Yes, for most people seeking a significant upgrade from big-box store bedding without paying for ultra-luxury brands, Brooklinen is absolutely worth it. The brand excels at delivering a premium feel and reliable durability by using high-quality materials like long-staple cotton, all at a fair, direct-to-consumer price point.
While not heirloom-level, Brooklinen's quality consistently outperforms its price tag, especially in its core bedding collections. Think of it as attainable luxury: you're getting 80% of the ultra-premium experience for about 30% of the cost. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what you need to know before you buy.
How Is Brooklinen's Quality?
Brooklinen's quality is consistent and impressive for its market position, focusing on excellent materials and solid construction rather than unnecessary frills. Here's what sets them apart:
- High-Quality Materials: The brand primarily uses long-staple cottons (including Egyptian and Supima) in its sheets. These longer fibers result in stronger, softer, and more durable threads that resist pilling and tearing much better than the short-staple cotton found in cheaper bedding.
- Solid Construction: Their sheets feature thread counts between 300-480, a range that offers an ideal balance of softness and breathability. Manufacturing details like mitered corners, reinforced hems, and sturdy elastic on fitted sheets demonstrate a commitment to craftsmanship that ensures products hold up to regular use and washing.
- Reliable Durability: With proper care (washing cold, tumble drying low), Brooklinen sheets typically last between 3 and 5 years, retaining much of their softness and color. Their fabrics are known to be colorfast, with minimal fading reported by long-term users.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues are minor but worth noting. The elastic on fitted sheets can stretch out after 2-3 years of heavy use, and their sateen weave sheets are slightly more prone to minor pilling compared to their crisper percale options.
Is Brooklinen Good Value for the Price?
Brooklinen's strongest selling point is its exceptional value. You are paying a mid-range price for a product that feels and performs like a high-end one.
Price Positioning
Brooklinen sits comfortably in the premium-yet-accessible market space. A queen sheet set typically costs between $100 and $160, and duvet covers range from $120 to $180. This positions them significantly above mass-market brands like IKEA or Target but well below ultra-luxury brands like Frette or Sferra, where a single sheet set can easily cost over $500.
What You're Paying For
With Brooklinen, you're paying for three key things: superior raw materials (long-staple cotton), a direct-to-consumer model that eliminates retail markup, and a modern, minimalist aesthetic. Their entire business is built on making luxury-grade home essentials accessible without the traditional brand inflation and distribution costs.
Where You Get Good Value
- Luxe Sateen & Classic Percale Sheets: These are their core products and offer the best pound-for-pound value. You get a truly luxurious sleep experience for a fraction of what competitor brands charge.
- Down & Down Alternative Comforters: Well-constructed and using high-quality fills, their comforters provide excellent warmth and comfort that compete well with brands charging 50% more.
- Bedding Bundles: Buying sheets, pillowcases, and a duvet cover in a bundle almost always provides a significant discount over purchasing items individually, maximizing value.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Limited-Edition "Trendy" Items: Some seasonal or collaboration collections may prioritize style over the substance of their core lines and may not offer the same long-term durability.
- Basic Accessories: While convenient, simpler accessories like laundry bags or eye masks carry the brand premium without necessarily offering better quality than less expensive alternatives.
- Candles and Decor: As Brooklinen expands its product lines, these ancillary items are priced to match the premium brand but don't always stand out in quality compared to brands that specialize in them.
Brooklinen Quality by Category
Quality can vary slightly across Brooklinen's expanding catalog. Here’s how their main product lines stack up:
Sheets & Duvet Covers
This is Brooklinen's flagship category and where their quality shines brightest. Made from long-staple cotton in percale, sateen, linen, or cashmere weaves, they offer exceptional softness and longevity for their cost. Expect a price span of $100-$180 for queen sets. Verdict: This is why the brand is famous - highly recommended.
Towels & Bath
Brooklinen’s bath towels, typically made from Turkish cotton, are plush, highly absorbent, and durable. They are a significant step up from standard department store towels and hold their own against other premium brands like Parachute. They get softer with each wash and resist fraying well. Verdict: A solid, high-quality choice that lives up to the brand's standards.
