The short answer is yes - for a specific type of buyer. Stickley is worth it if you are looking for heirloom-quality, American-made furniture and are willing to make a significant upfront investment. Known for its mastery of the Arts and Crafts and Mission styles, Stickley delivers exceptional craftsmanship using solid hardwoods and traditional construction techniques that are built to last for generations.
This is not fast furniture, it's a long-term investment in timeless design and durability. If your priority is budget or trendy aesthetics, this brand is not for you. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you get for the premium price tag.
How Is Stickley's Quality?
Stickley's reputation for quality is legendary and well-earned, built on a foundation of superior materials and time-honored construction methods. Here’s what sets their furniture apart:
- Premium Materials: The vast majority of Stickley furniture is made from solid hardwoods like quarter-sawn white oak, cherry, and mahogany. Upholstered pieces feature full-grain leather and high-density foam cushions (typically 2.0-2.5 lbs), ensuring both durability and long-term comfort.
- Traditional Construction: Stickley employs classic joinery techniques that stand the test of time. You'll find mortise and tenon joints, dovetail drawers, and pinned joints - methods that create incredibly strong and stable furniture far superior to the screws and glue used in mass-market furniture.
- Meticulous Finishes: Finishes are applied by hand in multiple steps, including sanding, staining, and sealing. This labor-intensive process not only creates a beautiful, deep patina but also provides a durable barrier against daily wear and tear.
- Durability and Longevity: It is not uncommon for a Stickley piece to last 30 years or more. This furniture is heavy, substantial, and built for daily use. Owners often report that their tables, chairs, and case goods remain sturdy and functional for decades, developing character with age.
- Common Complaints: While overwhelmingly positive, a few customer reviews mention minor inconsistencies in finishes or rare instances of veneer lifting on specific decorative pieces. Given the price, any flaw can feel significant, but widespread manufacturing defects are not a common issue.
Is Stickley Good Value for the Price?
Stickley's value proposition is centered on longevity and timelessness, not on being the cheapest option. It provides excellent long-term value for those who appreciate and can afford its premium positioning.
Price Positioning
Stickley occupies the high-end, premium segment of the furniture market. Expect to pay between $2,500 and $8,000 for a dining table and $4,000 to $12,000 for a sofa. This places them in the same tier as other heritage brands like Baker and Hickory Chair, and significantly above mid-range brands like Pottery Barn or Room & Board.
What You're Paying For
The high price tag covers American-made craftsmanship, primarily from workshops in New York and North Carolina. You are paying for solid hardwood materials - no particle board or MDF - and the labor of skilled artisans who use traditional, time-consuming construction and finishing techniques. You're also paying for a timeless aesthetic that won't need replacing when trends change.
Where You Get Good Value
- Heirloom Pieces: Dining tables, dressers, armoires, and bookcases are where Stickley truly shines. These solid wood pieces offer incredible longevity and can be passed down through generations.
- Classic Designs: Investing in Arts and Crafts or Mission-style furniture ensures it will never look dated. These classic forms have remained popular for over a century.
- Resale Value: Unlike most furniture, which depreciates rapidly, well-maintained Stickley pieces often retain significant value and are sought after in secondhand markets.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Budget-Focused Shoppers: If your main concern is price, Stickley is simply not a practical choice. You can find functional furniture for a fraction of the cost elsewhere.
- Trendy Aesthetics: If you enjoy redesigning your space every few years with the latest trends, the high cost and traditional look of Stickley make it a poor investment.
- Short-Term Needs: This furniture is built to last a lifetime. If you're furnishing a temporary space, the investment doesn't make financial sense.
Stickley Quality by Category
Quality is consistently high across the board, but certain categories are standout investments.
Dining Furniture
Considered a core strength, Stickley dining tables and chairs are built to withstand generations of family dinners. Made from solid oak or cherry using robust joinery, these pieces are exceptionally stable and durable. Prices for a table and six chairs can range from $7,000 into the tens of thousands, but the quality is undeniable. Verdict: A true heirloom investment.
