Joybird is a direct-to-consumer brand specializing in high-quality, customizable mid-century modern furniture, whereas Wayfair is a massive online marketplace offering an enormous selection of home goods from thousands of brands across every style and budget. The core difference is between a curated brand experience with a specific aesthetic and a vast, all-encompassing retailer where variety is the main attraction.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home decor retailer for your space.
Joybird: The Customizable Mid-Century Modern Brand
Joybird is the go-to destination for shoppers seeking a distinct mid-century modern look combined with the ability to personalize their pieces. With a strong emphasis on quality craftsmanship and sustainable practices, Joybird manufactures its own line of sofas, chairs, beds, and tables, allowing customers to choose from a wide array of fabrics and finishes to create furniture that's uniquely theirs.
- Product mix: Primarily focused on larger furniture pieces like sofas, sectionals, accent chairs, beds, dressers, and dining tables. Limited selection in categories like rugs or lighting.
- Style/vibe:Distinctly mid-century modern. Expect clean lines, tapered legs, tufted details, and bold, retro-inspired color palettes that channel a 1950s and 60s design feel.
- Price point: Mid-range to upper-mid-range. Sofas generally run from $1,200 to $2,500, accent chairs are $600–$1,500, and dining chairs start around $300 each.
- Quality: Known for solid construction. Most pieces feature kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-density foam cushions, and durable upholstery, backed by a lifetime warranty on frames.
- Customization: This is Joybird's biggest strength. Most upholstered items are available in over 50 fabric choices, including performance, velvet, and pet-friendly options, with free swatches to help you decide.
- Return policy:Extremely generous 365-day home trial period, giving you a full year to decide if you love your furniture.
- Delivery & Assembly: Offers in-home delivery, with most made-to-order items taking several weeks to be built and delivered. Simple assembly is sometimes required.
- Sustainability: Strong commitment to sustainability with a focus on sourcing FSC-certified wood, using eco-friendly fabrics, and funding reforestation efforts.
Joybird is ideal for the design-conscious shopper who wants to invest in a specific, high-quality mid-century aesthetic and values personalization options.
Shop Joybird: joybird.com
Wayfair: The One-Stop Shop for Everything Home
Wayfair is a giant online retailer that works like a massive marketplace for home goods, offering millions of products from thousands of different suppliers. From furniture and rugs to appliances and home improvement hardware, Wayfair's business model is built on providing unparalleled selection at every price point, making it a go-to for shoppers looking for variety and convenience.
- Product mix: Practically anything for the home. This includes furniture, rugs, lighting, decor, kitchenware, appliances, and even plumbing fixtures. Wayfair features thousands of brands as well as its own in-house brands like Wade Logan, Birch Lane, and AllModern.
- Style/vibe: Enormous variety spanning every possible aesthetic. You can find farmhouse, traditional, industrial, coastal, modern, bohemian, and minimalist designs all on one site.
- Price point:Extremely broad spectrum. You can find accent chairs under $150, sofas under $500, and entire dining sets for a few hundred dollars, alongside high-end designer pieces costing several thousand.
- Quality: Highly variable. Quality depends entirely on the specific product and manufacturer and can range from cheap particleboard pieces to high-end solid wood furniture. Reading customer reviews is essential.
- Customization: Very limited. Most items are sold as-is, though some products may offer a few pre-set color or finish options. It does not offer the made-to-order customization that Joybird specializes in.
- Sales: Constant sales and promotions. Wayfair is known for its major annual sale, "Way Day," as well as frequent deals on specific categories.
- Return policy:Generally a 30-day return window for most items, but policies can vary by seller. Return shipping fees often apply, especially for large items.
- Delivery & Assembly: Many items ship quickly, sometimes in just a day or two. Most furniture requires self-assembly.
Wayfair excels at offering maximum choice and convenience for shoppers who prioritize budget, fast delivery, and a wide array of styles.
Shop Wayfair: wayfair.com
Joybird vs. Wayfair Comparison
Price Comparison
Joybird operates in a clear mid-range price bracket. You are paying for a well-made, customizable piece with a distinct design. A typical sofa might cost $1,800, which reflects its quality materials and bespoke nature.
Wayfair's pricing is all over the map. You can furnish an entire room on a tight budget or splurge on a luxury centerpiece. While it's easy to find bargains - like a $400 sofa or a $100 accent chair - the value is directly tied to the product's quality. While Wayfair offers more accessibility for entry-level budgets, Joybird's pricing is more transparently linked to consistent quality and customization features.
Quality & Construction
Joybird represents a consistent quality standard. Their use of kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-density foams, and durable fabrics means you can generally expect a well-built piece of furniture designed to last. The company stands behind its products with strong warranties, including a lifetime frame warranty which speaks volumes.
