No, Broyhill furniture is generally not considered "good" quality in terms of long-term durability. It offers acceptable quality and decent value for budget-conscious shoppers who prioritize current styles over heirloom construction.
The brand specializes in affordable furniture that looks great but is not built to last for decades, typically using materials like particleboard and standard-density foams. It's a practical choice for temporary situations or low-use areas, but most pieces will not withstand heavy daily wear for more than 3-5 years. Here's a detailed breakdown of what to know before you buy.
How Is Broyhill's Quality?
Broyhill's quality is firmly in the mid-to-low range, with construction practices aimed at keeping costs down. Materials and craftsmanship are adequate for the price but fall short when compared to higher-end brands.
- Materials: The majority of Broyhill case goods (dressers, tables, etc.) are made with engineered wood like particleboard or MDF topped with a wood veneer or laminate finish. This construction is prone to chipping, peeling, and water damage over time.
- Frame Construction: Sofas typically use particleboard frames, sometimes with plywood reinforcements at stress points, rather than solid hardwood. This can lead to creaking, wobbling, or breaking with heavy use. Support is usually provided by sinuous wire springs, a standard for budget-friendly upholstery.
- Upholstery and Cushions: Upholstery is often made of polyester or polyester blends, which are stain-resistant but can pill or fade. Cushions are typically filled with medium-density foam (around 1.8 lb/cu ft), which provides initial comfort but is known to sag and develop indentations within 2-3 years.
- Common Complaints: Customer reviews frequently mention cushions flattening prematurely, veneer peeling at the edges, loose or wobbly legs, and drawers breaking down. The overall sentiment is that the furniture looks good at first but shows its age quickly.
Is Broyhill Good Value for the Price?
Broyhill offers decent initial value by providing trendy designs at very low prices, but this value diminishes quickly due to poor longevity. It's a classic case of getting what you pay for.
Price Positioning
Broyhill competes directly with brands like Ashley Furniture and Signature Design by Ashley, often at a slightly lower price point. Sofas typically cost between $600 and $1,200, beds range from $300 to $700, and dining tables are around $400 to $800. These prices are significantly lower than mid-range brands that use more durable materials like solid wood frames.
What You're Paying For
With Broyhill, you are primarily paying for style and accessibility. The brand is skilled at reproducing popular, high-end designs using more economical materials. You're getting a trendy look for a low upfront cost, but not the construction quality or durability needed for a long-term investment.
Where You Get Good Value
- Temporary Solutions: Ideal for furnishing a first apartment, dorm room, or for someone who moves often and doesn't want to invest in heavy, expensive furniture.
- Low-Traffic Areas: A Broyhill accent chair in a guest room or a console table in a rarely used hallway can be a great value.
- Bedroom Sets: Beds and dressers often receive higher satisfaction ratings as they are subjected to less dynamic stress than sofas or dining chairs.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- High-Use Sofas: A family sofa used daily for watching TV is likely to sag and creak within a few years, making it a poor long-term value.
- Dining Room Furniture: Dining tables and chairs that see daily family use will quickly show scratches, peeling veneer, and wobbly joints.
- Long-Term Investments: If you're looking for furniture to last 5+ years, the cost of replacing a Broyhill piece negates any initial savings.
Broyhill Quality by Category
Quality can vary slightly depending on the type of product you purchase.
Sofas & Sectionals
Broyhill sofas and sectionals are some of their weakest products in terms of durability. Built on particleboard frames with basic sinuous springs and medium-density foam, they are prone to sagging and frame issues within 2-4 years of regular use. These are best for formal living rooms or low-traffic areas.
Bedroom Furniture
Beds and dressers tend to fare better than upholstered items. While primarily made of engineered wood, their static nature means they hold up reasonably well if not subjected to rough use or frequent moves. Drawer construction can be flimsy, so avoid overloading them.
Dining Furniture
Veneer or laminate tabletop finishes on Broyhill dining sets are susceptible to scratches, heat marks, and moisture damage. The chairs, also typically made from engineered or lower-grade wood, can develop wobbly legs and loose joints quickly with regular use.
Storage & Case Goods
Items like bookcases, TV stands, and coffee tables have the same construction limitations as other categories. Laminated particleboard is standard, which can sag under the weight of heavy books or electronics. These are functional for light storage and display but are not built for heavy loads.
Our Verdict: Is Broyhill Worth It?
Broyhill is worth it only for shoppers who prioritize immediate affordability and style over durability and longevity. It serves a purpose for short-term furniture needs but should not be considered a lasting investment for your home.
Quality Grade: C
Broyhill earns a C for quality. It delivers on its promise of accessible style, and pieces are functional for light to moderate use. However, the widespread reliance on engineered wood, particleboard frames, and low-density cushions results in a short lifespan that prevents it from earning a higher grade. Inconsistent quality control and common customer complaints about premature wear are significant drawbacks.
Value Grade: C+
For value, Broyhill gets a C+. While the upfront prices are very attractive, the furniture's short durability (often 3-5 years) means you will be replacing it sooner than you would with a slightly more expensive brand. The true value is low for anyone seeking furniture to last beyond a few years, but for a temporary or budget-first solution, it provides a functional and stylish product for the money.
Better Alternatives to Broyhill
If Broyhill's durability concerns you, these retailers offer better quality furniture for a comparable or moderately higher price.
Ashley Furniture
Ashley Furniture offers a wider variety of collections, including some with more durable construction like solid wood components and kiln-dried hardwood frames. While still a budget-friendly brand, their mid-tier lines generally offer a significant step up in durability compared to Broyhill for a minor increase in price.
Shop now at ashleyfurniture.com
IKEA
IKEA provides more value for a similar price. While also heavily using engineered wood, their design, hardware, and engineering are often superior, leading to better structural integrity. IKEA's modularity and vast selection make it a more versatile choice for budget-conscious shoppers who value functional design.
Shop now at ikea.com
Wayfair (in-house brands like Laurel Foundry & Rivet)
Wayfair’s curated brands often offer better materials and more transparent construction details than Broyhill. Look for collections that specify solid wood frames or kiln-dried hardwood to get a durable piece at a competitive mid-range price point, balancing style and quality effectively.
Shop now at wayfair.com
Article
Article is a direct-to-consumer brand that offers a substantial quality upgrade for a moderately higher price. You can get a sofa with a solid wood frame, high-density foam cushions, and quality upholstery for what a high-end Broyhill piece might cost, resulting in far better long-term value.
Shop now at article.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Broyhill furniture made of solid wood?
No, the vast majority of Broyhill furniture is not made of solid wood. It primarily uses engineered woods like particleboard and MDF with wood veneers or laminate finishes to keep costs low. Solid wood components are rare and would only be found in select, higher-priced items.
How long does Broyhill furniture last?
With moderate use, you can realistically expect Broyhill furniture to last 3 to 5 years. High-use items like a family sofa may show significant wear, such as sagging cushions or a creaking frame, in as little as 2-3 years. Higher-end pieces used gently may last up to 7 years.
Is Broyhill better quality than Ashley Furniture?
No, Ashley Furniture generally offers better quality options than Broyhill. While both brands have entry-level lines, Ashley has a broader catalog with mid-tier collections that use more durable materials, including kiln-dried hardwood frames and higher-density foam cushions, giving it an edge in longevity.
Where is Broyhill furniture sold today?
Broyhill is primarily sold through major discount retailers and online stores. You can find their collections at Big Lots, Amazon, Wayfair, and other independent furniture outlets, making it a highly accessible brand for budget shoppers.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
