The short answer is: Rugs USA is worth it if you prioritize trendy style and affordability over long-term durability. Their massive selection is perfect for finding a fashionable, budget-friendly rug, but the quality of their most popular items - machine-made synthetic rugs - often doesn't stand up to heavy use over many years.
Think of them as a fantastic source for low-traffic areas or temporary situations where you want a big design impact for a small price. If you’re looking for an heirloom piece to last a decade in your bustling living room, however, you may want to look elsewhere. Here's what you need to know before you buy.
How Is Rugs USA's Quality?
Rugs USA's quality is highly inconsistent and directly tied to the specific materials and construction method of the rug you choose. Here's a breakdown of what to expect:
- Materials: The majority of their aggressively priced bestsellers are machine-made from synthetic fibers like polypropylene, polyester, or nylon. These materials are excellent at resisting stains and fading but lack the dense, resilient feel of natural fibers and can look matted or worn within a couple of years. Their more expensive wool and natural fiber options offer significantly better quality and longevity.
- Construction: Most of the inventory is power-loomed, a fast and cost-effective method ideal for mass production. This often results in a lighter-weight rug with a less dense pile. Finishing details, like fringes, are typically sewn on rather than woven into the rug, which can lead to fraying and unraveling over time.
- Durability and Longevity: This is where the difference is most apparent. Many customer reviews state that synthetic rugs in high-traffic areas show significant flattening and thinning within 1-3 years. In contrast, their wool and hand-tufted collections hold up much better, often lasting 5-10 years with proper care.
- Common Complaints: Frequent issues cited by customers include a plasticky feel or chemical smell upon arrival (with synthetics), pile that flattens quickly, shedding from wool rugs (which is normal initially), and colors that appear different in person than they do on the website.
Is Rugs USA Good Value for the Price?
Rugs USA's value proposition is centered entirely on style-per-dollar. For the price, they offer an aesthetic variety that is nearly unmatched in the online market, but this value diminishes if you require long-term durability.
Price Positioning
Rugs USA occupies the budget-to-mid-range segment of the rug market. Small synthetic accent rugs can be found for under $50, with common 8x10 room-sized options priced between $200-$500. Their higher-end wool and hand-knotted pieces can cost over $1,000, but their core business lies in the sub-$500 category, making them highly competitive with retailers like Wayfair, Overstock, and Amazon. Be aware that their business model relies heavily on frequent sales (often 30-70% off), meaning the "list price" is often inflated.
What You're Paying For
With Rugs USA, you are almost always paying for design and convenience over craftsmanship. You're getting a trendy Persian, Moroccan, or modern-style rug that looks great right out of the packaging for a very low price. You are not paying for heirloom-quality materials, dense pile construction, or artisan detailing. It's affordable decor meant to be stylish, not an investment meant to be timeless.
Where You Get Good Value
- Low-traffic areas: Perfect for guest rooms, offices, or formal living rooms where the rug won't see heavy daily foot traffic.
- Trendy or temporary decor: If you are a renter, a college student, or someone who likes to change their decor frequently, the low cost makes it a great value.
- Higher-end collections on sale: Purchasing one of their better-quality wool or hand-tufted rugs during a major sale can offer solid value that outperforms their synthetic options.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- High-traffic environments: Their cheaper synthetic rugs are a poor choice for entryways, hallways, and main family rooms as they tend to wear out too quickly.
- Long-term investment: If you want a rug that will last 10+ years and hold its value, Rugs USA is not the right choice.
- Buying at "full price": Given how often sales occur, paying the listed non-sale price represents poor value.
Rugs USA Quality by Material & Type
The quality of a brand is best understood through its different product offerings. For Rugs USA, this comes down to material and construction methods.
Machine-Made Synthetic Rugs (Polypropylene, Polyester)
This is the bread and butter of Rugs USA. These rugs are machine-made overseas in factories in Turkey and India. They offer incredible vividness in color and pattern, are highly stain-resistant, and are extremely affordable (often $150-$400 for a large size). The downside is a thin pile that quickly flattens, a less-than-luxurious feel underfoot, and a typical lifespan of just 1-3 years in a busy home. Verdict: Worth it for style on a tight budget, but not for durability.
