The Sill is worth it if you’re looking for stylish, healthy, pre-potted plants and value convenience and modern design over rock-bottom prices. The Sill excels at providing a curated experience, delivering robust plants paired with high-quality ceramic planters that are ready to display right out of the box.
The brand is positioned in the mid-to-high end of the market, offering better quality planters and healthier plants than big-box stores but at a higher price. Think of it as a one-stop shop for urban dwellers who want to add greenery to their home without the guesswork. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you get for your money.
How Is The Sill's Quality?
The Sill’s quality is consistently good, especially in their core products: live plants and ceramic planters. They focus on durable materials and healthy specimens, making them a reliable choice for both new and experienced plant owners.
- Ceramic & Concrete Planters: Most of their planters are made from kiln-fired, glazed ceramic, which is highly durable and resistant to scratching and chipping. Their concrete options are lightweight yet sturdy. This craftsmanship ensures the planters last for years with minimal wear.
- Plant Health: Plants are sourced from U.S. growers and arrive healthy and well-established. They offer a diverse selection of easy-care varieties (like Snake Plants and ZZ Plants) that are robust enough to handle shipping and thrive in typical home environments. Their 30-day plant guarantee provides a safety net if a plant arrives in poor condition.
- Wood Planters: Made from sustainably sourced hardwoods, these planters feature precise joinery and a quality finish. However, like any wood product, they require careful watering to avoid moisture damage and potential warping over time.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issue is damage during shipping, such as a cracked ceramic pot. However, customer service is widely reported as being responsive and quick to send replacements. A few reviews note superficial crazing (tiny cracks in the glaze) on some lower-cost ceramic lines over time.
Is The Sill Good Value for the Price?
The Sill offers strong value by bundling quality products with convenience and customer education, though you pay a premium for this curated experience.
Price Positioning
The Sill sits in the mid-range to premium segment of the online plant market. Small plants with simple pots start around $20-$40, while larger, more mature plants in premium ceramic planters can cost $80-$150+. These prices are competitive with similar online retailers like Bloomscape but are significantly higher than what you might find at IKEA, Home Depot, or a local nursery. Shipping is typically free on orders over $75, otherwise, expect a $10-$20 fee.
What You're Paying For
You're paying for more than just a plant and a pot. The price includes the convenience of a healthy plant delivered to your door, pre-potted in a stylish, well-made planter. You also get access to detailed care guides, online workshops, and responsive customer support, which is especially valuable for beginners. The brand's clean, modern aesthetic is a major part of its appeal and is built into the cost.
Where You Get Good Value
- Beginner Bundles: Plant and pot combinations, especially for easy-care varieties, offer great value by taking the guesswork out of plant ownership.
- Medium-Sized Ceramic Planters: Their core line of ceramic planters ($40-$80 range) offers an excellent balance of durability, modern style, and fair pricing.
- Gifts: A pre-potted, stylish plant from The Sill makes a convenient and high-impact gift that feels more premium than a DIY option.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Basic Accessories: Items like watering cans, misters, and small bags of soil can often be found for less at local garden centers or online.
- Single Small Plants: If your order doesn't meet the free shipping threshold, the shipping fee can almost double the cost of a small, inexpensive plant, making it poor value.
- Large Premium Planters: While beautiful, their largest and most ornate planters can creep into the $150+ range, where you can sometimes find similar quality artisan pieces for less.
The Sill Quality by Category
Quality and value can differ depending on what you're buying. Here’s a look at their main product lines:
Ceramic Planters
Ranging from $30 to $150, these are The Sill's standout products. Made from kiln-fired ceramic with durable glazes, they are sturdy, stylish, and built to last. They come in a variety of minimalist shapes and colors that fit well with modern decor. Verdict: Consistently good quality and one of the best reasons to shop here.
