Benchcraft is worth it if you're looking for affordable, trendy furniture for short-term use, but it is not a good long-term investment. As a brand produced by Ashley Furniture, Benchcraft offers contemporary designs at very accessible prices, making it a popular choice for first-time buyers and renters.
The trade-off for the low price is material quality and durability. Most pieces are built to last 3 to 5 years with moderate use before showing significant wear. If you prioritize style and budget over longevity, Benchcraft is a decent option, if you need furniture to withstand heavy daily use, you should look elsewhere.
How Is Benchcraft's Quality?
Benchcraft's quality is average for its price point, relying on materials and construction methods that keep costs down but limit durability. Here’s a detailed breakdown:
- Materials: The core materials are engineered wood like particleboard and MDF, usually covered with a wood-look veneer or laminate. Upholstery is predominantly polyester or poly-blend fabrics with standard foam cushions (typically 1.8 to 2.2 lbs per cubic foot), which are comfortable initially but prone to sagging over time.
- Construction: Frames for sofas and beds are typically built with a mix of engineered wood and some solid wood components attached with standard metal fasteners and staples. The construction is adequate for typical residential use but lacks the reinforced joints and sturdiness of higher-end brands, making it less suitable for heavy wear and tear.
- Durability and Longevity: Most Benchcraft furniture can be expected to last 3-5 years. The most common issues reported by customers are cushion compression, fabric pilling and tearing, and veneer chipping on wood furniture.
- Common Complaints: Customer reviews frequently mention cushions that lose their shape within 2-3 years and frames that develop creaks. Around 20-25% of owners of upholstered items report sagging or fabric tears after just a few years of regular use.
Is Benchcraft Good Value for the Price?
Benchcraft offers strong initial value by making trendy designs extremely affordable. However, its long-term value is diminished by a shorter lifespan compared to more expensive brands.
Price Positioning
Benchcraft is firmly positioned in the budget-friendly furniture market. Sofas typically range from $400 to $900, with beds selling for $300 to $700. These prices are competitive with brands like Ashley's own Signature Design or offerings from large retailers like Wayfair, but the material quality often reflects its lower cost.
What You're Paying For
With Benchcraft, you are primarily paying for style. The brand excels at creating "dupes" of high-end, contemporary, and transitional designs at a fraction of the price. The value proposition is centered on aesthetics and affordability for immediate needs, not on heirloom-quality materials or craftsmanship that will last a decade.
Where You Get Good Value
- First-time apartment furniture: Perfect for furnishing a space on a tight budget when you don't expect the pieces to last forever.
- Low-traffic rooms: Ideal for guest rooms, formal living rooms, or home offices where furniture isn't subjected to heavy daily use.
- Trendy accent pieces: A great choice for stylish chairs or tables you might want to switch out in a few years as trends change.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- High-traffic family rooms: Main family sofas, sectionals, and daily-use dining sets are likely to show wear quickly.
- Investment furniture: If you're looking for furniture to last 7-10 years or more, you won't find that level of durability here.
- Households with kids or pets: The polyester fabrics and engineered wood construction may not hold up well against the rigors of active family life.
Benchcraft Quality by Category
Quality can vary slightly depending on the product, but here's what to generally expect from Benchcraft's major furniture categories.
Sofas & Sectionals
Priced between $400 and $900, Benchcraft sofas use engineered wood frames and low-to-mid-density foam cushions. While comfortable at first, the cushions are a frequent point of complaint, with many owners reporting noticeable sagging within 3 years. This category is a decent option if you need an affordable sofa for a few years, but don't expect it to hold up like more expensive models.
Bedroom Furniture
Beds and dressers (ranging from $300-$700 for beds) are typically made from particleboard with veneer, featuring standard metal hardware. The construction is sufficient for a guest room or a temporary solution, but hardware can loosen over time, and the veneers are susceptible to chipping and peeling, especially in humid environments.
Dining Furniture
Falling in the $300-$1,200 range, dining sets often feature particleboard tabletops that look good new but are prone to warping if exposed to moisture or spills. Dining chairs can become wobbly with daily use due to basic joint construction. These sets are best for occasional dining rather than withstanding the daily wear of a busy family.
Our Verdict: Is Benchcraft Worth It?
Benchcraft is a reasonable choice for budget-conscious buyers who prioritize current styles and affordability over long-term durability. It serves its market well by providing trendy looks for less, but shoppers should be realistic about its 3-to-5-year lifespan for pieces under regular use.
Quality Grade: C+
Benchcraft earns a C+ for its average, mass-market quality. The brand uses industry-standard budget materials like engineered wood, veneers, and polyester fabrics. While the initial appearance is good, the lack of durable materials like solid wood frames or high-density foam means premature wear is common. It meets basic functional standards but doesn't offer lasting craftsmanship.
Value Grade: B-
For what you pay upfront, Benchcraft delivers fair value, landing it a B-. You get on-trend furniture that will look good for a few years at a very low cost. However, the need to replace pieces after just 3-5 years lowers its long-term value significantly compared to spending more on a piece that could last a decade or longer.
Better Alternatives to Benchcraft
If Benchcraft's limited durability is a concern, consider these alternatives that offer better construction and longevity for a similar or slightly higher investment.
Klaussner Furniture
Klaussner offers a significant step up in quality with solid wood frames and more durable fabrics, often with customization options. Prices are modestly higher, but the furniture is built to last far longer, providing better long-term value for essential pieces like sofas and beds.
Shop now at klaussner.com
Joybird
Focusing on mid-century modern design, Joybird uses high-quality materials like kiln-dried hardwood frames and high-density foam. Their custom-made pieces are built to last 8-10 years and represent excellent value for those wanting both style and substance.
Shop now at joybird.com
Ashley Signature Design
As Ashley's slightly more premium line, Signature Design often uses better materials, including more solid wood components and upgraded fabrics, than Benchcraft. It's a great middle ground if you want to stay within the Ashley ecosystem but get more durability for your money.
Shop now at ashleyfurniture.com
West Elm
For a similar investment, certain West Elm collections offer superior construction with solid wood frames and more durable materials. It's a good choice for modern and stylish furniture, but be selective as quality can be inconsistent across their product lines.
Shop now at westelm.com
American Leather
If your budget allows, American Leather is a premium choice known for top-grain leather and kiln-dried hardwood frames that last over 10 years. Though significantly more expensive, it's a true long-term investment in furniture that will not need to be replaced.
Shop now at americanleather.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Who makes Benchcraft furniture?
Benchcraft is one of the many brands owned and manufactured by Ashley Furniture Industries, one of the largest furniture manufacturers in the world. It is positioned as one of their more affordable, trend-focused product lines.
How long does a Benchcraft sofa last?
With moderate, typical daily use, a Benchcraft sofa can be expected to last between 3 and 5 years. Key failure points are often sagging cushions and fabric wear, which can start showing signs of degradation within 2-3 years.
Is Benchcraft considered low-quality furniture?
Benchcraft is best described as mid-tier or entry-level quality, not necessarily "low quality." It meets basic standards for function and safety but uses cost-effective materials like particleboard and lower-density foam that naturally limit its lifespan compared to higher-end furniture made with solid wood and more resilient components.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
