Pomelo is worth it if you prioritize trendy, modern style and affordability over long-term durability. The brand excels at delivering Scandi-inspired, Instagram-worthy designs at a price point that makes furnishing a first apartment or a temporary space feel accessible and stylish.
However, the quality reflects the price: materials like engineered wood and standard foam cushions mean most pieces are best suited for 2-3 years of moderate use. It’s a step up in design from IKEA, but it lacks the robust construction of more established mid-range players like West Elm or Article. Here's what you need to know before you buy.
How Is Pomelo's Quality?
Pomelo's quality is average for its price point, focusing on aesthetics over heirloom construction. Expect furniture that looks great but shows wear faster than more expensive alternatives. Here's a breakdown of what to expect:
- Materials: The majority of their furniture is built with engineered woods like MDF and particle board, finished with veneers or laminate. While this keeps costs down, these surfaces are prone to chipping and scratching. Upholstery typically uses synthetic performance fabrics and standard foam cushions that can flatten within 1-2 years of heavy use.
- Construction: Pomelo uses standard, cost-effective construction methods. This includes machine-cut joints held by dowels, staples, and cam locks rather than more durable techniques like dovetail or mortise-and-tenon joinery. While generally functional, hardware may loosen over time with use.
- Durability and Longevity: Most pieces are designed for a 2-3 year lifespan under normal household conditions. They hold up reasonably well in low-traffic areas but are not built to withstand heavy daily use, kids, or pets without showing significant wear.
- Common Complaints: Customer feedback frequently points to inconsistent quality control. Common issues include pieces arriving with chipped veneers or scratches from shipping, wobbly legs on tables and chairs after a few months, and cushions that sag or lose their shape quickly.
Is Pomelo Good Value for the Price?
Pomelo offers fair value, particularly for shoppers who want a trendy look without a large financial commitment. The value proposition is entirely based on getting contemporary style for less, not on a long-term investment.
Price Positioning
Pomelo occupies a space between budget brands like IKEA and more premium mid-range players like West Elm. You can expect to pay $600-$1,200 for a sofa, $150-$400 for a coffee table, and $80-$200 per dining chair. This pricing is slightly higher than an entry-level IKEA piece but significantly more accessible than brands known for solid wood construction.
What You're Paying For
With Pomelo, you are primarily paying for design. Their aesthetic is modern, minimalist, and on-trend, making them an excellent choice for achieving a specific look on a budget. You are not paying for premium materials, intricate craftsmanship, or furniture designed to last a decade.
Where You Get Good Value
- Accent Furniture: Side tables, consoles, and decorative chairs that won't see heavy daily use are great buys. You get the high-end look without needing robust durability.
- Decor & Accessories: Items like vases, mirrors, and lighting offer a cheap and easy way to incorporate Pomelo's modern style into your space.
- Short-Term Living Situations: For renters, students, or anyone furnishing a temporary space, Pomelo offers stylish solutions that you won't feel bad about leaving behind in a few years.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- High-Traffic Seating: A main family sofa or heavily used armchair will likely show its weaknesses quickly, with sagging cushions and frame-wobble being common complaints.
- Daily-Use Dining Furniture: Dining tables and chairs made from veneered MDF won't stand up well to the spills, scratches, and constant movement of family dinners.
- "Forever" Furniture: If you're looking for an investment piece to keep for 5+ years, Pomelo is not the right choice. The cost-per-year of ownership is high due to the short lifespan.
Pomelo Quality by Category
Quality can vary significantly depending on what you're buying. Here's a quick guide to their main product lines.
Sofas & Sectionals
Priced typically from $600-$1,200, Pomelo sofas feature synthetic fabrics over standard foam cushions and engineered wood frames. While they look sharp, the cushions are a known weak point and can begin to sag within 1-2 years. Verdict: A good option for a formal living room or low-traffic area, but not recommended for a primary family sofa.
Bedroom Furniture
Beds and dressers often use MDF with veneer or laminate finishes. The look is clean and modern, but durability is a concern. Drawer construction is basic, and surfaces can easily scratch or chip. Verdict: Suitable for a guest room or for temporary use but unlikely to withstand multiple moves or long-term daily wear.
