The short answer is yes, Sleepyhead is worth it for shoppers seeking a high-quality mattress at a competitive, mid-range price. The brand's materials, such as CertiPUR-US certified foams and durable pocketed coils, are comparable to what you'd find in higher-priced competitors like Casper or Tuft & Needle. For the price, their hybrid models deliver particularly strong performance and comfort.
Sleepyhead offers good value, especially if you buy during one of their frequent sales. It strikes a balance between advanced sleep technology and affordability, though some of its entry-level foam models may not have the same long-term durability as premium brands. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to know before you buy.
How Is Sleepyhead's Quality?
Sleepyhead's quality is solid for its price-point, generally rating a B+. It uses industry-standard materials and modern construction techniques, though consistency can vary between their budget foam models and their more premium hybrids. Here's what to expect:
- Materials: Mattresses are made with vetted components, including CertiPUR-US certified foams, which means they are low in VOCs and made without harmful chemicals. Top layers often feature gel-infused memory foam for cooling, supported by high-density polyfoam bases or steel pocketed coils.
- Construction: Most mattresses feature a multi-layer design to balance comfort and support. Hybrid models use individually pocketed coils which excel at motion isolation and provide better edge support. The stitching on mattress covers is typically uniform and clean, indicating good craftsmanship.
- Durability and Longevity: Most Sleepyhead mattresses maintain their shape and support for 3-5 years. The hybrid models generally outperform the all-foam mattresses in longevity due to the coil support system. Some users report softening or indentations after 2-3 years, especially with the lower-cost foam models.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues cited in customer reviews are premature foam sagging or indentation in less expensive models and the potential for coil noise to develop in hybrid mattresses after several years of use. Some owners also report that the edges can soften over time.
Is Sleepyhead Good Value for the Price?
Sleepyhead delivers good, but not perfect, value. Its main selling point is providing access to premium features like hybrid construction and cooling foams without the premium price tag, positioning itself as a smart buy for budget-savvy consumers.
Price Positioning
A queen-sized Sleepyhead mattress typically costs between $700 and $1,500, placing it in direct competition with brands like Nectar and the lower end of Purple's range. Sleepyhead frequently runs sales that offer 20-30% off, which significantly boosts its value proposition. At full price, its value is average, on sale, it becomes a very compelling offer.
What You're Paying For
With Sleepyhead, you are paying for modern design and advanced mattress technology sold through a direct-to-consumer model. This eliminates retail markups, allowing for features like gel-infused foam, pocketed coils, and detailed craftsmanship at a lower cost than traditional retail brands. The price reflects a balance between reliable materials and cost-efficiency.
Where You Get Good Value
- Hybrid Mattresses: Their hybrid models, which combine foam and steel coils, offer better longevity and support, providing the best return on your investment.
- Shopping During Sales: The best value is unlocked during their frequent 20-30% off sales, making even their premium models highly affordable.
- Mid-to-Premium Tiers: Higher-end Sleepyhead models often include features - like enhanced cooling layers and zoned support - found in mattresses costing several hundred dollars more.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Entry-Level Foam Mattresses: Their cheapest all-foam models are more prone to softening and developing indentations within 2-3 years, reducing their long-term value.
- Pillows and Accessories: While functional, pillows and accessories tend to show wear like flattening or pilling within 1-2 years and are a better deal when bundled with a mattress on sale.
- Paying Full Price: Given the frequency of sales, paying the full retail price means you are not getting the best possible deal on Sleepyhead products.
Sleepyhead Quality by Category
Quality can differ across Sleepyhead’s product lines, particularly between their hybrid models, all-foam options, and smaller sleep accessories.
Mattresses (Hybrid)
Ranging from $900-$1,500 for a queen, Sleepyhead's hybrid mattresses offer the best overall quality and durability. They combine pressure-relieving foam comfort layers with a robust pocketed coil support system that improves airflow, isolates motion, and provides reliable edge support. These models are expected to last 5+ years with proper care. Verdict: This category is worth it for most sleepers.
Mattresses (Foam)
Priced between $700-$1,100 for a queen, the all-foam mattresses use multiple layers of CertiPUR-US certified foam to provide contouring and pressure relief. While comfortable, these models are more susceptible to developing body indentations or softening over time, particularly under heavier users. Verdict: A decent choice for guest rooms or short-term use, but not the best for long-term primary bedroom use.
