Kirkland Signature offers dependable, budget-friendly sheets known for their excellent value, while Brooklinen is a direct-to-consumer brand specializing in luxury bedding with premium materials and stylish designs. The primary difference is cost and quality: Kirkland provides functional, everyday comfort for under $70 a set, whereas Brooklinen delivers a high-end, hotel-like experience starting at around $150.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right sheets for your bed.
Kirkland Sheets: The Practical, Budget-Friendly Choice
As Costco's private label, Kirkland Signature is known for delivering solid quality at a competitive price, and its sheet sets are no exception. They are designed for budget-conscious shoppers - from families to students - who need reliable, comfortable, and durable bedding without the luxury price tag. Sold exclusively at Costco, these sheets prioritize function and value over trendy designs.
- Product mix: Primarily focuses on sheet sets, offering various fabric types including 100% cotton (often Supima cotton), microfiber, and seasonal flannel options.
- Style/vibe: Functional and straightforward. The color palette is typically limited to basic solids like white, gray, beige, and light blue, fitting easily into any simple bedroom decor.
- Price point: Highly affordable. Queen sets generally range from $50–$70, offering one of the best values on the market for their quality level.
- Quality: Good, especially for the price. The cotton used is often high-quality, like Supima, which is known for its strength and softness. However, they aren't on the same luxury level as more premium brands.
- Fit & Sizing: Standard sizing that fits most mattresses, including deeper ones. The fit is generally good but may not feel as snug or tailored as luxury alternatives.
- Shopping Experience: Only available for purchase in Costco warehouses or on Costco.com. A Costco membership is typically required.
- Return policy: Backed by Costco’s famously generous return policy, which allows you to return products at virtually any time if you're not satisfied.
Kirkland sheets provide a comfortable and long-lasting bedding solution for anyone prioritizing low cost and practicality over high-end style.
Shop Kirkland Sheets: costco.com
Brooklinen: The Direct-to-Consumer Luxury Bedding
Brooklinen has made a name for itself as a leading online brand for "internet-famous" luxury bedding, aiming to provide high-end quality without the traditional retail markup. The brand’s sheets are beloved for their premium materials, exceptional comfort, and modern aesthetic. They appeal to design-conscious shoppers who are willing to invest in their sleep experience and want sheets that are both durable and beautiful.
- Product mix: A wide range of bedding made from top-tier materials like long-staple cotton, linen, TENCEL™, and cashmere. They offer multiple weaves, including crisp percale and silky-smooth sateen.
- Style/vibe: Modern, stylish, and minimalist. Brooklinen offers a curated selection of core colors, limited-edition seasonal shades, and subtle patterns that can elevate any bedroom's look.
- Price point: Mid-range to luxury. A queen Classic Core Sheet Set typically starts around $150–$200, representing a significant investment compared to Kirkland.
- Quality: Excellent. By using long-staple cotton and other premium fibers, their sheets are softer, more breathable, and more durable, often getting better with each wash.
- Customization: Offers the ability to build your own bundle, mixing and matching colors and fabrics to create a personalized bedding set.
- Sustainability: Committed to ethical manufacturing and sustainable practices, with many products having OEKO-TEX Standard 100 certification, ensuring they are free from harmful chemicals.
- Return policy: Offers a generous 365-day return or exchange window, allowing you plenty of time to decide if the sheets are right for you.
Brooklinen provides a premium sleep experience for those who value superior materials, modern design, and long-term durability in their bedding.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Kirkland Sheets vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a stark price difference between these two brands. Kirkland sheets are a clear winner on budget, with queen sets available for $50-$70. This phenomenal pricing makes them highly accessible for daily use, guest rooms, or anyone furnishing a home on a tight budget.
Brooklinen operates in a different tier, with its most popular queen sets starting around $150. This higher price reflects the premium long-staple cotton, meticulous craftsmanship, trendy color options, and direct-to-consumer brand experience. While significantly more expensive, many customers find the investment worthwhile for the superior comfort and style.