Blankets & Quilts
Quality in this category is generally strong, with good materials like wool and cotton used in well-designed, functional pieces. Priced between $150 and $300, they offer good comfort and style, though they face stiff competition from specialized textile brands. Verdict: Reliable quality and worth considering, especially during a sale.
Loungewear
Brooklinen's loungewear focuses on simple, comfortable silhouettes and soft materials. The quality is good, but it's not the standout value that their bedding is. While soft and well-made, you might find comparable items from apparel-focused brands for less. Verdict: A nice luxury, but not the best value the brand offers.
Our Verdict: Is Brooklinen Worth It?
Brooklinen is worth it if you are ready to invest in bedding that will noticeably improve your comfort and last for years, but you don't have the budget or desire for true luxury-tier pricing. It's the perfect sweet spot of quality, design, and price. Smart shoppers stick to their core bedding and bath collections to get the best possible value.
Quality Grade: B+
Brooklinen earns a solid B+ for quality. They use excellent raw materials like long-staple cotton and have consistent, durable construction standards that far exceed mass-market options. The only thing holding them back from an 'A' grade is that they are not heirloom quality, minor issues like stretched elastic after several years and occasional pilling on sateen prevent them from competing with the absolute best in the world.
Value Grade: A-
The value proposition is outstanding, earning an A-. Their direct-to-consumer model successfully democratizes premium bedding, making a luxurious feel accessible. While not "cheap," the price-to-quality ratio is one of the best on the market. Buying a Brooklinen sheet set is a smart investment in comfort that pays off over 3-5 years of use.
More Quality Brands Like Brooklinen
If you love Brooklinen's commitment to quality fabrics and modern design, or if you're looking for brands that focus on different materials or eco-conscious manufacturing, here are some other excellent brands to explore:
Parachute Home
Parachute offers a similar aesthetic to Brooklinen but with a greater emphasis on natural, eco-friendly materials like European flax linen and certified organic cotton. Their products are slightly more expensive, but they deliver a relaxed, timeless luxury feel that many find justifies the extra cost.
Shop now at parachutehome.com
Boll & Branch
Boll & Branch is the clear leader for anyone prioritizing ethical and sustainable production. All their products are 100% organic and Fair Trade certified. Their bedding is incredibly soft and durable, positioning them as a premium, eco-conscious alternative at a slightly higher price point than Brooklinen.
Shop now at bollandbranch.com
Snowe
Snowe delivers minimalist, high-quality home essentials with materials sourced from top European mills. Their Egyptian cotton percale sheets are incredibly light and crisp, and their aesthetic aligns well with Brooklinen customers, often with a slightly more refined and luxurious finish.
Shop now at snowehome.com
Cultiver
For true linen lovers, Cultiver is a top-tier choice. They specialize in 100% European flax linen that arrives pre-washed for incredible softness out of the box. They offer a deep and sophisticated color palette beyond the basics, perfect for creating a relaxed, layered bed.
Shop now at cultiver.com
Frette
If you have an unlimited budget and want the absolute best, Frette is the benchmark for ultra-luxury Italian linens. With prices starting over $300 for a sheet set, their products are an investment in heirloom-quality craftsmanship, intricate designs, and the most premium fibers available.
Shop now at frette.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do Brooklinen sheets last?
With proper care, which includes machine washing on a cool or warm cycle and line drying or tumble drying on low, Brooklinen sheets typically last 3 to 5 years. This is significantly longer than cheaper sheets made from short-staple cotton, which often start thinning or pilling after just one year.
Does Brooklinen get softer with washing?
Yes, absolutely. Like most high-quality fabrics made from long-staple cotton or linen, Brooklinen sheets become softer and more comfortable with each wash. The fibers relax and break in over time, contributing to an even cozier feel without losing their structural integrity.
Is Brooklinen better than Parachute?
It depends on your priorities. Brooklinen often wins on price and value, offering a fantastic product for what you pay. Parachute has a slight edge on style for those who prefer an earthy, neutral aesthetic and places a greater emphasis on sustainable materials like European linen and organic cotton, often at a slightly higher price.
What is the best time to buy Brooklinen?
Brooklinen holds several major sales each year, making them the best times to buy. Look out for their Black Friday/Cyber Monday sale and an annual Anniversary Sale in the spring, where they typically offer sitewide discounts of 20-25%.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
