KitchenAid is recognized for its stylish, premium appliances that feature advanced cooking technology and a design-forward aesthetic, making it a top choice for serious home chefs. In contrast, Maytag builds its reputation on durability and straightforward, heavy-duty performance, appealing to budget-conscious families who need reliable, hardworking appliances that last.
Let's compare these two household names to help you decide which brand is right for your kitchen.
KitchenAid: The Premium Choice for Home Chefs
KitchenAid has established itself as a premium brand for culinary enthusiasts, famous for its iconic stand mixer and a full suite of high-performance major kitchen appliances. It targets consumers who view the kitchen as a creative workspace and prioritize style, innovative features, and professional-grade results. Their products blend timeless design with modern technology, making them both a statement piece and a functional workhorse.
- Product mix: Full range of large kitchen appliances including refrigerators, wall ovens, cooktops, ranges, and dishwashers. KitchenAid is also a leader in countertop appliances like their famous stand mixers, blenders, and food processors.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, modern, and often retro-inspired. Known for clean lines and a commercial-style look, available in signature colors like Empire Red alongside classic stainless steel and other modern finishes.
- Price point: Premium. Stand mixers begin around $300, while major appliances like refrigerators and ranges typically cost between $1,500 and $3,500+, depending on the model and features.
- Quality: Built with high-quality materials such as stainless steel and die-cast metal. The focus is on precision, durability, and a solid feel, backed by comprehensive warranties.
- Dimensions/Sizing: Offers a wide variety of dimensions, including counter-depth refrigerators for a built-in look and various oven and cooktop sizes to fit different kitchen layouts, from compact apartments to large, custom kitchens.
- Sustainability: Many KitchenAid appliances are ENERGY STAR certified, helping to reduce energy consumption and utility costs. The brand is focused on efficiency without sacrificing performance.
For those willing to invest in superior performance and sophisticated design, KitchenAid offers stylish, feature-rich appliances that elevate the home cooking experience.
Shop KitchenAid: kitchenaid.com
Maytag: The Dependable, Hardworking Performer
Maytag is a legendary American brand synonymous with dependability and power. Positioned as the go-to choice for homeowners who need appliances that can handle the rigors of daily family life, Maytag focuses on robust construction, simple controls, and long-lasting reliability. Their no-fuss approach appeals to practical buyers who prioritize function and durability over elaborate features or trendy designs.
- Product mix: Extensive line of home appliances including washers, dryers, refrigerators, dishwashers, and ranges. Best known for their powerful laundry machines and durable kitchen solutions.
- Style/vibe: Utilitarian and robust. The design is straightforward and traditional, with an emphasis on sturdiness. While many models are available in stainless steel, the overall aesthetic prioritizes function over form.
- Price point: Affordable to mid-range. Most major Maytag appliances fall within the $500 to $1,500 price range, offering excellent value for their durability and performance.
- Quality: Known for its durable, heavy-duty components and solid build. Maytag appliances are engineered to be tough and are famously backed by a 10-year limited parts warranty on key components like compressors and motors.
- Dimensions/Sizing: Produces appliances in standard industry sizes designed to easily fit into most existing kitchen and laundry room configurations. This makes replacement and installation simple and hassle-free.
- Shopping Experience: Widely available at major big-box retailers like Lowe's and Home Depot, making them easy to shop for and purchase.
Maytag delivers reliable, American-built appliances that offer peace of mind for buyers seeking straightforward performance and longevity at a great price.
Shop Maytag: maytag.com
KitchenAid vs. Maytag Comparison
Price Comparison
The most significant difference between the two brands is price. KitchenAid operates firmly in the premium category. You're paying for advanced features, high-end materials, and a sophisticated design, with refrigerators and ranges often costing well over $2,000. It's an investment in a certain kitchen lifestyle.
Maytag is the clear winner on affordability. By focusing on core performance and durability over cutting-edge tech or designer finishes, Maytag offers refrigerators, ranges, and dishwashers for a fraction of KitchenAid's cost - often in the $500 to $1,500 range. For shoppers focused on value and reliability, Maytag provides great performance for the money.
Style &, Aesthetic
KitchenAid leads in design and aesthetics. The brand offers a cohesive visual collection with commercial-style handles, sleek lines, and a wide array of colors and finishes. Their appliances are designed to be a focal point in the kitchen, appealing to homeowners who want a polished, coordinated look.
