The KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment and the Ninja Creami both make delicious frozen desserts at home, but they work in completely different ways. The KitchenAid is an accessory bowl that attaches to a stand mixer to traditionally churn ice cream, while the Ninja is a standalone countertop appliance that shaves and processes a solid-frozen base into an ultra-creamy texture. This fundamental difference in process affects preparation time, versatility, and the final price.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right frozen dessert maker from KitchenAid or Ninja for your kitchen.
KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment is a clever add-on for anyone who already owns one of the brand's iconic stand mixers. It turns a versatile baking tool into a classic ice cream machine. By simply swapping the mixing bowl for the pre-frozen freezer bowl and adding the dasher attachment, you can churn up to two quarts of traditional ice cream, gelato, or sorbet in under 30 minutes.
- What it is: A freezer bowl and dasher attachment that works with most KitchenAid tilt-head and bowl-lift stand mixers.
- Key features: The 2-quart freezer bowl contains a liquid coolant within its double walls. The included dasher (or paddle) rotates inside the frozen bowl to churn the liquid base, preventing large ice crystals from forming.
- Price: Around $100-$150. This does not include the stand mixer, which must be purchased separately and typically starts at $300.
- Style: Classic, simple design made to complement the timeless look of a KitchenAid stand mixer.
- Materials/Construction: Durable plastic dasher and housing with a double-walled metal freezer bowl.
- Pros: A cost-effective solution for existing KitchenAid mixer owners. Doesn't take up extra counter space since it uses the mixer's base. Produces classic, rich, churn-style ice cream. High-quality construction you expect from the brand.
- Cons: The freezer bowl requires at least 15-24 hours in the freezer before it's ready to use. Can only make one batch at a time before the bowl needs to refreeze completely. Requires the separate purchase of an expensive stand mixer.
This attachment is ideal for loyal KitchenAid users who want to add ice cream making to their mixer's capabilities without buying another separate appliance.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com
Ninja Creami
The Ninja Creami is a compact, powerful, all-in-one appliance dedicated to making a wide variety of frozen treats. Rather than churning a liquid, it uses a unique "Creamify" technology where a high-speed blade shaves and churns a pre-frozen solid base into an incredibly smooth and creamy dessert. This makes it popular for everything from traditional ice cream and gelato to dairy-free sorbets and protein-packed smoothie bowls.
- What it is: A dedicated, standalone countertop machine for making ice cream, sorbet, gelato, milkshakes, and more.
- Key features: Multiple one-touch programs (Ice Cream, Sorbet, Gelato, Lite Ice Cream, Milkshake, Smoothie Bowl, Mix-In). Creamerizer Paddle shaves ice crystals into creamy textures. Comes with pint-sized containers for freezing bases.
- Price: Typically ranges from $250 to $300.
- Style: Modern and compact with a sleek, vertical design and a user-friendly interface.
- Materials/Construction: Main body is plastic, with a robust motor and metal processing components. Pint containers and lids are BPA-free plastic.
- Pros: A versatile, all-in-one unit that doesn't require other equipment. Fast processing time (1-2 minutes). Creates exceptionally smooth, creamy textures. Multiple programs offer great flexibility. Can make multiple batches if you pre-freeze extra pints.
- Cons: A more significant upfront investment. Takes up dedicated counter or cabinet space. The process requires freezing the entire base solid for 24 hours beforehand. Can be very loud during the short processing cycle.
The Ninja Creami is perfect for anyone seeking a convenient, multi-functional appliance that delivers fast results and ultimate control over dessert textures and ingredients.
Shop this product: ninjakitchen.com
KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment vs. Ninja Creami Comparison
Preparation & Process
This is the most significant difference. The KitchenAid attachment follows a traditional method: freeze the large bowl for at least 15 hours, pour in your chilled liquid base, and let the mixer's motor churn it for 20-30 minutes until it reaches a soft-serve consistency. Then, the ice cream usually needs another few hours in the freezer to harden completely.
The Ninja Creami flips this process. You mix your base ingredients directly into one of its pint containers and freeze it solid for 24 hours. Once frozen, you place it in the machine, which then powers a blade down through the frozen puck, shaving and blending it into a ready-to-eat dessert in about 90 seconds. While the ingredient freeze time is similar for both, the Ninja's hands-on "making" time is much faster.
