The short answer is yes, Mixtiles are worth it if you’re looking for a fast, easy, and damage-free way to create a personalized photo wall. Their products excel at delivering a modern aesthetic and incredible convenience, allowing you to build a gallery wall in minutes without any tools.
However, they are not a substitute for high-end, archival-quality framed art. Mixtiles are a mid-range decor solution designed for style and flexibility over heirloom longevity. Here’s a detailed breakdown of their quality, value, and what you need to know before buying.
How Is Mixtiles' Quality?
Mixtiles offers respectable, B-grade quality that prioritizes convenience and looks over premium materials. The print quality is high, but the overall product is not built to be a permanent fixture. Here’s what to expect:
- Construction & Materials: Each tile consists of a photographic print mounted on a lightweight composite backing. It's a sturdy but thin material that can feel plasticky compared to traditional wood or acrylic frames. The focus is on being light enough to hang with adhesive, not on a robust, substantive feel.
- Print Quality: This is a major strength. Most customers find the photo reproduction to be sharp, with accurate colors and high resolution. The quality is comparable to what you’d receive from professional photo printing services.
- Adhesive & Repositioning: The peel-and-stick adhesive is designed to be removed and repositioned without damaging walls. While it works well initially, the adhesive strength diminishes with each move, potentially leading to tiles falling off over time.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues are related to long-term durability. Customers report edge peeling and tiles lifting after 1-2 years, especially on textured walls or in humid environments like bathrooms. Prints exposed to direct sunlight can also begin to fade within a few years.
Is Mixtiles Good Value for the Price?
For the convenience they offer, Mixtiles provide good value. You are paying for a simple, all-in-one solution that solves the common problems of hanging pictures: wall damage, expensive framing, and complex layouts.
Price Positioning
Mixtiles are typically priced around $99 for a pack of nine tiles, making each tile about $11. Shipping usually adds a flat fee of around $7.99. This positions them in the mid-range of photo decor - more expensive than printing photos yourself at Shutterfly, but significantly cheaper than custom framing at a shop like Framebridge.
What You're Paying For
You’re paying primarily for convenience and a modern aesthetic. The value comes from the ability to upload photos from your phone and have gallery-ready, self-adhering tiles arrive at your door. The damage-free, tool-free installation is a huge selling point for renters, dorm residents, or anyone hesitant to put nails in their walls.
Where You Get Good Value
- Renters or temporary spaces: Perfect for decorating without losing your security deposit.
- Dynamic gallery walls: Easily create and rearrange large photo displays as your collection grows.
- Kid's rooms or hallways: A lightweight, safe alternative to heavy frames with glass.
- Quick home updates: Instantly personalize a space with minimal effort and no tools required.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Heirloom photos: Important, one-of-a-kind photos deserve archival materials for long-term preservation.
- Textured walls: The adhesive doesn’t stick well to bumpy or uneven surfaces, leading to peeling and falling.
- Humid environments: Kitchens and bathrooms can weaken the adhesive and cause the tiles to detach.
- Rooms with direct sunlight: The prints are not UV-protected and will fade over 2-3 years with constant sun exposure.
Our Verdict: Is Mixtiles Worth It?
Mixtiles are absolutely worth it for the right person and the right space. If you value ease of use, a clean modern look, and the flexibility to decorate without permanent commitment, they are an excellent choice. However, if you are looking for heirloom quality or a true long-term art piece, you should invest in traditional framing or higher-end canvas prints.
Quality Grade: B
Mixtiles earns a B for quality. The print resolution is excellent, and the product delivers exactly what it promises: a lightweight, easy-to-hang photo tile. It loses points for its non-premium composite materials and an adhesive system that isn’t foolproof, with known issues of peeling and fading over a couple of years. It’s well-made for a temporary decor item but doesn’t compete with archival-quality framing.
Value Grade: B
At around $11 per tile, the value is solid. You're getting a fully finished product that solves a common decorating problem elegantly. While you could technically print and hang photos for less, Mixtiles removes all the friction from the process. Its value is tied directly to convenience and the damage-free guarantee, making it a fair trade-off for its lower long-term durability.
Better Alternatives to Mixtiles
If you're looking for something with greater durability, higher-end materials, or a different aesthetic, consider these alternatives to create your perfect wall display.
Framebridge
For turning personal photos into heirloom pieces, Framebridge offers high-quality custom framing with solid wood frames, UV-protected acrylic, and archival mats. It’s more expensive, but it provides a permanent, protected display for your most cherished memories.
Shop now at framebridge.com
CanvasPop
If you love the frameless look but want higher quality, CanvasPop specializes in gallery-quality canvas prints. Their products feature thick, durable canvas and vibrant, long-lasting inks, making them a great step-up for a more permanent and impactful photo display.
Shop now at canvaspop.com
Photowall
Photowall offers a wide variety of wall murals, canvas prints, and framed art with a focus on premium materials and durability. It’s an excellent choice for a statement piece or gallery-grade art meant to last for decades instead of years.
Shop now at photowall.com
Art.com
For endless variety on a budget, Art.com offers a massive selection of posters and art prints that you can buy standalone or with a frame. While the quality is a step below custom framing, it provides an affordable way to decorate with specific art styles beyond your own photos.
Shop now at art.com
Saatchi Art
If you’re looking for original artwork instead of personal photos, Saatchi Art is a curated online gallery for discovering art from emerging artists worldwide. This is an investment in fine art, offering a much more upscale and unique alternative for your walls.
Shop now at saatchiart.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Do Mixtiles damage walls?
Mixtiles are specifically designed not to damage walls. The peel-and-stick adhesive can be removed cleanly from most properly painted surfaces. However, on walls with flat paint or weak plaster, there is a small risk of paint chipping upon removal.
How long do Mixtiles last?
Under ideal indoor conditions (away from direct sun and humidity), Mixtiles should last for several years. However, customer reports suggest you might see some fading or edge peeling after 1-2 years, especially if they are repositioned or exposed to harsh conditions.
Can you reuse or reposition Mixtiles?
Yes, they are designed to be moved and rearranged. That said, the adhesive becomes less effective with each reapplication. It's best to plan your layout carefully to minimize how often you need to move them.
Do Mixtiles work on textured walls?
Mixtiles work best on smooth, clean surfaces. They are not recommended for heavily textured walls (like stucco or orange peel finishes), as the adhesive can't create a strong enough bond, causing the tiles to peel or fall off.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
