The short answer is yes - Balsam Hill is worth it if you are looking for one of the most realistic artificial Christmas trees on the market and plan to use it for many years. Their trees feature exceptional craftsmanship, heirloom-quality materials, and stunningly lifelike details that mass-market brands can't match. You are paying a premium for aesthetics and long-term durability.
However, the high price tag isn't justified for everyone, especially if hyper-realism isn't your top priority. If the occasional shedding of flocked models or the initial investment gives you pause, there are other high-quality alternatives that offer better value for your needs.
How Is Balsam Hill's Quality?
Balsam Hill's quality is in the premium tier of the artificial tree market, with a strong focus on realism and durable construction. Here’s a detailed breakdown of what to expect:
- Materials: Their signature "True Needle" foliage uses high-quality PE (polyethylene) tips molded from real branches, giving the trees an incredibly lifelike appearance and feel. For fullness, these realistic outer tips are mixed with classic PVC needles on the interior branches, a standard practice for high-end artificial trees.
- Construction: The trees are built on heavy-duty steel poles with hinged branches that easily fold down for setup and up for storage. This sturdy framework ensures stability even for larger models. The craftsmanship extends to hand-painted branch tips to mimic the subtle color variations of real trees.
- Durability: With proper care and storage, a Balsam Hill tree is designed to last 5-10 holiday seasons, or even longer. The steel frame is rust-resistant, and the PE/PVC tips are engineered to be colorfast and maintain their shape over many years of use.
- Common Complaints: The most frequent issues mentioned by customers involve their flocked trees, which are known to shed, especially during the first unboxing and setup. After many seasons, some pre-lit models can experience bulb or wiring failures, which is a potential long-term maintenance point for any pre-lit tree.
Is Balsam Hill Good Value for the Price?
Balsam Hill trees offer good value for those who prioritize realism and long-term durability over initial cost. You are making an investment in a holiday centerpiece that should not need replacement for a decade.
Price Positioning
Balsam Hill is positioned at the high end of the market. A 7.5-foot tree typically starts around $700, while larger 9-foot pre-lit or flocked models can easily exceed $1,200-$2,000. These prices are competitive with other premium brands like Frontgate and NeumanTrees but are significantly higher than what you'd find at big-box retailers.
What You're Paying For
The premium price is justified by three key factors: uncanny realism from their PE True Needle technology, robust construction built to last for years, and the convenience of thoughtfully designed features like easy assembly and professionally strung lighting. You're buying a product designed to be an heirloom piece, not a disposable decoration.
Where You Get Good Value
- Realistic Non-Flocked Trees: Their classic green trees, like the Fraser Fir, offer the best long-term value, as they avoid the shedding issues associated with flocked models while still providing top-tier realism.
- Long-Term Use: If you divide the cost over a lifespan of 10 years, a $1,000 tree costs $100 per year, making it a reasonable long-term investment compared to buying cheaper, less durable trees every few years.
- Pre-Lit Models: While a potential long-term failure point, the convenience and professionally strung look of their pre-lit LED trees are a major value driver for many busy families.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Budget-Conscious Shoppers: If your main goal is just to have an artificial tree that looks nice for a reasonable price, the premium for Balsam Hill's hyper-realism is likely not worth it.
- Flocked Trees: Due to complaints about shedding and potential mess, the long-term aesthetic value of flocked trees might diminish more quickly than their non-flocked counterparts.
- Wreaths and Garlands: While made with the same quality, their matching decor's high price point can be harder to justify, as there are many beautiful, more affordable options on the market.
Balsam Hill Quality by Category
While known for trees, quality varies slightly across their different product types.
Unlit Artificial Trees
This is Balsam Hill's core strength. Using best-in-class PE tips for realism and sturdy steel frames, their unlit trees (like the popular BH Fraser Fir) are built to last over a decade. Priced from $600 to $1,500+, they are a sound investment for those who are passionate about decorating and want a durable, beautiful canvas for their ornaments.
Pre-Lit Artificial Trees
Offering the same realistic foliage and construction, pre-lit trees add significant convenience. Balsam Hill uses long-lasting commercial-grade LED lights that are expertly woven into the branches. While minor bulb failures can occur over time, the wiring is generally reliable for many seasons. Expect to pay a $200-$500 premium for this feature compared to unlit models.
Flocked Christmas Trees
Aesthetically beautiful, Balsam Hill's flocked trees provide a magical snowy look. However, quality here is more subjective. The flocking material is prone to shedding during setup, takedown, and storage, which can be messy and reduce the tree's pristine look over time. They require more careful handling and offer slightly less long-term durability than non-flocked options.
Wreaths & Garlands
Designed to match their tree collections, Balsam Hill's wreaths and garlands use the same high-quality PE/PVC foliage. They are lush, full, and durable enough for use year after year. The main drawback is the price - a single 9-foot garland can cost over $150, which is steep compared to widely available alternatives.
Our Verdict: Is Balsam Hill Worth It?
For discerning buyers who want the most realistic artificial tree and view it as a long-term holiday investment, Balsam Hill is absolutely worth the price. The quality of their materials and construction ensures a beautiful centerpiece that will last for many holiday seasons, making the high initial cost more palatable over time.
Quality Grade: A-
Balsam Hill earns a high grade for its industry-leading realism, use of premium PE tips, hand-finished details, and sturdy steel construction. Their trees are built to last. The grade is slightly reduced from a perfect A due to durability concerns and mess from the shedding on their otherwise beautiful flocked models.
Value Grade: B+
For what you get in terms of longevity (5-10+ years) and aesthetic quality, Balsam Hill offers solid value. The price is high, but the cost-per-year makes it a smart buy for those who can afford the initial investment. The value is strongest in their non-flocked trees, however, the restrictive price point keeps it from being a top-tier "A" value for all consumers.
Better Alternatives to Balsam Hill
If the sticker price is too high or you're concerned about issues like flock shedding, here are excellent alternatives that offer comparable quality or better value:
Frontgate
Frontgate offers similarly realistic artificial trees with premium PE tips and sturdy construction, often at a slightly more competitive price. Shoppers often report that their flocked trees shed less than Balsam Hill's, making them a strong alternative for those wanting a snow-covered look.
Shop now at frontgate.com
King of Christmas
King of Christmas strikes an excellent balance between quality and affordability. Their trees feature a mix of PE and PVC needles for a realistic look at a price point that is often 30-50% lower than Balsam Hill, providing outstanding value for budget-conscious families.
Shop now at kingofchristmas.com
NeumanTrees
Often considered the pinnacle of artificial tree craftsmanship, NeumanTrees are known for their exceptional durability and handcrafted construction. They come with an even higher price tag than Balsam Hill but are truly heirloom-quality pieces built to last for generations with meticulous attention to detail.
Shop now at neumantree.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are Balsam Hill trees so expensive?
Their high price is due to premium materials like realistic PE tips molded from real branches, sturdy steel construction designed for 10+ years of use, high-end LED lighting systems, and detailed hand-finishing. You're paying for superior realism and heirloom-level durability.
How long do Balsam Hill trees really last?
With proper handling and storage, Balsam Hill trees typically last 5 to 10 years, and many customers report using them for even longer. This longevity is a key factor in justifying their high initial cost compared to cheaper trees that might only last 2-3 seasons.
Do Balsam Hill flocked trees shed a lot?
Yes, shedding is a common complaint with their flocked trees, especially during the first unboxing and setup. While the effect is beautiful, expect some mess during assembly and teardown. Careful handling and proper storage can help minimize the amount of flock loss over the years.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
