The short answer is yes - for most things. Sur La Table generally offers good quality kitchenware, but strategically. The retailer shines when it comes to its curated selection of premium brands like Le Creuset, All-Clad, and Wüsthof, which are built for serious home chefs and offer excellent long-term durability. However, its value proposition is less consistent with some of its lower-priced, in-house branded items.
You can trust Sur La Table for high-performance, heirloom-quality pieces from established manufacturers, but you might find better value elsewhere for basic kitchen gadgets and entry-level non-stick pans. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to buy and what to skip.
How Is Sur La Table's Quality?
Sur La Table's quality is best described as well-curated, focusing on mid-to-high-end products that perform reliably. They prioritize proven materials and construction over fleeting trends. Here's a closer look:
- Materials: Premium products feature best-in-class materials designed for longevity. This includes multi-ply stainless steel with aluminum cores for even heating in All-Clad cookware, chip-resistant enameled cast iron from Le Creuset, and high-carbon stainless steel for Wüsthof knives that hold an edge.
- Construction and Craftsmanship: The craftsmanship of their top brands is a major selling point. Their best cookware uses techniques like layered metal construction to prevent warping and ensure optimal heat conduction. Enameled cast iron pieces utilize kiln-fired finishes for durability, setting them apart from cheaper alternatives.
- Sourcing and Manufacturing: The brand's strength lies in its global sourcing from renowned manufacturing hubs. Top-tier cookware often comes from France (Le Creuset, Staub), cutlery from Germany (Wüsthof), and other high-end items from the U.S. (All-Clad). Their house brands are typically produced in China or Taiwan under specific quality control guidelines.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues relate to their lower-tier, house-branded items, not their flagship brands. Customers report that cheaper non-stick pans can peel or lose effectiveness within 1-2 years, and some basic utensils may bend or feel flimsy under heavy use.
Is Sur La Table Good Value for the Price?
The value you get from Sur La Table depends entirely on what you buy. They offer exceptional long-term value on premium items but can feel overpriced on entry-level basics.
Price Positioning
Sur La Table is a premium retailer, with pricing comparable to competitors like Williams Sonoma and Crate & Barrel. Cookware sets can range from $300 for a quality starter set to over $2,500 for a professional All-Clad collection. Individual knives typically cost between $50 and $300. While not a budget destination, their prices reflect the quality and brand reputation of the products they carry.
What You're Paying For
With Sur La Table, your money goes toward a curated collection of proven, high-performance kitchen tools. You're paying for durability, precise engineering (like even heat distribution in pans), and materials that are built to last for decades, not just a few years. You're also paying for the confidence that comes with buying from established brands that often include lifetime warranties.
Where You Get Good Value
- Premium Brand Cookware: An All-Clad stainless steel pan or a Le Creuset Dutch oven is an investment that can last a lifetime, making its high initial cost a great long-term value.
- High-End Cutlery: Forged knives from brands like Wüsthof, Shun, and Global are exceptionally made and will outperform and outlast cheaper alternatives many times over.
- Specialty Bakeware: Durable ceramic, aluminized steel, or cast iron bakeware from reputable names offers excellent performance that justifies its price tag for avid bakers.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Entry-Level Non-Stick Pans: Lower-cost, house-branded non-stick cookware often doesn't hold up for more than a couple of years, making cheaper alternatives from other retailers a better value.
- Basic Kitchen Gadgets: Simple tools like peelers, spatulas, or measuring spoons can be found at identical quality for a much lower price at stores like Target or even on Amazon. You're paying a premium for the Sur La Table name.
- Textiles and Soft Goods: While their aprons, dish towels, and oven mitts are nicely designed, they don't offer a significant quality advantage over less expensive options unless purchased during a major sale.
Sur La Table Quality by Category
Quality and value fluctuate significantly between different product categories. Here’s how each stacks up.
Cookware (Pots & Pans)
This is Sur La Table's strongest category. Their premium offerings - like multi-clad stainless steel from All-Clad and enameled cast iron from Staub and Le Creuset - are the industry standard for durability and performance. However, their lower-end, house-branded non-stick frying pans priced around $40-$60 don't offer the same longevity and can warp or scratch easily. Verdict: A fantastic investment for premium brands, be cautious with the budget lines.
