Keepsake is designed for those who want high-quality, professionally framed photos with a timeless, classic aesthetic using materials like real wood and shatterproof glass. In contrast, Mixtiles focuses on modern, affordable photo tiles that feature a simple peel-and-stick backing, allowing you to easily create and rearrange photo walls without damaging surfaces.
Let's compare everything you need to know about these two popular photo decor brands to help you choose the right one for your home.
Keepsake: The Timeless Custom Framing Choice
Keepsake specializes in creating personalized, high-quality framed photos and artwork that feel like they're straight from a custom frame shop. The brand is known for its wide range of classic frame styles, sizes, and finishes, making it a favorite for anyone looking to turn cherished memories into long-lasting, heirloom-quality pieces for their walls.
- Product mix: Primary focus is on custom-framed personal photos. They offer a variety of frame materials and styles to create everything from a single statement piece to a full gallery wall.
- Style/vibe: Classic, elegant, and timeless. The designs include everything from simple wood frames to more ornate and metallic options, fitting seamlessly into traditional, transitional, and sophisticated modern decor styles.
- Price point: Mid-range. Prices for framed photos typically start around $50 for smaller sizes and can reach several hundred dollars for larger, more elaborate frames and custom configurations.
- Quality: Made with durable materials, including real wood frames and premium shatterproof glass. The craftsmanship results in a polished, gallery-quality look designed to last for many years.
- Sizing &, Fit: A significant advantage of Keepsake is its range of sizes, from small 8x10 inch frames to large 24x36 inch pieces and beyond. They offer much more flexibility for those needing specific dimensions.
- Shopping Experience: Customization happens on their website, where you can upload photos, select from dozens of frame styles, and preview your final design before purchasing.
Keepsake is the go-to choice for those seeking meaningful, professionally framed photo displays that offer a more permanent and high-end feel.
Shop Keepsake: keepsake.com
Mixtiles: The Modern Peel-and-Stick Solution
Mixtiles created an innovative solution for decorating with personal photos: lightweight, repositionable tiles that stick directly to your walls. Their mission is to make creating photo galleries easy, affordable, and flexible. This damage-free approach makes them a perfect fit for renters, dorm rooms, or anyone who enjoys frequently updating their home decor.
- Product mix: Their core product is a peel-and-stick photo tile. You can order sets of tiles to create a modular, grid-style photo wall that can be added to and rearranged over time.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and contemporary. The frameless design creates a sleek, clean presentation that lets the photos themselves stand out, complementing modern decor styles perfectly.
- Price point: Very affordable. Individual tiles typically cost between $20-$25, with frequent promotions and discounts offered for ordering larger sets, making it easy to cover a wall on a budget.
- Quality: The tiles are made from a lightweight but durable, scratch-resistant material that maintains color vibrancy. While not traditional, they are built for longevity and frequent handling.
- Installation &, Assembly: Mixtiles require no tools, nails, or hooks. Just peel the backing and stick them to the wall. They are designed to be removed and repositioned multiple times without leaving marks or residue.
- Shopping Experience: Their website and mobile app are incredibly user-friendly. You can quickly upload images from your phone or computer, arrange layouts, and preview your wall design.
Mixtiles are ideal for creating personalized photo walls that are easy to install, update, and rearrange as your life and tastes change.
Shop Mixtiles: mixtiles.com
Keepsake vs. Mixtiles Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear difference in price between these two brands. Mixtiles is the budget-friendly choice, with a straightforward pricing model where each tile costs around $20-$25. This makes building a large photo wall accessible and affordable. Discounts on sets make larger orders even more economical.
Keepsake operates in a mid-range price tier, reflecting its investment in high-quality materials and professional craftsmanship. With individual frames starting around $50, the cost can quickly climb for larger pieces or multiple frames. Keepsake is an investment in a permanent, high-end display.
Style &, Aesthetic
Your choice will heavily depend on your home's style. Keepsake offers a timeless, elegant look with its variety of traditional frame options. From warm woods to minimalist metal and gallery whites, their products can complement sophisticated, traditional, or transitional interiors. They are perfect for creating focal points over a sofa or a classic gallery wall in a hallway.
Mixtiles has a distinctively modern and minimalist aesthetic. The simple, uniform, frameless tiles create a clean, cohesive look that is ideal for contemporary spaces. Their style is less about the frame and more about creating a collective photo story in a grid or collage format.