Bedroom Furniture
Stickley's beds, dressers, and armoires are incredibly substantial and finely crafted. Drawers feature smooth-gliding wood-on-wood or high-quality metal slides and classic dovetail joints. Solid hardwoods ensure these pieces won't sag or warp over time. Verdict: Exceptional quality and built to last a lifetime.
Sofas & Sectionals
Stickley upholstery features kiln-dried hardwood frames, high-quality spring systems, and rich, durable leathers or performance fabrics. While the frames are built to last forever, some customers note the high-density foam cushions soften after many years of heavy use, which is typical. Price range is typically $4,000-$12,000. Verdict: Excellent frame construction and materials, offering decades of service.
Case Goods (Bookcases, Cabinets, Desks)
Like its dining and bedroom furniture, Stickley's case goods exemplify the brand's commitment to quality. The solid wood construction and robust joinery mean bookcases can handle heavy loads without bowing, and desks feel solid and unwavering. Verdict: An A+ choice for a home office or library.
Our Verdict: Is Stickley Worth It?
Stickley is absolutely worth it for buyers who prioritize heritage craftsmanship, American-made quality, and timeless design over affordability. This is furniture as a long-term investment, intended to be used and cherished for decades, not replaced every few years. If you value substance over style trends, Stickley is one of the best choices you can make.
Quality Grade: A
Stickley earns a firm 'A' for its unwavering commitment to quality. The use of premium solid hardwoods, traditional joinery like mortise and tenons, and meticulous hand-finishing processes result in furniture that achieves true heirloom durability. While no brand is perfect, Stickley consistently delivers pieces designed to last a lifetime, putting it in the top tier of furniture manufacturing.
Value Grade: B
The 'B' grade for value acknowledges the extremely high price point. The price-to-quality ratio is excellent when considering life-cycle cost - this furniture won't need to be replaced. For those who can afford the initial outlay, the longevity, durability, and high resale value make Stickley a shrewd investment compared to buying mid-range furniture multiple times over.
More Quality Brands Like Stickley
If you love Stickley's commitment to quality craftsmanship and American-made furniture, here are some other brands with similar high standards worth exploring:
Baker Furniture
Operating at an even higher price point, Baker is known for its partnerships with world-renowned designers and its exceptional, artisan-level finishes. If you seek impeccable, classic designs with a more formal or European feel, Baker is a top-tier peer to Stickley.
Shop now at bakerfurniture.com
Hickory Chair
Hickory Chair shares Stickley's commitment to bench-made craftsmanship in North Carolina and offers extensive customization options. Their aesthetic ranges from traditional to transitional, making them a great choice if you want heirloom quality with a slightly different design voice.
Shop now at hickorychair.com
Henredon
Known for elegant, traditional case goods and distinctive designs, Henredon has been a standard-bearer for high-end furniture for decades. Their pieces feature fine veneers, intricate inlays, and robust construction on par with Stickley's quality ethos.
Shop now at henredon.com
Ethan Allen
While priced slightly below Stickley, Ethan Allen offers a strong commitment to North American manufacturing and solid wood construction in many of its collections. It provides a more accessible entry into heirloom-quality furniture with a broad range of classic and contemporary styles.
Shop now at ethanallen.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Stickley furniture so expensive?
The high cost is due to four main factors: the use of premium solid hardwoods (no particle board), domestic manufacturing in the US, labor-intensive traditional construction techniques (like dovetail and mortise and tenon joinery), and multi-step, hand-applied finishes.
How long does Stickley furniture last?
Stickley furniture is built to be heirloom quality, meaning it's designed to last for generations. With proper care, it's common for pieces to be in excellent structural condition after 20-30 years of daily use, often outlasting their original owners.
Is Stickley furniture truly solid wood?
Yes, the vast majority of Stickley's furniture is made from solid hardwoods. They are most famous for their use of solid quarter-sawn white oak and cherry. While they may use fine veneers for decorative purposes like inlays on some pieces, the core structure is always robust solid wood.
Where is Stickley furniture made?
Stickley proudly manufactures its furniture in the United States. Its primary workshops are located in Manlius, New York, with upholstery operations based in North Carolina, continuing a long tradition of American craftsmanship.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