Dining Furniture
Dining tables and chairs suffer from the same material limitations. Veneered surfaces are susceptible to water damage and scratches, and the joinery on chairs may loosen over time, leading to wobbling. Verdict: Best for light use in a dining nook, avoid for a high-traffic family dining room.
Decor & Accessories
Ranging from $20-$100, decorative items like vases, artwork, and small lamps are where Pomelo shines. Quality is akin to what you'd find at Target or HomeGoods, but with a more curated, modern aesthetic. Verdict: A great, low-risk way to add some on-trend style to your home.
Our Verdict: Is Pomelo Worth It?
Pomelo is worth considering for a specific type of shopper: someone who values current design trends and low prices far more than durability. If you are furnishing a space for the short term and want it to look great, Pomelo provides that. For anyone seeking furniture that will last, it's best to look elsewhere.
Quality Grade: B-
Pomelo earns a B- because its products generally function and look as advertised for a reasonable period. The grade is held back by the prevalent use of budget materials like MDF and standard foam, inconsistent quality control, and a design life of only 2-3 years. While the aesthetic is strong, the underlying construction is average at best.
Value Grade: C+
The value here is fair but not exceptional. While the prices are low, the short lifespan means you're not getting a great long-term return on your investment. If an $800 sofa only lasts you two years, its cost of ownership is $400/year - potentially higher than a more durable $1,500 sofa that lasts five years. The C+ reflects good upfront value for style that is tempered by poor long-term economic sense.
Better Alternatives to Pomelo
If the limited durability of Pomelo concerns you, here are some alternatives that offer similar styles with better construction, reliability, or more cost-effectiveness.
Article
Article offers a similar mid-century modern aesthetic with superior materials, including solid wood options and high-density foam cushions. While prices are moderately higher, their direct-to-consumer model provides furniture built to last 5-7 years, offering far better long-term value.
Shop now at article.com
Joybird
Specializing in customizable upholstered furniture, Joybird uses kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-quality foams. Their pieces are significantly more expensive but are built with heirloom-level attention to detail and come with strong warranties, making them a true long-term investment.
Shop now at joybird.com
Burrow
Known for its clever modular sofas, Burrow uses durable materials like sustainably-forested hardwood frames and non-toxic, stain-resistant fabrics. Their furniture is designed for real life, with built-in chargers and a focus on longevity, making them a practical and durable upgrade from Pomelo.
Shop now at burrow.com
West Elm
As a step up in price and quality, West Elm offers a broader range of styles with better materials, including solid wood and more performance fabric options. While pricier, their pieces generally have a longer lifespan, bridging the gap between budget decor and high-end furniture.
Shop now at westelm.com
AllModern
A part of Wayfair, AllModern provides a huge selection of on-trend modern furniture that often features better materials than Pomelo for a comparable price. Look for items specifically describing solid wood construction for a noticeable upgrade in durability.
Shop now at allmodern.com
IKEA
For those questioning Pomelo’s value, IKEA often offers similar or better quality on its higher-end lines (like the STOCKHOLM or EKTORP series) for a lower price. While not always as chic, the value proposition for durable, functional furniture is often stronger.
Shop now at ikea.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does Pomelo furniture actually last?
With moderate, careful use, you can realistically expect most Pomelo furniture to last about 2-3 years. High-traffic items like a primary sofa or dining table may show significant wear, such as sagging cushions or surface chipping, within 1-2 years.
Is Pomelo better quality than IKEA?
Pomelo often prioritizes trend-forward design over IKEA’s focus on functionalism, so pieces might look more stylish. However, the underlying quality is very similar to IKEA's mid-tier ranges. IKEA's higher-end product lines often offer better materials and durability for a comparable or lower price.
What are the most common complaints about Pomelo?
The most frequent customer complaints involve damage during shipping (chipped veneers, scratches), a lack of long-term durability (sagging cushions, wobbly joints), and an assembly process that can be frustrating due to unclear instructions or missing hardware.
Does Pomelo furniture require assembly?
Yes, the vast majority of Pomelo furniture arrives flat-packed and requires assembly. Customers generally report that it takes 1-2 hours per piece, but warn that the included instructions can sometimes be overly simplistic or difficult to follow.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
