The KitchenAid Professional Plus and Hamilton Beach stand mixers serve two very different bakers: KitchenAid offers a powerful, durable, all-metal machine for serious enthusiasts, while Hamilton Beach provides a practical, lightweight, and budget-friendly option for casual users. The difference comes down to build quality, motor power, and price, with the KitchenAid being a premium long-term investment and the Hamilton Beach offering excellent value for basic tasks.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right stand mixer for your kitchen.
KitchenAid Professional Plus Stand Mixer
The KitchenAid Professional Plus is an iconic, high-performance stand mixer built for home bakers who demand power and durability. Featuring a robust motor, all-metal construction, and a large capacity bowl-lift design, it's designed to handle heavy, dense mixtures like bread dough and large batches of cookies with ease, positioning it as a countertop workhorse for serious cooks.
- What it is: A professional-grade, bowl-lift stand mixer designed for heavy-duty home use.
- Key features: Powerful motor, 5 to 6-quart capacity, all-metal construction, bowl-lift design for stability, planetary mixing action for thorough ingredient incorporation, and compatibility with dozens of attachments.
- Price: Typically $400 - $500.
- Dimensions: Roughly 16" tall, 10" wide, and weighs between 25-30 pounds.
- Materials/Construction: Die-cast metal body, high-quality metal gears, and a sturdy stainless steel bowl.
- Style: Classic retro-inspired design available in a wide array of colors, often becoming a visual centerpiece of the kitchen.
- Pros: Extremely powerful for tackling tough doughs. Superior durability and longevity. Large capacity for big batches. Huge range of color options and available attachments.
- Cons: High price point can be a significant investment. Heavy and bulky, making it difficult to move and store. Some users find an overhead cabinet a must-have for safe, secure storage.
This mixer is ideal for frequent bakers and culinary enthusiasts who need a reliable machine that will last for decades and handle any recipe thrown at it.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/professional-plus-series
Hamilton Beach (HD) Stand Mixer
The Hamilton Beach (HD) Stand Mixer is built for everyday home cooks who need a reliable and affordable tool for light-to-moderate mixing tasks. It provides all the basic functions of a stand mixer in a lightweight, compact, and user-friendly package that focuses on practicality and value over premium features, making it perfect for cakes, meringues, and occasional cookie batches.
- What it is: An affordable, lightweight stand mixer for casual and everyday baking needs.
- Key features: 250-450 watt motor, 4 to 5-quart capacity, multiple speed settings, and often includes basic attachments like a flat beater, dough hook, and whisk.
- Price: Generally $70 - $150.
- Dimensions: Around 12-14" tall and weighs under 10 pounds.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily plastic housing with a stainless steel mixing bowl.
- Style: Simple, utilitarian design that prioritizes function. Available in basic colors like black, white, or silver.
- Pros: Very affordable and offers great value. Lightweight and compact for easy storage. Simple to operate for beginners. Sufficient for most common baking recipes.
- Cons: Plastic body is less durable than metal. Less powerful motor may struggle with dense bread doughs. Fewer color and attachment options. Can feel less stable during heavy mixing.
This mixer is suited for budget-conscious buyers, beginners, or those with small kitchens who only bake occasionally and don't require professional-grade power.
Shop this product: hamiltonbeach.com/7-speed-stand-mixer
KitchenAid Professional Plus vs. Hamilton Beach Comparison
Materials & Construction
The difference in build quality is the most significant contrast. The KitchenAid Professional Plus features a die-cast metal body and all-metal gears, giving it incredible durability and stability, which is why these mixers are known to last for decades. Its heft keeps it firmly planted on the counter, even when kneading heavy bread dough.
The Hamilton Beach mixer uses a plastic housing to keep costs down and weight low. While perfectly serviceable for most tasks, it doesn't offer the same long-term durability and may vibrate or move on the counter with thicker mixtures. This build is great for easy storage but is not designed for frequent, heavy-duty use.
Dimensions & Scale
Sizing is a key differentiator for kitchen practicality. The KitchenAid is a substantial appliance, weighing over 25 pounds and standing tall. It's designed to be a permanent countertop fixture. Its 5- to 6-quart bowl is large enough for double batches of cookies or multiple loaves of bread.
