The KitchenAid Toaster and the Smeg Toaster are two top contenders in the premium appliance market, but they appeal to very different shopper priorities. KitchenAid focuses on classic design, workhorse durability, and accessible mid-range pricing, while Smeg is a design-first brand, offering iconic 1950s retro aesthetics and vibrant colors at a higher, more boutique price point.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right toaster for your countertop.
KitchenAid Toaster
KitchenAid toasters are known for their reliable performance and sturdy construction, carrying the brand's reputation from its famous stand mixers. They feature a timeless, slightly retro look that blends seamlessly into most kitchen decor without being overpowering. These toasters are built for daily use, prioritizing function and longevity over fashion-forward design.
- What it is: A durable, high-performance toaster from a well-respected American brand known for creating kitchen workhorses.
- Key features: Wide slots for bagels and thick bread, extra high-lift levers to easily retrieve smaller items, multiple browning controls, and a straightforward user interface.
- Price: Mid-range, typically falling between $80 and $150.
- Dimensions: Varies by model, but a typical 2-slice toaster is around 8-10 inches wide and 8 inches high, fitting comfortably on most countertops.
- Materials/Construction: Built with durable stainless steel and high-quality plastic components designed for longevity and consistent heat performance.
- Style: Classic and utilitarian with a soft retro influence. Available in a smaller range of colors, usually including Empire Red, Onyx Black, and Stainless Steel.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price, renowned for durability and long-term reliability, versatile style fits many kitchens, easy to match with other KitchenAid appliances.
- Cons: Limited color palette compared to Smeg, design is more functional than eye-catching, may lack the niche "statement piece" appeal.
This toaster is a great match for home cooks who value reliability and a classic look and want an appliance that will perform consistently for years.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/countertop-appliances/toasters.html
Smeg Toaster
Smeg toasters are iconic pieces of kitchen art, instantly recognizable for their 1950s retro design, curved lines, and explosion of color options. This Italian brand positions its appliances as much as decor as they are functional tools. A Smeg toaster is for someone who wants to make a style statement and appreciates the blend of high-end aesthetics with modern technology.
- What it is: A premium, design-focused toaster celebrated for its vibrant retro aesthetic that serves as a kitchen centerpiece.
- Key features: Distinctive 1950s design, a wide array of vibrant and pastel colors, chrome accents, and dedicated functions including reheat, defrost, and bagel settings.
- Price: Premium, with most models priced between $150 and $250.
- Dimensions: Generally compact and stylized, with a 2-slice model measuring around 8 inches wide and 8 inches high.
- Materials/Construction: Meticulously built with a powder-coated steel body, polished chrome base, and high-quality internal components for a sturdy, premium feel.
- Style: Unmistakably retro vintage, inspired by the 1950s. Available in an extensive palette including Pastel Green, Pink, Cream, and bold Red.
- Pros: A beautiful design statement that elevates kitchen decor, wide range of unique colors, high-quality feel and materials, performs its toasting job very well.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than other high-performing toasters, the bold style might not suit all kitchen designs, primary value is placed on aesthetics.
This appliance works best for design-savvy individuals who are willing to invest in a pop of color and personality for their kitchen countertop.
Shop this product: smeg.com/products/toasters
KitchenAid Toaster vs. Smeg Toaster Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
This is the most significant point of difference. The Smeg Toaster is a purpose-built style icon. Its 1950s-inspired curves and vast color options - from pastel pink to Racing Green - are meant to be a focal point on your counter. It's an intentional piece of decor.
The KitchenAid Toaster, by contrast, has a timeless and functional aesthetic. Its look is classic and understated, designed to blend into the kitchen rather than stand out. While available in colors like the brand's signature Empire Red, its palette is much more restrained and intended to match a broader range of styles without causing a fuss.
Materials & Construction
Both toasters are built to a high standard, but their material choices reflect their design philosophy. KitchenAid toasters use a combination of stainless steel and heavy-duty plastics to create a robust, resilient appliance ready for years of daily use. They feel sturdy and reliable in hand.
Smeg emphasizes premium finishes. Its powder-coated steel body and polished chrome accents give it significant heft and a luxurious feel. The knobs and lever feel satisfying to use, aligning with the premium price and experience the brand is selling.
Price & Value
KitchenAid offers an excellent return on investment. With prices typically under $150, you are paying for durable construction, reliable heating elements, and a brand name trusted for generations. The value is rooted in performance and longevity.
Smeg commands a premium price, from $150 to $250. With a Smeg, you are investing in impeccable Italian design and an iconic aesthetic as much as you are in a toaster. The value lies in its dual function as both a high-performing appliance and a piece of kitchen decor.
Who Each One Works Best For
The KitchenAid toaster is for the pragmatist. This user wants a toaster that works flawlessly every morning, is easy to clean, will last for a decade, and blends quietly into their kitchen landscape. They value reliability and a fair price above all.
The Smeg toaster is for the stylist. This user sees their kitchen as an extension of their personal style and wants every item on display to reflect that. They are happy to pay more for an appliance that brings them joy to look at and use, serving as a conversation piece that also makes perfect toast.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both of these toasters make excellent toast, so the decision really comes down to your priorities, budget, and personal style.
Choose the KitchenAid Toaster if:
- You prioritize performance, reliability, and durability for everyday use.
- Your budget is in the $100-$150 range and you want the best functional value.
- You prefer a classic, understated look that complements your kitchen decor without demanding attention.
- You already own KitchenAid appliances and want a coordinated set.
Choose the Smeg Toaster if:
- Aesthetics are your top priority and you want an appliance that doubles as decor.
- You love bold, retro-inspired design and a specific color to match your kitchen's personality.
- You see appliances as a long-term style investment and are willing to pay a premium for it.
- You want a beautiful conversation-starter sitting on your countertop.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between a KitchenAid and a Smeg toaster?
The main difference is their core philosophy. KitchenAid focuses on function and durability with a classic design. Smeg prioritizes iconic retro aesthetics and brand prestige, commanding a higher price for its unique style.
Is the Smeg toaster worth the price?
If you value design and see your toaster as a piece of decor, yes, it's worth it. It’s well-made and performs reliably. But if you're only focused on toasting performance, a KitchenAid offers comparable results for significantly less money.
Which toaster is more durable?
Both are well-built with metal bodies. However, KitchenAid has built its entire brand reputation on producing long-lasting, workhorse appliances, and their toasters follow that tradition. Smeg's build is premium, but you'll need to be mindful of protecting its glossy enamel finish from scratches.
Do KitchenAid toasters come in different colors?
Yes, but the selection is much smaller than Smeg's. KitchenAid typically offers its products in classic colors like Empire Red, Onyx Black, Contour Silver, and Pistachio, which are designed to be versatile.
Can you get a 4-slice version of these toasters?
Absolutely. Both KitchenAid and Smeg offer 2-slice and 4-slice versions of their popular toaster models to accommodate families and larger households.
Is one toaster brand better for bagels?
Both brands design their toasters with wide slots that easily accommodate bagels and thicker artisan breads. Many models also include a specific "bagel" setting that toasts the cut side while gently warming the back.
How do you clean these toasters?
Both models come with a removable slide-out crumb tray at the bottom for easy disposal of crumbs. For the exterior, wipe with a soft, damp cloth. Avoid using abrasive sponges or harsh chemicals, which could damage the finish, especially on the Smeg's colored enamel.
Which toaster makes better toast?
When it comes to the final product, both toasters are excellent. They toast bread evenly and consistently across their multiple browning settings. The choice isn't about which one toasts better, but which appliance better fits your budget and style.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
