The short answer is: Urban Barn is worth it for shoppers who prioritize trendy design and affordability over long-term durability. Their furniture offers a stylish, contemporary aesthetic for mid-market prices but isn't built to be heirloom quality.
Positioned as a more accessible alternative to brands like West Elm, Urban Barn delivers on-trend pieces that look great. However, materials like engineered wood and standard-density foam cushions mean you can expect visible wear within a few years on high-use items. Here’s a detailed breakdown of their quality and value.
How Is Urban Barn's Quality?
Urban Barn's quality is best described as mid-tier, balancing modern design with mass-market materials and construction. They provide a noticeable step up from budget retailers but don't compete with high-end, solid wood brands.
- Materials: The majority of their furniture, especially case goods like dressers and coffee tables, uses engineered wood (MDF or particleboard) with veneer or laminate finishes. Upholstery is typically made from polyester blends or other synthetic fabrics over foam cushions that have a standard density of around 1.8-2.2 lbs.
- Construction: Frames are often constructed from engineered woods, with joinery relying on common methods like dowels and cam-locks. This is standard for furniture at this price point but lacks the sturdiness of the mortise-and-tenon or dovetail joints found in more premium pieces.
- Durability and Longevity: You can expect Urban Barn furniture to last approximately 5-8 years with moderate use. However, many customers report that high-use items, particularly sofas, show signs of wear like sagging cushions or fabric pilling within 2-3 years.
- Common Complaints: Frequent customer feedback points to cushions that flatten or sag relatively quickly. Other common issues include veneer finishes that can chip or peel over time and tables or chairs that develop a wobble after a couple of years of use.
Is Urban Barn Good Value for the Price?
Urban Barn offers good aesthetic value for the money, but its overall value proposition depends on your expectations for longevity. The initial price is appealing for the style you get, but the potential need for replacement reduces its long-term cost-effectiveness.
Price Positioning
Urban Barn sits squarely in the mid-range market. Sofas typically cost between $700 and $1,500, coffee tables are around $200-$500, and bedroom sets range from $1,200 to $3,000. These prices are often slightly more affordable than direct competitors like West Elm or CB2, who offer similar styles but sometimes use slightly better materials.
What You're Paying For
With Urban Barn, you are primarily paying for design. Their collections are cohesive and follow current interior design trends, which makes it easy to furnish a space with a modern, stylish look without a huge investment. You are paying for in-the-moment style rather than durable, heirloom craftsmanship.
Where You Get Good Value
- Accent Pieces: Items that don't see heavy daily use, such as lamps, wall art, accent chairs, or consoles, often provide excellent value.
- First-Time Buyers: For those furnishing a first apartment or home, Urban Barn offers a complete look for a reasonable price.
- Sale Purchases: Buying during one of their frequent sales or promotional events significantly improves the price-to-quality ratio.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- High-Traffic Furniture: Main family sofas, kitchen tables, or any item that will endure heavy, daily use may not hold up, making them poor long-term investments.
- Heirloom Pieces: If you are looking for furniture to last 10+ years or to pass down, Urban Barn's materials and construction methods are not designed for that level of durability.
- Standard Cushions: Their non-upgraded sofa cushions are a frequent point of complaint and may need replacing or reinforcing after just a few years.
Urban Barn Quality by Category
Quality can vary significantly from one product line to another. Here's a look at what to expect from their major categories.
Sofas & Sectionals
Sofas often use engineered wood frames and basic spring systems with 1.8-2.2 density foam cushions. At prices from $700-$1,500, they are style-forward, but durability is limited. They are a decent choice for a formal living room or temporary solution, but expect noticeable cushion compression within 2-3 years of daily family use.
Bedroom Furniture
Dominated by particleboard and MDF with laminate or veneer finishes, items like dressers and nightstands are functional and match the brand's aesthetic. The joinery is standard but not robust, and surfaces can be susceptible to scratching or chipping. For $1,200 to $3,000 per set, they work well in guest rooms or low-impact settings.