Live Plants
Priced between $20 for small plants to over $80 for larger specimens, the plants are reliably healthy and sourced from reputable U.S.-based nurseries. Their selection focuses heavily on beginner-friendly options. The 30-day guarantee adds confidence to the purchase. Verdict: Worth it, especially for beginners or those who want a guarantee of a healthy plant.
Concrete & Wood Planters
These offer a nice aesthetic alternative to ceramics. The concrete is surprisingly lightweight, and the wood is high-quality. Both are designed for indoor use and hold up well, though wood planters require more careful watering routines. Verdict: Good quality options if they fit your specific decor style.
Plant Care Accessories
This category includes soil mixes, fertilizer, watering cans, and misters. The quality is perfectly acceptable - often made with stainless steel or sturdy plastics. However, this is the category with the weakest value proposition. Verdict: Convenient to add to your order, but not the best value. You can often find similar or identical products for less elsewhere.
Our Verdict: Is The Sill Worth It?
The Sill is a great service for anyone who wants to buy stylish, healthy houseplants without hassle. It's particularly well-suited for beginners, gift-givers, and busy people who appreciate the convenience of a curated, all-in-one 'plant in a pot' solution delivered to their door.
Quality Grade: B+
The Sill earns a B+ for quality due to its focus on well-crafted ceramic and concrete planters and consistently healthy plants. The materials are durable for indoor use, and the 30-day plant guarantee shows confidence in their product. The grade is held back from an A by occasional shipping damage to fragile planters and some inconsistencies in lower-cost items.
Value Grade: A-
For its target customer, The Sill provides A- value. The prices are fair for the quality of the planters, a healthy, pre-potted plant, and the educational resources provided. The free shipping threshold is reasonable and makes larger orders a great deal. The value is slightly diminished for small orders with high shipping fees or for basic accessories that are overpriced compared to competitors.
More Quality Brands Like The Sill
If you appreciate The Sill's model of delivering quality plants and stylish planters, you might enjoy these other online plant shops:
Bloomscape
Bloomscape offers a similar service but delivers larger, more mature plants directly from their greenhouse. Their advanced packaging is excellent at protecting plants in transit, and they provide robust, detailed care instructions. Prices are comparable to The Sill.
Shop now at bloomscape.com
Horti
Horti focuses on building confidence in new plant parents through their plant subscription boxes. It is designed to help you gradually build your collection with resilient plants before moving on to more exotic species, making them a great educational alternative.
Shop now at horti.com
Leon & George
Positioned as a luxury plant service, Leon & George specializes in large, impressive floor plants paired with high-end, handmade ceramic planters. It’s significantly more expensive than The Sill but is an excellent choice for a statement piece.
Shop now at leonandgeorge.com
Rooted
Known for its fun, accessible branding and great plant selection, Rooted aims to reconnect people with nature. They offer a wide variety of plants, from common to more rare, and often have great prices, making them a strong competitor.
Shop now at rooted.nyc
Frequently Asked Questions
Are The Sill plants healthy when they arrive?
Yes, overwhelmingly. The Sill partners with nurseries in the U.S. and has developed robust packaging to ensure plants arrive healthy and secure. They also offer a 30-day "Happy Plant Guarantee" and will replace any plant that arrives in poor condition or dies within that window.
Why is The Sill so expensive?
You are paying for a bundled service: a healthy plant, a quality planter (usually ceramic), proper soil, and expert potting all delivered to your door. This convenience, customer support, and branding contribute to a price point that is higher than buying a plant and a pot separately from a garden center.
Is The Sill good for beginners?
Absolutely. The Sill is one of the best choices for beginners due to their focus on easy-care plants, simple and clear care instructions for every plant they sell, and accessible customer support for any questions. Their online workshops are also a great resource for learning.
What is The Sill's return policy?
For live plants, The Sill does not accept returns but offers its 30-day guarantee for replacements. For non-plant items like planters and accessories, you can return them in their original condition within 30 days for a refund, though you may have to cover the return shipping cost.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
