Invicta watches are worth it for buyers prioritizing bold, statement designs on a tight budget, but they are not a good choice for those seeking long-term durability or fine watchmaking. The brand excels at offering the look and feel of luxury watches for RRPs under $200 but cuts corners on quality control, finishing, and movement consistency to achieve those prices.
Simply put, Invicta is a fashion-first brand. Think of them as a great option for a stylish, occasional-wear piece, but look elsewhere if you want a reliable, daily-wear watch that will last for years. Here’s what you need to know before you buy.
How Is Invicta's Quality?
Invicta's quality is highly inconsistent and varies dramatically between their budget-friendly fashion models and their more premium collections. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:
- Materials: Most watches use stainless steel cases, which are standard for the price. The biggest variable is the crystal, most entry-level models use mineral glass, which scratches more easily, while higher-end lines like the Reserve collection upgrade to more durable sapphire crystals.
- Movements: Invicta uses a wide range of movements. Their affordable quartz watches typically feature reliable Japanese movements from Seiko or Miyota, which are accurate and durable. Their popular automatic models, like the Pro Diver, often use a non-branded Seiko automatic movement, while their premium watches may feature Swiss automatic movements from makers like Sellita or ETA. The quality here is generally good and dictated by the price point.
- Construction & Finishing: This is Invicta's biggest weakness. While the watches often feel heavy and substantial, closer inspection can reveal rough edges, poorly finished components, and inconsistent assembly. Quality control is a frequently cited issue among customers.
- Common Complaints: Customer reviews often mention issues with water resistance failing to meet the stated rating, bezels or crowns becoming loose, and finishes (especially gold plating) wearing off prematurely. These problems are more common in their sub-$150 watches.
Is Invicta Good Value for the Price?
Invicta's value is based almost entirely on aesthetics over craftsmanship. You get a lot of visual impact for your money, but you sacrifice the reliability and refinement found in competing brands at similar price points.
Price Positioning
Invicta operates in the low-to-mid range of the watch market. Entry-level quartz models can be found for $50-$150, popular automatics like the Pro Diver sit in the $150-$300 range, and their premium "Reserve" collection can cost $300-$600+. While their Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) is often dramatically inflated, their actual street price puts them in direct competition with brands like Seiko, Citizen, and Orient.
What You're Paying For
You are paying primarily for eye-catching design. Many of Invicta's most popular models are "homages" or direct copies of iconic luxury watches from brands like Rolex and Breitling. The value proposition is getting that high-end look for a tiny fraction of the cost, making them ideal statement pieces for those on a budget.
Where You Get Good Value
- Fashion Pieces: If you want a large, flashy watch to wear occasionally for style, Invicta offers excellent aesthetic value under $200.
- Quartz Models: For pure reliability, their watches with Japanese quartz movements offer the best value, as these movements are accurate and require minimal maintenance.
- Trying a Style: If you love the look of a Rolex Submariner but can't spend thousands, an Invicta Pro Diver for around $80 lets you try the style without financial risk.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Daily Wear: If you need a watch that can stand up to daily abuse, the inconsistent quality control makes Invicta a risky choice.
- Heirloom Quality: Invicta watches are not built to last generations. The materials and construction will not hold up over decades of wear.
- Investment Value: Unlike collectible brands, Invicta watches have virtually no resale value and depreciate immediately.
Invicta Quality by Collection
Quality and materials change significantly depending on which Invicta collection you are buying from.
Entry-Level Fashion Models (Under $150)
These models focus entirely on trend-driven design. They feature Japanese quartz movements, mineral glass crystals, and basic stainless steel cases, often with plated finishes. They're built for looks, not longevity, expect them to last 2-3 years with careful wear before showing significant signs of aging like scratched crystals or fading finishes. Verdict: A decent buy for a specific look on a shoestring budget.
Pro Diver Series ($100 - $300)
The Pro Diver is Invicta's most famous model, directly mimicking the Rolex Submariner. For the price, you get decent materials, including a stainless steel case and often a reliable Seiko automatic movement. However, the water resistance claims are a common point of contention, with many owners reporting issues. Verdict: A very popular and affordable entry into automatic "diver-style" watches, but do not trust it for actual diving.