Dining Furniture
Dining tables often feature veneer-over-MDF tops. While visually appealing, they offer less durability than solid wood alternatives and require careful protection from heat and moisture. Chairs can develop wobbly legs over time. This category is best for formal dining rooms rather than for withstanding the rigors of nightly family meals.
Decor & Accessories
This is arguably Urban Barn's strongest category for consistent value. Items like pillows, throws, rugs, lamps, and wall decor are trendy, reasonably priced, and an easy way to incorporate their modern style without betting on structural longevity. Quality is generally aligned with the price point and competitive with similar retailers.
Our Verdict: Is Urban Barn Worth It?
Urban Barn is a solid choice for style-conscious shoppers on a mid-range budget who understand they are buying medium-term furniture. It’s perfect for furnishing a first home or refreshing a room with current trends, but it is not the right brand for those seeking durable, buy-it-for-life pieces.
Quality Grade: B-
Urban Barn earns a B- for consistently delivering on its promise of accessible, stylish furniture while being transparent about its mid-tier construction. The use of engineered woods and standard foam prevents a higher grade, as longevity is a clear trade-off. However, their products generally meet the quality expectations for their price point without major surprises.
Value Grade: C+
The brand gets a C+ for value. The initial design-per-dollar is excellent, and prices are competitive. The grade is held back by the limited lifespan of high-use pieces, which increases the total cost of ownership over a decade. Value improves greatly when items are bought on sale, but at full price, you're paying more for aesthetics than for substance.
Better Alternatives to Urban Barn
If the trade-offs in durability are a concern, consider these alternatives that offer better long-term quality, often at a similar or slightly higher price point.
Article
Article provides a similar modern aesthetic but with a stronger focus on durable materials, consistently using solid wood frames and high-density foam cushions. Their direct-to-consumer model keeps pricing competitive, making them a superior long-term investment for high-use items like sofas ($1,000-$2,500).
Shop now at article.com
West Elm
As a step up in price and quality, West Elm ($1,200-$3,000 for sofas) offers better craftsmanship and more options with solid wood and sustainably sourced materials. While they also have some veneer pieces, their overall construction and material quality are generally higher than Urban Barn's.
Shop now at westelm.com
Structube
Structube offers trendy, modern furniture at a price point that is often even more affordable than Urban Barn. While their entry-level quality is similar, their higher-tier collections can provide better build quality and durability for the money, making it a strong budget-conscious alternative.
Shop now at structube.com
EQ3
Focusing on timeless design and Canadian craftsmanship, EQ3 is a significant step up in quality and price. With an emphasis on solid wood frames, customization, and domestic manufacturing, their pieces are built to last 10+ years and represent a true long-term investment.
Shop now at eq3.com
Joybird
Known for its customizable mid-century modern furniture, Joybird uses kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-quality performance fabrics. They are more expensive than Urban Barn but offer extensive warranties and a reputation for durability, making them an excellent choice for a family's main sofa.
Shop now at joybird.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does Urban Barn furniture last?
You can generally expect Urban Barn furniture to last 5-8 years, which is typical for mid-range market products. However, high-use items like primary sofas or dining chairs may begin to show significant wear, such as cushion sagging or loose joints, within 2-3 years.
Is Urban Barn furniture made of real wood?
Most Urban Barn furniture is not made from solid wood. The brand primarily utilizes engineered woods, such as MDF (medium-density fiberboard) and particleboard, which are then covered with wood veneers or laminates to achieve a desired look. Solid wood is rarely used and is typically limited to small accents.
Is Urban Barn better quality than IKEA?
Yes, Urban Barn is generally considered a step up in quality and design from IKEA. It offers more sophisticated aesthetics and slightly better baseline construction. That said, select IKEA lines made from solid wood (like the Hemnes collection) may offer comparable or even better longevity at a lower price point than Urban Barn's veneered pieces.
What kind of furniture style is Urban Barn?
Urban Barn focuses on modern, contemporary, and eclectic styles. Their collections are heavily influenced by current interior design trends, offering a casual and accessible take on popular aesthetics like modern farmhouse, mid-century modern accents, and contemporary rustic decor.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