Conversely, the Hamilton Beach mixer is much more compact and lightweight, often weighing less than 10 pounds. It's easy to lift and store in a pantry or cupboard, making it a great choice for smaller kitchens or those who don't want appliances cluttering their counters. Its 4-quart bowl is ample for single recipes of cake batter, frostings, and general-purpose mixing.
Style & Aesthetics
KitchenAid has built its brand around style as much as performance. The Professional Plus mixer is famous for its timeless, retro design and comes in a huge spectrum of colors to match any kitchen decor, from a classic Empire Red to a modern Matte Black. It’s treated as much as a statement piece as it is a functional tool.
The Hamilton Beach mixer has a more straightforward, utilitarian look. Designs are simple and functional, usually available in a few basic colors like black, white, or silver. The aesthetic focus is on practicality, not on being a decor centerpiece.
Price & Value
There's a significant price gap between these two mixers. The KitchenAid retails for $400 or more, a serious investment for a home kitchen. However, its value comes from its longevity, power, and versatility - it's a "buy it for life" appliance for many owners. You're paying a premium for professional-grade quality and design.
The Hamilton Beach mixer, typically available for under $150, provides exceptional value for the occasional baker. It capably handles most common baking tasks at a fraction of the cost. While it won't last as long as a KitchenAid under heavy strain, its value proposition for the price is hard to beat for a beginner or casual user.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both stand mixers are excellent tools for home bakers, but they are built for entirely different needs and priorities.
Choose the KitchenAid Professional Plus if:
- You bake frequently, at least several times a month.
- You often make heavy doughs for bread or pizza.
- You want a durable machine that will last for 10, 20, or even 30 years.
- Style is important, and you want an appliance that doubles as kitchen decor.
- You plan to use a wide variety of attachments like pasta makers or meat grinders.
Choose the Hamilton Beach (HD) if:
- You're on a tight budget or are buying your first stand mixer.
- You primarily bake cakes, cookies, or meringues and don't make heavy bread dough often.
- You have limited counter or storage space.
- You need a lightweight mixer that is easy to move and put away.
- You value practicality and affordability over brand prestige and premium materials.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main performance difference between KitchenAid and Hamilton Beach mixers?
The main performance difference is power and stability. A KitchenAid motor is designed to power through stiff bread doughs and large batches without straining. In contrast, a Hamilton Beach mixer has sufficient power for batters, frostings, and light cookie dough but may struggle or overheat with very dense mixtures.
Is the KitchenAid Professional Plus really worth the extra cost?
For dedicated home bakers, yes. Its all-metal construction, powerful motor, and availability of specialized attachments offer long-term value and versatility that cheaper mixers can't match. If you bake multiple times a week, a KitchenAid is a worthwhile investment. If you bake a few times a year, it may be overkill.
Which mixer is better for a small kitchen?
The Hamilton Beach is the clear winner for small kitchens. It's significantly lighter and more compact, making it easy to store in a cabinet or pantry when not in use. The KitchenAid Professional Plus is very heavy and bulky, so it usually requires a permanent spot on the countertop.
Can a Hamilton Beach mixer handle bread dough?
It can knead softer doughs for items like dinner rolls or cinnamon buns, but it may struggle with very dense, low-hydration bread doughs. Users should follow the manufacturer's speed and time recommendations to avoid overheating the motor.
Which brand offers more color options?
KitchenAid is famous for its vast color selection, offering dozens of shades and finishes to coordinate with any kitchen design. Hamilton Beach mixers are typically limited to basic colors like black, white, silver, and occasionally red.
Can I use KitchenAid attachments on a Hamilton Beach mixer?
No, the attachments are not interchangeable. KitchenAid mixers have a universal power hub designed specifically for their line of attachments, an ecosystem that Hamilton Beach does not share.
Which mixer is easier to clean?
Both are relatively easy to clean. Most models from both brands come with a stainless steel bowl that is dishwasher safe, as are the beater and dough hook. However, you should always hand-wash whisks to protect their fine wires.
Is the KitchenAid too heavy to move regularly?
For most people, yes. Weighing between 25 and 30 pounds, the Professional Plus model is designed to be a stationary appliance. If you lack counter space and need to store your mixer after each use, its weight can be a significant drawback.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