Hand-Tufted Wool Rugs
A step up in quality and price, these rugs feature a denser pile and the natural resilience and softness of wool. They are constructed by punching strands of wool through a canvas backing with a tufting tool. While more durable than synthetics (lasting 5-10 years), they are prone to shedding, especially when new. Priced from $400-$800 for larger sizes, they offer a good middle ground. Verdict: A good value purchase, especially when on sale, if you can tolerate some initial shedding.
Natural Fiber Rugs (Jute, Sisal)
Rugs USA offers a wide selection of jute and sisal rugs, prized for their earthy, coastal aesthetic. They are very durable and affordable for natural-fiber options. However, they can be coarse underfoot and are notoriously difficult to clean, as liquids can permanently stain the fibers. They work best in dining rooms or low-traffic areas. Verdict: A great stylistic choice for the right room, but impractical for messy or high-traffic spaces.
Our Verdict: Is Rugs USA Worth It?
Rugs USA is worth it for shoppers who understand the trade-off they are making: sacrificing long-term durability for incredible style variety at budget-friendly prices. If you're decorating a guest room, a starter home, or an apartment, or if you simply love changing your style every few years, it's an excellent resource. However, if you're looking for a "buy it for life" rug for a high-traffic family room, you will likely be disappointed.
Quality Grade: C+
This grade reflects the vast inconsistency across the catalog. The high volume of entry-level synthetic rugs, which often last only 1-3 years, brings the overall score down. While their premium wool collections could earn a "B" on their own, the brand as a whole delivers a C-level quality experience where flattening, fraying, and a non-luxurious feel are common outcomes for their best-selling products.
Value Grade: B-
Rugs USA provides good value from a style-to-price perspective. For a few hundred dollars, you can completely change the look of a room, and for many, that's a huge win. The value is hampered by poor long-term durability, which means the cost-per-year of use is higher than it first appears. Strategic shopping during their frequent 70% sales bumps this grade up significantly.
Better Alternatives to Rugs USA
If you're concerned about durability and want to step up in quality without breaking the bank, here are a few alternatives that offer better craftsmanship for the price.
Loloi Rugs
An industry favorite known for designer collaborations, Loloi offers great style with a noticeable step up in quality. Their rugs, especially their power-loomed options with denser piles, feel more substantial and tend to hold up better over time than comparable Rugs USA products.
Shop now at loloirugs.com
Safavieh
Sold through many retailers including Wayfair and Overstock, Safavieh is a massive producer with a reputation for solid mid-range quality. Their wool collections offer particularly good durability, and customer satisfaction ratings for longevity are consistently higher than for baseline Rugs USA synthetic pieces.
Shop now at safavieh.com
Mohawk Home
For durable synthetic rugs that can withstand heavy foot traffic, Mohawk is a fantastic choice. Many of their rugs are made in the USA and are designed for active households, featuring enhanced stain resistance and robust construction that prevents flattening and crushing. Their designs are typically more traditional than trend-focused.
Shop now at mohawkhome.com
Schoolhouse
Priced higher than Rugs USA, Schoolhouse offers exceptional quality and craftsmanship for those with a bigger budget. Focusing on traditional manufacturing techniques and high-quality materials like wool, their rugs are investment pieces designed to become modern heirlooms and easily justify their cost with longevity.
Shop now at schoolhouse.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do Rugs USA rugs actually last?
Expectancy varies wildly by material. Their machine-made polypropylene and polyester rugs often show noticeable wear, flattening, or thinning within 1-3 years in a high-traffic area. Their pricier wool and hand-tufted rugs can last 5-10 years with proper care.
Are Rugs USA rugs good for high-traffic areas?
Generally, no. We would not recommend their popular synthetic rugs for busy entryways, hallways, or family room centers. If you must use one in a high-traffic zone, choose one of their higher-quality wool options or a more durable brand like Mohawk.
Why are Rugs USA rugs so cheap?
Their low prices are achieved through a combination of using cost-effective synthetic materials (polypropylene), efficient machine-based production (power-looming), sourcing from large overseas factories, and a direct-to-consumer online business model that eliminates retail overhead.
Is everything at Rugs USA always on sale?
It certainly seems that way. Their business model relies on a high-low pricing strategy where items are listed at an inflated price and almost always promoted with a significant discount. A smart shopper should never pay the "list price" and should wait for one of the frequent 70% or 80% off sales.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