Reserve Collection ($300 - $600+)
The Reserve line is where Invicta puts its best foot forward. These watches feature superior materials like sapphire crystals, more complex designs, and are often powered by higher-quality Swiss-made automatic or quartz movements. The finishing and overall construction are a clear step up from their cheaper models. Verdict: Offers better quality, but at this price point, you are often better served by more reputable brands like Tissot or Certina.
Our Verdict: Is Invicta Worth It?
Invicta is best approached as a fast-fashion brand for watches. If you want a bold, attention-grabbing accessory at an unbeatable price and don't expect it to last a lifetime, it offers a compelling package. However, for anyone seeking genuine craftsmanship, daily-driver reliability, or long-term value, your money is better spent elsewhere.
Quality Grade: C+
Invicta earns a C+ for quality because while it uses reliable third-party movements (like Seiko quartz), the brand is held back by consistent reports of poor quality control, weak water resistance, and subpar finishing. The materials used are generally acceptable for the price tier, but the execution is too inconsistent to earn a higher grade. Some premium models are built better, but they can't lift the overall reputation of the brand.
Value Grade: B-
The value grade is a B- because, from a pure style-per-dollar perspective, Invicta is hard to beat. You can get a massive chronograph or a classic diver homage for under a hundred bucks, which is great for those exploring styles. The grade is held back because the poor durability and potential repair costs diminish the long-term value proposition significantly compared to more robust competitors.
Better Alternatives to Invicta
If Invicta's inconsistent quality and reliance on "homage" designs aren't for you, these alternatives offer better durability and originality at similar prices.
Seiko 5 Sports
Known as the ultimate entry-level automatic watch, the Seiko 5 line offers legendary durability, in-house mechanical movements, and excellent build quality, often for under $300. They are a true workhorse watch and a far more durable pick for a daily driver.
Shop now at seikousa.com
Citizen Eco-Drive
Citizen's proprietary Eco-Drive technology uses light to power the watch, eliminating the need for battery replacements. They are famously reliable, well-built, and offer a wide variety of styles in the $150-$500 range that easily outperform Invicta in longevity.
Shop now at citizenwatch.com
Orient
A subsidiary of Seiko, Orient is beloved by watch enthusiasts for offering incredible value. Their models like the Bambino (dress) and Mako (diver) feature high-quality in-house automatic movements and superior finishing for under $200-$300, making them a fantastic alternative to Invicta Automatics.
Shop now at orientwatchusa.com
Fossil
If your main goal is fashionable design, Fossil is a direct competitor that offers a similar range of styles and price points. Their build quality is often considered slightly more consistent than Invicta's for trendy, modern designs.
Shop now at fossil.com
Tissot
If your budget can stretch to the higher end of Invicta's offerings ($300-$500), Tissot offers a genuine Swiss-made watch with a sapphire crystal and far better craftsmanship. The Tissot PRC 200 is a perfect example of a significant step up in quality and brand reputation for a little more money.
Shop now at tissotwatches.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Why is Invicta controversial in the watch community?
Invicta is often criticized by watch enthusiasts for two main reasons: heavily "borrowing" iconic designs from luxury brands like Rolex without adding their own creative input, and using a deceptive pricing strategy where watches are given a hugely inflated MSRP and then sold at a perpetual 80-90% discount to create a false sense of value.
Are Invicta Pro Divers good for actual diving?
No, you should not trust an Invicta Pro Diver for serious diving. Despite having "Diver" in the name and a water resistance rating of 200 meters, many owners have reported leaking and failed seals with minimal water exposure. For a reliable, budget-friendly dive watch, look to the Citizen Promaster or Seiko SKX series.
Which Invicta movements are the best?
Invicta's Japanese quartz movements (often from Miyota or an affiliate of Seiko) are the most reliable and hassle-free, especially for their lower-priced models. For mechanical watches, their premium models with Swiss Sellita or ETA movements are a clear step up from the base Seiko NH35A movements found in their cheaper automatics.
Are Invicta's deals and high discounts on TV real?
The massive discounts are misleading. The Manufacturer's Suggested Retail Price (MSRP) is an artificially high number that the watch never actually sells for. The "Sale Price" is the watch's true everyday price, and is intentionally marketed as a limited-time deal to create purchasing urgency for what's actually an affordably-produced watch.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