With Wayfair, quality is the biggest variable. Because it's a marketplace, it carries everything from cheaply made, flat-pack furniture to high-end items from respected brands. One sofa might use flimsy particleboard, while another boasts a solid oak frame. Success on Wayfair depends heavily on a shopper's ability to vet products by carefully reading detailed descriptions and, most importantly, scanning dozens of customer photos and reviews.
Style & Aesthetic
Choosing between the two on style is very straightforward. If you love the mid-century modern, retro vibe, and want to create a cohesive home around that theme, Joybird is your expert specialist. Its entire catalog is curated to fit this look, making it easy to coordinate pieces.
In contrast, Wayfair is a stylistic buffet. Its massive inventory caters to shoppers who want to mix and match styles, or who are looking for something very specific that falls outside of a popular trend, such as traditional French country or a sleek industrial piece. Wayfair's portfolio is broad, whereas Joybird's is deep.
Shopping Experience
Shopping with Joybird is a boutique, brand-focused experience. You're guided through a customization process, offered free fabric swatches, and have access to design consultations. The standout feature is its 365-day return policy, which removes nearly all risk from making a large online furniture purchase.
The Wayfair experience is about efficient searching and discovery on a massive scale. Its website has robust filtering tools to help you sift through millions of items. Customer reviews are the backbone of the platform, providing crucial real-world feedback. However, customer service and return processes can be more complicated, as policies can differ between third-party sellers.
Return Policies
Joybird’s 365-day return policy is one of the best in the industry. It gives you an incredible amount of time to live with the furniture and ensure it’s the right fit, which is especially important for a made-to-order item. This creates a high level of trust and confidence for the buyer.
Wayfair’s standard return policy is 30 days for an item in its original condition and packaging. While fair, it's much more restrictive than a brand like Joybird. Furthermore, shoppers are often responsible for return shipping costs, which can be expensive for heavy furniture, making returns a more significant consideration.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to whether you prioritize a specific style and customization or a vast selection and budget-friendliness.
Choose Joybird if:
- Your home aesthetic is firmly planted in mid-century modern design.
- You want to fully customize the fabric and color of your furniture to be unique.
- You are investing in a decor piece and prioritize high-quality materials and durability.
- Sustainability and eco-friendly manufacturing practices are important to you.
- An extremely generous return policy gives you peace of mind for a big purchase.
Choose Wayfair if:
- You are looking for the widest possible selection of styles and brands in one place.
- You are shopping on a tight budget or want to find quick, affordable updates.
- You need an item delivered quickly and are willing to assemble it yourself.
- You enjoy hunting for deals during big sale events.
- You feel comfortable doing your own research by reading customer reviews and product specs to find the best value.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Joybird or Wayfair cheaper?
Wayfair is significantly cheaper for most categories. It offers a vast range of budget-friendly options, with some furniture pieces costing under $200. Joybird is a mid-range brand, with prices that reflect higher-quality materials and customization features.
Which has better quality furniture?
Joybird consistently offers better quality furniture across its entire collection. They use superior materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames and offer strong warranties. Wayfair's quality varies drastically from product to product, making it essential to read reviews to determine an item's durability.
What is the style difference between Joybird and Wayfair?
Joybird specializes exclusively in mid-century modern design. Wayfair, on the other hand, is a marketplace that offers almost every home decor style imaginable, from farmhouse and traditional to contemporary and industrial.
Can you customize furniture at Wayfair like you can at Joybird?
No. Joybird's business model is built around made-to-order customization, allowing you to choose from dozens of fabrics or colors for a single piece. Most items on Wayfair are mass-produced and sold as-is, with only a few pre-selected options available on certain products.
Which has a better return policy?
Joybird has a far superior return policy, offering a 365-day home trial. Wayfair's standard return window is 30 days, and shoppers may have to pay for return shipping on large items.
Is Joybird a brand or a retailer like Wayfair?
Joybird is a direct-to-consumer brand that designs, makes, and sells its own exclusive line of furniture. Wayfair is a marketplace retailer that sells products made by thousands of different third-party brands and manufacturers.
Is Joybird furniture sustainable?
Joybird has a strong focus on sustainability. They use FSC-certified wood and eco-friendly fabrics and partner with conservation groups. While Wayfair has some eco-friendly products, its commitment to sustainability is less consistent across its vast marketplace model.
Which site is better for finding deals and sales?
Wayfair is much better for finding deals. They run sales and promotions constantly, including their famous "Way Day" event. Joybird has sales, but they are generally seasonal and less frequent than Wayfair's deep, always-on discounts.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