Knives & Cutlery
Sur La Table is an excellent source for high-performance knives. They carry world-renowned brands like Wüsthof from Germany and Shun from Japan, which use high-carbon stainless steel that stays sharp and resists corrosion. A single chef's knife can cost $150+, but it’s a tool that will last for decades with proper care. Verdict: Absolutely worth it for professional-grade knives from leading brands.
Bakeware
From stoneware baking dishes to American-made aluminized steel baking sheets, Sur La Table’s bakeware is generally high quality and built to deliver consistent results. Brands like USA Pan and Staub offer exceptional performance. Their house brand bakeware is also quite reliable, generally performing better than their house brand cookware. Verdict: A solid category with good options at various price points.
Kitchen Tools & Gadgets
This category is a mixed bag. You can find well-made, durable tools made from stainless steel or heat-resistant silicone. However, you can also pay a premium for simple plastic gadgets that offer no better quality than what you'd find at a discount store. Price is not always an indicator of quality here, so inspect items closely. Verdict: Hit or miss. Stick to reputable brands or shop specifically for durable materials like metal and wood.
Our Verdict: Is Sur La Table Worth It?
Sur La Table is worth it for home cooks who see their kitchen tools as a long-term investment. By focusing your budget on their curated collection of premium cookware and cutlery from world-class brands, you can acquire equipment that will perform beautifully for years or even decades. The key is to shop selectively and avoid overpaying for basic gadgets and entry-level items that offer poor value.
Quality Grade: B+
Sur La Table scores a B+ for quality because of its excellent curation of top-tier, heirloom-quality brands like All-Clad, Le Creuset, and Wüsthof. These products are manufactured with superior materials and construction techniques designed for longevity. The grade is held back from an A by the inconsistency of their lower-priced, in-house products, which don’t meet the same high standards and have known durability issues.
Value Grade: B
The value proposition is solid but not universal, earning a B. The long-term value of a Le Creuset Dutch oven or a Wüsthof knife is immense, as they can last for generations, making the high upfront cost worthwhile. However, this is balanced by their overpriced basic utensils and gadgets and their less-durable budget cookware, which pull the overall value score down.
Better Alternatives to Sur La Table
If you're looking for more consistent value or specialized options, these alternatives provide a better balance of price and quality for certain needs.
Williams Sonoma
For a similar premium curated experience, Williams Sonoma offers a slightly broader range of high-end brands and exclusive collections. They are a direct competitor with comparable pricing and are known for exceptionally strong quality in both their name-brand and private-label bakeware lines.
Shop now at williams-sonoma.com
Wüsthof
Instead of buying a mid-range knife set from a retailer, go directly to a specialist. For anyone serious about cutlery, Wüsthof offers German-engineered, forged knives that come with a lifetime warranty and are considered industry benchmarks for performance and durability.
Shop now at wusthof.com
Le Creuset
If your primary goal is finding enameled cast iron cookware that will truly last a lifetime, buying directly from Le Creuset is a smart move. Celebrated for their timeless design and resistance to chipping, their French-made Dutch ovens are an investment piece that defines the category.
Shop now at lecreuset.com
Lodge Cast Iron
For incredible value and durability without the high price of enameled pieces, Lodge is the clear winner. Their American-made seasoned cast iron skillets deliver unbeatable heat retention and searing capabilities for a fraction of the cost ($20-$40) and will last forever with proper care.
Shop now at lodgecastiron.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sur La Table better quality than Williams Sonoma?
They are very comparable in quality, as both focus on premium, trusted brands. Williams Sonoma may have a slight edge in the consistency and quality of its in-house brands, particularly their bakeware, but both retailers offer an excellent selection of heirloom-quality kitchenware.
What brands sold at Sur La Table are the best?
The most respected and durable brands to look for at Sur La Table are All-Clad (stainless steel cookware), Le Creuset and Staub (enameled cast iron), Wüsthof and Shun (knives), and USA Pan (bakeware). Focusing on these brands almost always ensures a high-quality purchase.
Is Sur La Table's house brand cookware any good?
Sur La Table's house brand cookware is decent for beginner or casual cooks but doesn't offer the longevity or performance of their premium brand counterparts. The non-stick collections are a common weak point, with reviews frequently mentioning visible wear after just 1-2 years of regular use.
When is the best time to buy from Sur La Table?
The best time to shop is during major seasonal sales events, such as their Anniversary Sale, Black Friday, or post-holiday clearances. During these times, you can often find significant discounts (20% or more) on premium brands that rarely go on sale, which dramatically increases the value proposition.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