Maytag appliances are designed to be workhorses, not show ponies. The aesthetic is practical, sturdy, and somewhat traditional. While modern stainless steel finishes are common, the design language is more about robustness than high style. They blend into the kitchen rather than standing out.
Quality &, Construction
Both brands are owned by Whirlpool Corporation and are known for producing quality appliances, but they emphasize different aspects of it. KitchenAid's quality is found in its premium materials, precision engineering, and innovative cooking technologies. Their appliances feel solid and provide fine-tuned performance for discerning cooks.
Maytag's quality is all about raw durability and longevity. The brand uses heavy-duty motors, belts, and springs to ensure their machines can handle heavy loads and frequent use. Their famous 10-year limited parts warranty is a testament to the brand's confidence in its core components, offering long-term peace of mind.
Product Selection
Both brands offer a full suite of major kitchen appliances. KitchenAid's standout advantage is its unmatched excellence in countertop appliances, especially the iconic stand mixer, which sets the standard in the industry. For a baker or passionate cook, KitchenAid's ecosystem of small appliances is a major draw.
Maytag, while strong in kitchen appliances, is equally dominant in the laundry room. Their washers and dryers are legendary for their power and dependability. If you're outfitting both your kitchen and laundry room and want consistent, hardworking machines, Maytag offers a complete home solution.
Sustainability &, Ethics
Both brands are committed to energy efficiency, with many products earning the ENERGY STAR certification. KitchenAid often highlights its modern, energy-efficient technologies as part of its premium features package.
Maytag's vision of sustainability is closely tied to its ethos of durability. By building appliances that last longer, the brand helps reduce unnecessary replacements and landfill waste. Their focus on creating products that can be repaired rather than discarded is an inherently eco-friendly practice.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal priorities in the kitchen: your budget, your cooking style, and your aesthetic preferences.
Choose KitchenAid if:
- You're a passionate home cook or baker who wants professional-grade performance.
- You value a sleek, cohesive design and want your appliances to be a statement piece.
- You're willing to invest in advanced features like precision temperature control and versatile cooking modes.
- You want specific color options to match your kitchen decor.
Choose Maytag if:
- You need an extremely durable and reliable appliance that can stand up to heavy daily use.
- Your top priority is practical performance and longevity over appearance.
- You're on a budget and want the best possible value and a strong warranty.
- You prefer straightforward, easy-to-use controls without complex settings.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is KitchenAid or Maytag more expensive?
KitchenAid is significantly more expensive. It is a premium brand with prices reflecting advanced features, design, and high-end materials. Maytag is a budget- and mid-range brand focused on delivering durable performance at an affordable price.
Which brand has better quality appliances?
Both build quality appliances. KitchenAid's quality is in its premium feel, precision performance, and finish. Maytag's quality is in its rugged, heavy-duty construction designed for longevity and reliability, backed by a 10-year limited parts warranty on key components.
Are KitchenAid and Maytag owned by the same company?
Yes, both KitchenAid and Maytag are owned by the Whirlpool Corporation, which also owns other popular brands like Amana and JennAir. They target different market segments with distinct features and price points.
Which brand has more finish and color options?
KitchenAid offers far more variety in colors and finishes. While Maytag primarily sticks to classics like white, black, and stainless steel, KitchenAid is famous for a broad palette of colors, especially for its stand mixers.
Which brand is better for a family with kids?
Maytag is generally the preferred choice for busy families. Its appliances are built to withstand heavy use, are easy to operate, and come at a family-friendly price point. Their proven durability means they can handle the demands of a hectic household.
Does KitchenAid really make their appliances in the USA?
While components are sourced globally, many KitchenAid appliances, including their celebrated stand mixers, are assembled in the USA. For instance, the stand mixers are assembled in Greenville, Ohio.
Is Maytag still known for the lonely repairman?
The "lonely Maytag repairman" was an iconic advertising campaign highlighting the brand's dependability. While all appliances will eventually need service, Maytag continues to build its brand around reliability and durability to live up to that legacy.
Do both brands offer a strong warranty?
Yes, but in different ways. Both offer standard one-year warranties. Maytag's signature offering is its 10-year limited parts warranty on certain major components like dishwasher racks, range burners, and refrigerator compressors, which provides exceptional long-term peace of mind.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
