Naturepedic is worth it if you are looking for a top-tier organic mattress and can afford the premium price. Their products deliver exceptional quality with certified non-toxic materials, making them a wise investment for health-conscious individuals, families with young children, and anyone with chemical sensitivities or allergies.
While more expensive than mainstream brands, you are paying for durable, U.S.-made construction and the peace of mind that comes with a verifiably safe and organic sleep environment. Here's a detailed breakdown of Naturepedic's quality, value, and what you need to know before buying.
How Is Naturepedic's Quality?
Naturepedic's quality is excellent, placing it in the top tier of mattress brands. Their focus is on using premium, certified organic materials combined with meticulous U.S.-based manufacturing. Here's what sets them apart:
- Certified Organic Materials: The brand uses USDA Organic cotton, organic wool as a natural flame retardant (eliminating chemical sprays), and GOLS-certified organic latex. These materials are not only non-toxic but also naturally durable, breathable, and resistant to dust mites.
- High-Quality Construction: Mattresses feature hand-stitched seams, high-density quilting, and inner layers assembled with eco-friendly adhesives, avoiding formaldehyde and other VOCs. Their mattresses are significantly heavier than competitors, indicating dense and substantial materials.
- Long-Term Durability: Customer reports and material science confirm these mattresses are built to last. Many owners report minimal sagging and consistent support after 8-15 years of use, which is backed by a 20-year warranty. The robust steel coils and resilient organic latex hold their shape extremely well over time.
- Common Complaints: Issues are rare, but some long-term owners (7+ years) mention occasional coil squeaks developing. A small number of new customers also note a natural, earthy "off-gassing" from the wool and latex that typically dissipates within a week.
Is Naturepedic Good Value for the Price?
Naturepedic offers good value for a specific type of buyer: one who prioritizes health and durability over the lowest possible price. While not cheap, the cost is justified by the materials and construction.
Price Positioning
Naturepedic mattress prices range from approximately $1,200 to $4,500. A Queen Organic Cotton Classic mattress costs around $2,300, which is competitively priced against other certified organic brands like Avocado and Saatva Organic. It is significantly more expensive than non-organic, direct-to-consumer brands like Casper or Tuft & Needle, which use synthetic foams and chemically treated materials.
What You're Paying For
You’re paying for third-party certified safety and high-quality natural materials. The price includes GOTS/GOLS organic certifications, USDA Organic material sourcing, chemical-free fire retardants, and skilled labor in their Ohio-based factory. The 20-year warranty also reflects the brand's confidence in its long-term durability, adding to the overall value proposition.
Where You Get Good Value
- Crib & Kids Mattresses: Unbeatable value for parents prioritizing a non-toxic sleep environment for their children. The safety aspect justifies the entire cost.
- Allergy & Chemical Sensitivities: For those with health concerns, the hypoallergenic and chemical-free nature provides immense value that commodity mattresses cannot.
- Long-Term Investment: If you plan to keep your mattress for 10-20 years, the cost-per-year is competitive, as it will outlast cheaper foam mattresses by a significant margin.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Budget Shoppers: If your primary concern is price, you can find comfortable mattresses for a fraction of the cost from mainstream brands using conventional materials.
- Guest Rooms: For a bed that gets infrequent use, the expense and organic benefits may be unnecessary.
- Those Unconcerned with Organics: If you aren't focused on non-toxic materials, the price premium for certifications won't seem justified.
Naturepedic Quality by Category
Quality is consistently high across Naturepedic's product lines, but their value shines brightest in specific categories.
Crib & Kids Mattresses
This is Naturepedic's standout category. Crib mattresses feature GOTS-certified fabrics, food-grade waterproof surfaces (made from non-GMO sugarcane), and are completely free of flame retardants, adhesives, and vinyl/PVC. Priced from $250-$500, they are considered by many parents to be the gold standard for infant sleep safety and well worth the investment.
Adult Mattresses (EOS, Chorus & Serenade)
Naturepedic's adult mattresses range from innerspring (Chorus) to customizable latex and coil hybrids (EOS). They all feature organic cotton and wool, supportive coil systems, and options for organic latex. Price ranges from $2,000 to $4,500+ for a Queen. They offer excellent support and durability and are a great choice for adults who want to eliminate chemicals from their bedroom.
Bedding, Pillows & Toppers
Using the same GOTS-certified materials, Naturepedic toppers and pillows extend the organic sleep system. Their Trio Organic Pillow, for example, features customizable layers of shredded latex and PLA. While premium-priced, the quality is top-notch, breathable, and a good fit for those who already love their mattresses.
Our Verdict: Is Naturepedic Worth It?
Yes, Naturepedic mattresses are worth the investment for buyers who prioritize certified organic materials, non-toxic construction, and long-term durability. It is one of the safest and healthiest mattress brands on the market, especially for infants and children.
Quality Grade: A-
Naturepedic earns an A- for its unwavering commitment to premium, certified-organic components and meticulous U.S.-based craftsmanship. Materials like organic wool, cotton, and latex are top-of-the-line. The only reason it misses a full A is due to infrequent but consistent long-term reports of minor coil noise in some models.
Value Grade: B+
The value here is a B+. Naturepedic provides excellent long-term durability and invaluable health benefits, justifying the premium price for the right customer. However, the high upfront cost makes it less accessible to the average buyer, preventing it from earning a top grade purely based on price-to-comfort ratio.
More Quality Brands Like Naturepedic
If you love Naturepedic's commitment to craftsmanship and healthy materials, here are some other brands with similar high standards worth checking out:
Avocado Green Mattress
Avocado is another leader in certified organic mattresses, using GOLS organic latex, GOTS organic wool, and cotton with a similar eco-conscious mission. Their mattresses have a slightly firmer, more buoyant feel and are Climate Neutral Certified, appealing to sustainability-focused shoppers at a similar price point.
Shop now at avocadogreenmattress.com
Saatva
While not exclusively organic, Saatva’s Latex Hybrid model uses Talalay latex, organic cotton, and recycled steel coils, offering a luxury feel with eco-friendly components. They are known for free white-glove delivery and excellent customer service, competing with Naturepedic on premium quality and feel.
Shop now at saatva.com
Birch by Helix
Birch offers a natural and GREENGUARD Gold certified latex hybrid mattress at a more competitive price point than Naturepedic or Avocado. They use natural latex, organic cotton, and wool, providing a great non-toxic option for shoppers who want organic materials but are looking for a slightly more affordable entry point.
Shop now at birchliving.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are Naturepedic mattresses so expensive?
Naturepedic's pricing reflects the high cost of its materials and manufacturing. Sourcing GOTS-certified organic cotton, GOLS-certified organic latex, and manufacturing entirely in the U.S. with skilled labor is significantly more expensive than using synthetic foams and imported components.
Do Naturepedic mattresses smell?
Naturepedic mattresses do not have the chemical "off-gassing" smell common with memory foam mattresses. Some customers report a faint, natural, earthy smell from the organic wool and latex, which is non-toxic and typically disappears completely within a few days of unboxing.
How long do Naturepedic mattresses last?
With proper care, a Naturepedic mattress is designed to last 15-20 years, far exceeding the 7-10 year lifespan of a typical mattress. Their high-density materials and supportive coils resist sagging and body impressions, and every adult mattress comes with a 20-year limited warranty.
Are Naturepedic mattresses good for allergies?
Yes, they are an excellent choice for allergy sufferers. The organic wool and latex are naturally resistant to dust mites, mold, and mildew. Furthermore, the absence of harsh chemicals, glues, and flame retardants helps reduce exposure to common irritants that can trigger allergies and respiratory sensitivities.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