Quality &, Materials
Keepsake delivers traditional quality. They use premium materials like sustainably harvested real wood, acid-free mats to protect photos, and shatterproof glass. The finished product feels substantial, durable, and polished, mimicking the feel of a custom-framed piece from a professional shop.
Mixtiles prioritizes modern functionality. The photo tiles are made of a lightweight, scratch-resistant material engineered for easy handling. Their quality is defined by their brilliant photo printing and, most importantly, the reliable adhesive backing that allows for repositioning without wall damage. It's a different kind of quality - one focused on flexibility rather than permanence.
Sizing &, Fit
Keepsake offers significant versatility in sizing. You can order frames in a wide variety of dimensions, from small accents to large statement art, giving you complete control over scale. This is ideal if you have a specific space to fill, such as a large wall above a fireplace or a narrow vertical spot.
Mixtiles are standardized, typically coming in an 8x8 or 10x10 inch square format. This modular design makes it incredibly easy to plan a layout and expand it later. However, you are limited to this uniform size, which may not work for all applications or design visions.
Shopping Experience
Both brands offer excellent online customization tools, but they cater to different shoppers. Keepsake’s website allows you to dive deep into customization, choosing frame materials, matting options, and seeing detailed previews. It’s perfect for the user who wants to control every detail of their final piece.
The Mixtiles experience, available on desktop and via a mobile app, is built for speed and simplicity. You can upload photos directly from your phone’s camera roll and design a whole wall in minutes. The focus is on a quick, hassle-free process from start to finish.
Sustainability &, Ethics
Both brands show a commitment to responsible practices. Keepsake uses sustainably sourced wood for its frames and focuses on creating durable, long-lasting products that won't end up in a landfill. Their mission is to create heirloom pieces that stand the test of time.
Mixtiles’ sustainability angle comes from its reusable, damage-free design. By eliminating the need for nails and hardware, and creating a product that can be moved and rearranged, they promote a more sustainable decorating practice that reduces waste and property damage.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal style, living situation, and how you want to display your memories.
Choose Keepsake if:
- You want a timeless, heirloom-quality framed photo that feels like a lasting investment.
- Your home has a traditional, classic, or sophisticated modern decor style.
- You are creating a standalone statement piece or need custom sizing options.
- You prefer the polished look of real wood frames, matting, and glass.
Choose Mixtiles if:
- You are a renter or prefer a decoration solution that won’t damage your walls.
- You want an affordable way to create a large gallery wall with many photos.
- You love modern, minimalist design and a clean, frameless look.
- You enjoy frequently rearranging your decor or want a gallery you can easily add to over time.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Keepsake or Mixtiles cheaper?
Mixtiles is significantly cheaper. A single Mixtile costs around $20-$25, while a single framed picture from Keepsake starts at around $50 and goes up with size and frame complexity.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
The brands define quality differently. Keepsake offers better traditional quality with real wood frames, shatterproof glass, and professional craftsmanship for a permanent, heirloom result. Mixtiles offers excellent modern quality, with durable, scratch-resistant tiles and reliable adhesives designed for flexibility and ease of use.
Are Mixtiles easy to remove and reposition?
Yes, that is their main feature. Mixtiles are designed with a special adhesive that sticks securely to most walls but can be peeled off and re-stuck multiple times without losing adhesion or damaging the wall surface.
Can I get custom frame sizes from Keepsake?
While not fully custom to any dimension, Keepsake offers a wide range of standard and large-format sizes, giving you much more control and flexibility than you get with Mixtiles.
Which is better for renters?
Mixtiles is the clear winner for renters. Their peel-and-stick, nail-free design means you can create a beautiful photo wall without risking your security deposit.
Does Keepsake use real glass in their frames?
Keepsake uses a high-quality, lightweight and shatterproof "styrene facing." It's similar to plexiglass or acrylic and offers the same clarity as real glass without the risk of shattering during shipping or in your home.
What style of home decor do these brands work best with?
Keepsake's classic frames are versatile but shine in traditional, transitional, and contemporary homes. Mixtiles' minimalist, frameless look is perfect for modern, Scandinavian, and eclectic interior design styles.
Can you create a large gallery wall with both brands?
Yes, but the process and look are different. Mixtiles is an ideal solution for a modular, grid-style gallery wall that is very easy to install and expand. Keepsake can be used to create a more traditional, curated gallery wall with varying sizes and frame styles, but it requires more planning and traditional wall mounting.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