Functionality & Versatility
The KitchenAid attachment excels at one thing: making traditionally churned frozen desserts. It works equally well for ice cream, sorbet, and gelato. Its large 2-quart capacity is also an advantage for making bigger batches for a family.
The Ninja Creami is much more versatile. Out of the box, it offers specific functions for different types of treats, including Lite Ice Cream, Smoothie Bowls, and even Milkshakes that rival a diner's. Its Mix-In function also perfectly incorporates things like cookies or chocolate chips. This extensive functionality makes it a more multi-purpose dessert station.
Price & Value
If you already own a KitchenAid mixer, the attachment is an incredible value at around $100. It unlocks a new function for a device you already have. However, if you don't own the mixer, the total cost for the set would be over $400, making it a serious investment.
The Ninja Creami costs between $250 and $300 and works straight out of the box with no other requirements. For someone starting from scratch, the Creami is the more straightforward and often cheaper all-in-one solution for a dedicated ice cream maker. The value comes from its speed, ease of use, and versatility.
Who Each One Works Best For
The KitchenAid attachment is built for the existing KitchenAid enthusiast - the home baker or dedicated cook who appreciates high-quality standalone tools and wants to expand their mixer's capabilities. It's for someone who feels sentimental about the classic churning process and values the brand's reputation for longevity.
The Ninja Creami is designed for families, health-conscious individuals who create custom protein ice creams, and anyone who prizes convenience and variety. It appeals to users who want creamy, perfect results with minimal fuss and appreciate a purpose-built appliance that excels at multiple tasks.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both devices make excellent frozen desserts, but they are designed for very different users and kitchen workflows.
Choose the KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment if:
- You already own a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer and want an affordable add-on.
- You appreciate the traditional process of churning ice cream and the texture it creates.
- You value multi-functional tools over single-purpose appliances to save counter space.
- You need to make larger batches (up to 2 quarts) at once.
Choose the Ninja Creami if:
- You want a dedicated, all-in-one machine that works right out of the box.
- Speed and simplicity are your top priorities during the final prep stage.
- You plan to make a wide variety of frozen treats, including sorbets, lite ice cream, and smoothie bowls.
- You want incredibly creamy results and the flexibility to re-spin your dessert for perfect texture.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the KitchenAid and Ninja Creami?
The core difference is the process. The KitchenAid attachment churns a liquid base in a frozen bowl to gradually freeze it. The Ninja Creami takes a solid frozen block of ingredients and finely shaves it into a creamy dessert, which is a much faster final processing step.
Do I need a KitchenAid mixer to use the ice cream attachment?
Yes. The ice cream maker is an attachment, not a standalone product. It relies entirely on the motor of a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer to power the dasher that churns the ice cream.
Do you have to pre-freeze anything for the Ninja Creami?
Yes. While you don't freeze the bowl itself, you must mix your liquid ingredients in the Creami's pint container and freeze it for a full 24 hours until it's completely solid before processing.
Which one makes ice cream faster?
The Ninja's final processing to make the ice cream is much faster - around 2 minutes compared to KitchenAid's 20-30 minute churn time. However, both require a mandatory 24-hour freeze period beforehand, so the total time from start to finish is very similar.
Which one is more durable?
Both are made by reputable brands known for quality. The KitchenAid attachment is simpler mechanically, with fewer moving parts, and its longevity relies mostly on the very durable stand mixer base. The Ninja Creami is a more complex appliance with its own high-speed motor, which may be subject to more wear over time with heavy use.
Can the KitchenAid attachment make gelato or sorbet?
Absolutely. The traditional churning method used by the KitchenAid is perfect for making gelato, ice cream, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. You just need to follow a recipe specific to that type of dessert.
Which one produces a creamier texture?
The Ninja Creami is famous for its exceptionally creamy and smooth texture, which results from its unique method of shaving down ice crystals into incredibly fine particles. Many users find it produces a consistency superior to traditionally churned home ice cream.
How much space do they require?
The KitchenAid attachment is just a large bowl and a dasher, which can be stored in a cabinet. However, the stand mixer it relies on has a large footprint on the counter. The Ninja Creami is a tall, narrow appliance that takes up less counter space than a stand mixer but requires dedicated space of its own.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