Quality & Materials
Kirkland sheets punch above their weight in quality, often featuring 100% Supima cotton, a type of pima cotton known for its long fibers that create a soft and durable fabric. They are sturdy, hold up well to frequent washing, and provide reliable comfort for everyday use. While impressive for the price, they don't have the same buttery-soft or airy feel as true luxury linens.
Brooklinen exclusively uses long-staple cotton for its signature percale and sateen sheets, which results in a noticeably softer, smoother, and more breathable fabric. These sheets are designed to last for years and often become softer over time. Their linen and TENCEL™ offerings provide even more options for different sleep preferences, from crisp and cool to silky and drapey.
Style & Aesthetic
Kirkland's design philosophy is purely functional. Sheets come in a handful of basic, solid colors designed to be inoffensive and practical. They get the job done but won't be a statement piece in your bedroom design.
Brooklinen places a strong emphasis on style. Their color palette includes timeless neutrals as well as limited-edition seasonal shades and subtle, modern patterns. The overall aesthetic is clean, sophisticated, and aligns with contemporary bedroom trends. If making your bed look as good as it feels is a priority, Brooklinen has a clear advantage.
Shopping Experience
Shopping for Kirkland sheets requires a Costco membership and either a trip to the warehouse or an online order. The experience is no-frills and transaction-focused. The main benefit is Costco’s legendary customer-friendly return policy, which essentially removes any risk from the purchase.
Brooklinen offers a classic e-commerce experience with a beautiful website, detailed product guides, extensive customer reviews, and bundles that let you customize your bedding. Their 365-day return policy is exceptionally generous for the bedding industry, giving you a full year to test the products.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your budget and what you value most in your bedding.
Choose Kirkland Sheets if:
- You are on a strict budget but still want good quality.
- You need durable, workhorse sheets for a kid's room or guest bed.
- You have a Costco membership and prioritize convenience and value.
- You prefer simple, practical bedding and don't care about designer colors.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want a luxurious, hotel-quality feel when you get into bed.
- Style, color, and bedroom aesthetic are important to you.
- You are investing in a "forever" set of sheets and prize longevity and softness.
- You are a hot sleeper and want breathable options like percale or linen.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Kirkland or Brooklinen cheaper?
Kirkland is significantly cheaper. A queen set of Kirkland sheets typically costs $50-$70, while a comparable set from Brooklinen starts at around $150. You can often buy two or three sets of Kirkland sheets for the price of one Brooklinen set.
Which has better quality sheets?
Brooklinen has better quality sheets. They use superior materials like long-staple cotton, which creates a softer, more breathable, and longer-lasting fabric. While Kirkland's quality is excellent for its price point (often using Supima cotton), Brooklinen's materials and construction are definitively more premium.
Are Kirkland sheets soft?
Yes, Kirkland cotton sheets are known for being soft and comfortable, especially considering their low price. However, they may not achieve the same silky-smooth or buttery-soft feel as the premium fabrics used by Brooklinen.
Are Brooklinen sheets worth the money?
For many people, yes. If you value a luxurious sleep experience, superior comfort, and appreciate stylish design, Brooklinen sheets are a worthwhile investment. Their durability also means they will likely last longer than cheaper alternatives, providing better long-term value.
Which sheets are better for hot sleepers?
Brooklinen is generally a better choice for hot sleepers because they offer a wider range of breathable fabrics. Their Classic Percale sheets are renowned for being crisp, cool, and airy, and their linen sheets are also excellent for temperature regulation.
Can you return sheets to both stores?
Yes, and both brands have fantastic return policies. Costco offers a near-unconditional satisfaction guarantee, allowing you to return Kirkland sheets at almost any time. Brooklinen offers a 365-day return or exchange window, giving you ample time to be sure you love your sheets.
Where are Kirkland sheets made?
The manufacturing country for Kirkland sheets can vary by product and year, but many of their popular cotton sheet sets are made in India, a country known for high-quality textile production.
Does Brooklinen have sales?
Yes, Brooklinen typically holds major sales a few times a year, most notably during its Anniversary Sale in the spring and during Black Friday/Cyber Monday. These events are the best times to purchase their products at a discount.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
