Yes, The Company Store is worth it for shoppers seeking high-quality bedding and home textiles made from premium natural fibers. The brand excels in producing durable, comfortable, and well-crafted essentials like sheet sets and down comforters that are built to last for years.
While their prices are in the mid-to-high range, the value comes from their focus on traditional construction and long-lasting materials like Egyptian cotton and Belgian linen. Here's a detailed breakdown of their quality, value, and what you get for your money.
How Is The Company Store's Quality?
The Company Store's quality is consistently above average, with their higher-end collections reaching premium standards. They prioritize excellent materials and reliable craftsmanship over fast-fashion trends. Here's what to expect:
- Premium Materials: They built their reputation on using top-tier natural fibers. Core products feature long-staple Egyptian cotton sheets (300-600 thread count), strong Belgian linen, and high-quality European down with fill power ratings of 700+, ensuring long-lasting loft and warmth.
- Thoughtful Construction: Craftsmanship is a focus, particularly in their quilts and comforters. Look for details like double-stitched borders to prevent unraveling and chambered construction in duvets to ensure fill stays evenly distributed and doesn't clump.
- Durability and Longevity: Customer reports confirm that their products, especially the premium sheet sets, age gracefully. The materials soften with each wash without significant pilling or thinning, often seeing 3-5 years of regular use with proper care.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues are related to lower-priced items. Durability of zippers on some duvet covers can be a weak point, and lower thread count sheet sets may show pilling or wear sooner than their premium counterparts.
Is The Company Store Good Value for the Price?
The Company Store offers good value, particularly for those who prioritize longevity and quality materials over the lowest possible price. While not cheap, their costs are justified by the product's performance over time.
Price Positioning
The brand occupies a mid-to-high position in the home textiles market. Expect duvet covers from $150-$300, sheet sets from $100-$250, and down comforters from $200-$500. This is comparable to, or sometimes slightly higher than, competitors like Brooklinen or Parachute, reflecting their emphasis on craftsmanship and premium sourcing from US and European mills.
What You're Paying For
You're primarily paying for superior raw materials, durable construction methods, and a timeless aesthetic. The investment is in pieces that maintain their comfort and structural integrity for years, unlike cheaper alternatives that may need replacing after only a year or two. The price also reflects responsible sourcing and manufacturing in specialized mills.
Where You Get Good Value
- Egyptian Cotton Sheets: Their higher-end cotton sheets offer excellent cost-per-use, as they last significantly longer than cheaper options and become progressively softer over time.
- Down & Down Alternative Comforters: These are a standout category. The high fill-power and quality construction mean they provide excellent warmth and maintain their loft for many years, making them a worthwhile long-term investment.
- Heirloom Quilts: For those seeking classic design and detailed craftsmanship, their quilts are well-made and designed to last generations.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Lower-Priced Sheet Sets: Entry-level collections with lower thread counts (around 300) might not offer the same longevity and can be prone to pilling, diminishing their value compared to the premium lines.
- Decorative Accessories: While aesthetically pleasing, some decorative pillows and throws may not have the workhorse durability of their core bedding lines, making them feel overpriced for their function.
- Items Purchased at Full Price: With sales offering 15-25% off, paying full price can feel steep. The best value is almost always found during one of their promotional periods.
The Company Store Quality by Category
Quality remains strong across most categories, but their core bedding essentials are where the brand truly shines.
Sheet Sets
Using materials like Egyptian and Supima cotton, their sheets are known for softness and durability. Higher thread count options are excellent and resist pilling well, though lower-end sets are less consistent. A queen set ranges from $100 for basic cotton percale to over $250 for premium sateen. Verdict: A solid choice, especially their premium collections.
Comforters & Duvet Inserts
This is arguably their strongest category. Their down and Legends® down alternative comforters feature high fill power (700+) and quality shells that prevent feather loss and clumping. Ranging from $200-$500+, these are built for exceptional comfort and long-term use. Verdict: Excellent quality and a worthwhile investment.
Duvet Covers & Quilts
Constructed from durable fabrics like cotton percale and linen, their duvet covers and quilts feature strong stitching and timeless designs. Their quilts are especially well-regarded for their handcrafted feel. The one potential weakness is zippers on some duvet covers. Verdict: High quality, but inspect zipper construction.
Decor & Accessories
Throws and decorative pillows use quality materials like Belgian linen and cotton twill. However, customer feedback suggests they may not hold their shape and structure as robustly as the core bedding over time. These items are best purchased for style rather than heavy-duty function. Verdict: Good, but not the best value category.
Our Verdict: Is The Company Store Worth It?
Yes, The Company Store is worth it for anyone prioritizing classic style and long-lasting quality in their bedding and bath linens. Their products are made to be used and loved for years, offering solid long-term value that often surpasses that of cheaper, trend-focused brands.
Quality Grade: A-
The Company Store earns an A- for its commitment to premium natural fibers and strong construction techniques. Pieces from their core collections, like Egyptian cotton sheets and European down comforters, deliver exceptional performance and longevity. The grade is held back from a pure 'A' due to minor inconsistencies in their entry-level items and occasional hardware issues like weak zippers.
Value Grade: B
With a B for value, The Company Store offers a fair price for the high quality and durability you get. Their products are a sound investment that pays off over years of use, outlasting cheaper competitors significantly. The value is strongest during sales events (15-25% off), which turn a good value into a great one. They aren't the cheapest option, but you get what you pay for in terms of comfort and endurance.
More Quality Brands Like The Company Store
If you appreciate The Company Store’s focus on quality materials and timeless design, here are a few other brands that share a similar commitment to excellence.
Brooklinen
Brooklinen delivers modern luxury with a focus on high-quality, long-staple cotton and linen, often at a slightly more competitive price point. Their simple, elegant aesthetic and direct-to-consumer model have earned them a loyal following for reliable quality.
Shop now at brooklinen.com
Parachute
Parachute excels in minimalist, premium-quality bedding made from natural fibers like linen, percale, and brushed cotton. With prices comparable to The Company Store, they offer a sleek, modern alternative focused on eco-conscious sourcing and impeccable comfort.
Shop now at parachutehome.com
Snowe
Positioning itself as luxury-grade yet accessible, Snowe offers meticulously crafted bedding with materials like long-staple Egyptian cotton from Italy. Their price point is slightly higher, reflecting an even greater emphasis on artisanal craftsmanship and sophisticated durability.
Shop now at snowehome.com
Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch sets itself apart with a focus on 100% organic, ethically sourced GOTS-certified cotton. Their products are exceptionally soft and durable, appealing to consumers who prioritize sustainability and traceability without compromising on a plush, luxurious feel.
Shop now at bollandbranch.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does The Company Store bedding last?
With proper care, their premium bedding can last for years. Higher-end Egyptian cotton sheets often last 3-5+ years, softening with age, while their well-constructed down comforters can last even longer while retaining their loft and warmth.
What is The Company Store known for?
The Company Store is best known for its high-quality down comforters, premium cotton and linen sheets, and classic, timeless designs. They have built a strong reputation over decades for durable goods that prioritize comfort and longevity over passing trends.
Is The Company Store better than Brooklinen?
They cater to different tastes. The Company Store offers a more classic, traditional aesthetic, while Brooklinen is more modern and minimalist. Both offer very good quality materials, but The Company Store's heritage lines are often lauded for their heirloom-style construction and exceptional durability.
When does The Company Store have sales?
The Company Store frequently offers promotions and seasonal sales, especially around holidays like Presidents' Day, Memorial Day, and throughout the fourth quarter. These sales typically provide discounts of 15-25%, making it the best time to buy to maximize value.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
