer fronts specifically for IKEA's SEKTION cabinet boxes. This allows homeowners to get a custom look with the affordable IKEA framework.
Do both brands offer design services?
Yes, but in different ways. KraftMaid's process is built around professional design services available at their dealer showrooms. IKEA offers a free online 3D planning tool and in-store consultants who can help you refine your layout, but the experience is more self-directed.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