Pillows & Accessories
Featuring shredded or solid memory foam, Sleepyhead pillows and accessories ($50-$150) offer decent comfort. However, their lifespan is shorter, often showing signs of flattening or wear within 1-2 years. The quality is a step above bargain brands but doesn’t match the durability of specialized pillow manufacturers. Verdict: Consider them alongside a mattress purchase if they come heavily discounted.
Our Verdict: Is Sleepyhead Worth It?
Sleepyhead is a commendable choice for consumers who want an advanced, comfortable mattress without paying a luxury premium. Its sweet spot is the hybrid mattress line purchased during a promotional period, which provides excellent quality and features for the price. While it may not offer the heirloom longevity of a top-tier brand, it delivers a comfortable and supportive sleep experience for many years.
Quality Grade: B+
Sleepyhead earns a B+ for quality due to its use of sound materials like CertiPUR-US certified foams and durable steel pocketed coils. Craftsmanship is generally good, and construction mimics that of more expensive online brands. The grade is held back from an 'A' by reports of premature softening in lower-tier foam models and some longevity inconsistencies noted in customer reviews after the 3-year mark.
Value Grade: B
With a value grade of B, Sleepyhead represents a solid financial decision, particularly when purchased on sale. The price-to-feature ratio is strong, especially for its hybrid mattresses. The value is tempered slightly because the longest-lasting models push against the $1,500 price point, and inconsistent warranty claim experiences reported by some customers add a minor element of risk.
More Quality Brands Like Sleepyhead
If you're impressed by Sleepyhead's value and online model, but want to compare it against other strong contenders, here are a few other brands that offer excellent quality and similar styles:
Casper
Casper has a well-established reputation for durable hybrid mattresses that feature Zoned Support for spinal alignment, often outlasting competitors. If longevity and consistent quality are your top priorities and you have a slightly higher budget ($1,000-$2,200), Casper is a trusted choice.
Shop now at casper.com
Tuft &, Needle
Offering a similar direct-to-consumer value proposition, Tuft &, Needle is known for its durable and supportive adaptive foam mattresses at prices comparable to Sleepyhead. Customer reviews highlight minimal sagging even after 5+ years, making it a reliable alternative.
Shop now at tuftandneedle.com
Purple
For a step up in technology and durability, Purple's proprietary Hyper-Elastic Polymer grid offers unique pressure relief and is exceptionally resilient against sagging. Although pricier (starting around $1,200), it's a great option for heavier sleepers or anyone concerned about body impressions.
Shop now at purple.com
Amerisleep
Ideal for the eco-conscious shopper, Amerisleep uses plant-based memory foams designed for durability and breathability. Their mattresses often come with longer warranties and are reported to maintain support for over 7 years, making them a strong long-term investment.
Shop now at amerisleep.com
Saatva
If you're seeking a luxury, long-term investment, Saatva offers high-end innerspring and hybrid mattresses built like traditional luxury beds. With heirloom-quality materials designed to last over 10 years and complimentary white-glove delivery, Saatva is a true premium alternative.
Shop now at saatva.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does a Sleepyhead mattress actually last?
A Sleepyhead mattress typically lasts between 3 to 5 years before potentially developing noticeable softening or body indentations. Their hybrid models tend to have better longevity, often providing reliable support for 5 years or more, while their all-foam models may show wear sooner.
Do Sleepyhead mattresses smell when unboxed?
Yes, like most bed-in-a-box mattresses, Sleepyhead mattresses often have a slight "new product" smell known as off-gassing upon unboxing. Because they use CertiPUR-US certified foams, this smell is non-toxic and typically dissipates within 24 to 72 hours in a well-ventilated room.
Is Sleepyhead better than Casper?
Neither is definitively "better" as they serve different priorities. Casper generally has a stronger reputation for long-term durability and its Zoned Support system is a premium feature. Sleepyhead, however, often offers comparable comfort technology and hybrid models at a more competitive price point, especially during sales.
What is Sleepyhead's return policy?
Sleepyhead typically offers a 100-night sleep trial, which allows you to test the mattress at home and return it for a refund or exchange if you are not satisfied. While most customers have a smooth process, some have reported logistical challenges or delays during the return process.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
