Yes, for the right buyer, Sherrill Furniture is a high-quality brand worth the investment. Their furniture is built for longevity using traditional, American-made craftsmanship and premium materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames and eight-way hand-tied springs.
Sherrill is an excellent choice for those prioritizing heirloom-quality pieces over fast-fashion trends and who are willing to pay a premium for durability. However, the high price point and long lead times mean it isn't the best fit for every budget or timeline. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to expect.
How Is Sherrill Furniture's Quality?
Sherrill Furniture is known for its meticulous construction and use of durable materials, placing it firmly in the mid-to-high end of the market. Here's what defines their quality:
- Frames and Joinery: Their furniture is built on solid, kiln-dried hardwood frames (often maple or oak) that resist warping and cracking. Frames are reinforced with corner blocks and double-dowel joinery, ensuring exceptional structural integrity that lasts for decades.
- Suspension System: Sherrill uses the gold-standard eight-way hand-tied spring system in most of their upholstered pieces. This labor-intensive method creates a durable, comfortable, and supportive seat that distributes weight evenly and prevents sagging over time.
- Cushion Quality: Cushions are made from high-resilience foam, typically with a density of 2.0+ pounds per cubic foot. This ensures they hold their shape and comfort far longer than the 1.8 density foam found in mid-range brands.
- American Manufacturing: With manufacturing facilities in North Carolina, Sherrill maintains tight quality control over their processes. This leads to better craftsmanship and consistency compared to brands that outsource production overseas.
- Common Complaints: While overwhelmingly positive, the most common issues are minor. Some customers report fabric pilling on certain lighter-colored textiles and occasional damage during shipping. Their long lead times (8-16 weeks) are also a frequent pain point for buyers.
Is Sherrill Furniture Good Value for the Price?
Sherrill provides strong long-term value for a high initial investment. You pay more upfront, but the furniture is built to last 10-15 years or more, whereas cheaper alternatives might need replacing every 3-5 years.
Price Positioning
Sherrill sits in a premium price bracket, with sofas typically ranging from $3,500 to $8,000. This positions them well above mass-market brands like West Elm or Pottery Barn and puts them in direct competition with other high-end, American-made manufacturers like Lee Industries and Century Furniture.
What You're Paying For
The premium price tag covers superior materials, traditional construction methods, and domestic labor costs. You are paying for a "buy it for life" piece of furniture that features a solid hardwood frame, eight-way hand-tied springs, and extensive customization options for fabrics and finishes - features rarely found at lower price points.
Where You Get Good Value
- Upholstered Sofas and Armchairs: Their core product lines offer excellent value due to their exceptional construction. A Sherrill sofa can easily last over a decade with proper care, making the cost-per-year of use very reasonable.
- Timeless, Classic Pieces: By focusing on classic silhouettes rather than fleeting trends, their furniture is less likely to feel dated. This longevity in both style and structure represents a smart investment for your home.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Buyers on a Tight Timeline: With custom pieces taking 8-16 weeks to produce and deliver, the value proposition diminishes if you need furniture quickly.
- Shipping and Delivery Costs: White-glove delivery for these heavy, well-built pieces can be expensive, adding a significant amount to the final ticket price that isn't always factored into the initial budget.
Sherrill Furniture Quality by Category
Sherrill specializes in beautifully crafted upholstered seating. While they offer other items, their reputation is built on the quality of their sofas, sectionals, and chairs.
Upholstered Furniture (Sofas, Sectionals, Chairs & Recliners)
This is where Sherrill truly shines. Their upholstered furniture is built to heirloom standards, featuring kiln-dried hardwood frames, eight-way hand-tied spring suspension, and high-density foam cushions. With dozens of high-quality fabric and leather options, you are essentially purchasing a custom, long-lasting piece. Prices are high, but the durability and comfort justify the cost for those seeking a one-time purchase that endures. Verdict: Worth it if it's in your budget.
Our Verdict: Is Sherrill Furniture Worth It?
Sherrill Furniture is an excellent choice for consumers seeking durable, American-made pieces with timeless style. If you have the budget and patience for their lead times, you are investing in furniture that will likely outlast most other brands on the market.
Quality Grade: B+
Sherrill earns a B+ for its strong commitment to high-quality materials and construction methods like kiln-dried hardwood frames and eight-way hand-tied springs. Their US-based manufacturing allows for consistent craftsmanship. The grade is held back from an A only by minor inconsistencies, such as fabric pilling on select options and damage that sometimes occurs during shipping.
Value Grade: B
The brand gets a B for value. Although the initial price is high, the exceptional durability makes it a fantastic long-term investment. You are paying a premium for materials and construction that ensure a 10-15+ year lifespan. The value is slightly reduced by the high initial cost and significant shipping expenses, which can be prohibitive for some buyers.
More Quality Brands Like Sherrill Furniture
If you appreciate Sherrill's dedication to American craftsmanship and quality, these other brands offer similar standards and styles worth exploring.
Lee Industries
Lee Industries is synonymous with high-quality, eco-friendly, American-made furniture. They offer similar kiln-dried hardwood frames and eight-way hand-tied springs at a slightly more accessible price point than Sherrill ($2,800-$7,000 for a sofa), making them an excellent alternative.
Shop now at leeindustries.com
Century Furniture
Positioned at the higher end of the luxury market, Century offers impeccable handcrafted furniture with classic and contemporary designs. Their construction quality rivals or exceeds Sherrill's, but so do their prices ($4,000-$10,000+ for a sofa). Consider Century if you are seeking ultimate brand prestige and heirloom quality.
Shop now at centuryfurniture.com
Craftmaster Furniture
Craftmaster strikes a great balance between value and durability, offering US-made furniture with kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-resilience cushions. Their sofas ($2,500-$5,500) provide a solid step-up in quality from mass-market brands without reaching Sherrill's premium price points.
Shop now at craftmasterfurniture.com
American Leather
If your style leans more modern, American Leather offers top-tier quality with top-grain leather and solid hardwood frames. They are renowned for their industry-leading rapid delivery times on custom furniture, providing a great option if you can't wait months for your order.
Shop now at americanleather.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Sherrill Furniture made in the USA?
Yes, the vast majority of Sherrill Furniture is proudly manufactured in their facilities in North Carolina. This allows them to maintain high standards of quality control and craftsmanship.
How long does Sherrill Furniture last?
With its solid hardwood frames and superior construction, Sherrill furniture is built to last. Many owners report their pieces remain comfortable and structurally sound for over 10 to 15 years with proper care.
Why is Sherrill Furniture so expensive?
The price reflects the premium materials, labor-intensive construction techniques (like eight-way hand-tied springs), extensive customization options, and domestic manufacturing costs. You are paying for a piece designed for longevity, not disposability.
What kind of warranty does Sherrill Furniture offer?
Sherrill typically offers a very strong warranty that backs their quality claims. Their warranties often cover the frame and spring systems for 10-15 years, giving buyers excellent peace of mind.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
