Yes, Balsam Hill trees are worth it if you prioritize realism and long-term durability and are willing to make a significant upfront investment. They are widely considered one of the leading brands for high-end, lifelike artificial Christmas trees that stand up to years of use.
The brand's main value proposition is its hyper-realistic appearance, achieved through meticulous craftsmanship and high-quality materials. While you'll pay a premium compared to big-box store options, a Balsam Hill tree is a long-term purchase designed to last for a decade or more, making it a sound investment for many families.
How Is Balsam Hill's Quality?
Balsam Hill's quality is excellent within the artificial tree market, with a strong focus on materials and construction that mimic real evergreens. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:
- Materials & Construction: Their premium trees use PE (polyethylene) tips molded from real branches, creating an incredibly realistic look and feel. These are combined with more traditional PVC tips on the interior for fullness. The frames are made from sturdy metal with hinged branches that unfold easily and can support heavy ornaments without significant drooping.
- Realism & Craftsmanship: The hand-shaped PE tips, natural color variations, and realistic branch spacing are the brand’s standout features. They invest heavily in replicating specific tree species like Fraser Firs or Norway Spruces with high fidelity, making their trees prized for their natural beauty.
- Durability & Longevity: With proper care and storage, a Balsam Hill tree is designed to last for over a decade. The pre-lit models feature long-lasting LED lights, often rated for 50,000 hours of use, and the colorfast materials resist fading over time. Many owners report using their trees for 5-10+ years with minimal signs of wear.
- Common Issues: The most frequent complaints are minor and often manageable. You may experience light shedding, especially from flocked models or during the first setup. Some customers report occasional issues with pre-lit wiring connections or loose tips, but these are typically covered by their warranty and repairable.
Is Balsam Hill Good Value for the Price?
Balsam Hill offers strong, long-term value for customers who view their artificial tree as a multi-year investment. While the initial cost is high, the quality and durability justify the price over time.
Price Positioning
Balsam Hill sits firmly in the premium segment of the market. Small, unlit trees start around $400, while their most popular 7.5-foot, pre-lit models typically range from $1,000 to $1,500. This is competitive with other high-end brands like Frontgate but significantly more expensive than budget brands found at big-box retailers, which often cost between $100 and $400.
What You're Paying For
The premium price tag covers superior realism, durable materials, and thoughtful engineering. You are paying for the injection-molded PE tips that look and feel like real needles, the sturdy steel frames that won't wobble, the convenience of easy-connect lighting systems, and a 3-year warranty backed by reliable customer service. Essentially, you're paying to avoid the sparse, plastic look of cheaper trees.
Where You Get Good Value
- "Most Realistic" Models: Their trees featuring a high percentage of PE tips offer the best value, as this is the brand's core strength.
- Pre-Lit Trees: The professionally strung, long-lasting LED lights save hours of setup and are built to last many seasons, adding significant value.
- Seasonal Sales Events: Balsam Hill frequently runs promotions, especially off-season, Black Friday, and post-Christmas. Buying during a sale for 20-40% off makes the investment much more palatable.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Entry-Level/PVC-Heavy Models: Their less expensive trees with fewer PE tips offer less realism, diminishing the main reason to choose Balsam Hill over a more budget-friendly competitor.
- Heavily Flocked Trees: While beautiful, flocked models are prone to shedding, which can feel frustrating given the high price point and potentially shorten the tree's pristine appearance.
- Non-Tree Decor: While their wreaths, garlands, and decor are high-quality, they often carry a significant brand markup. You may find similar quality decor for less from other retailers.
Balsam Hill Quality by Category
Quality can vary slightly across their product lines, though it remains consistently high.
Artificial Christmas Trees (PE/PVC)
This is their flagship category. With steel frames, hinged branches, and a high concentration of realistic PE needles, these trees are built to last 10+ years. The lighting systems are reliable, and setup is user-friendly. Verdict: Excellent quality and the primary reason to shop with the brand.
Flocked & Frosted Trees
These trees offer the same sturdy construction but with a layer of artificial snow. While visually stunning, the flocking inevitably sheds during setup, decorating, and takedown. This doesn't affect the tree's structural integrity but can be messy and may degrade slightly over many years. Verdict: Great quality, but expect some maintenance and cleanup.
Wreaths & Garlands
Made with the same realistic foliage as their trees, Balsam Hill's wreaths and garlands are dense, beautiful, and durable. They are a significant step up from standard retail options and will maintain their appearance for several holiday seasons. Verdict: Premium quality that matches the trees, though often priced at a premium.
Our Verdict: Is Balsam Hill Worth It?
Balsam Hill is an excellent investment for anyone tired of buying a new, mediocre artificial tree every few years. If you value hyper-realism and are willing to pay for durable, long-lasting quality, this brand is absolutely worth the price, especially when purchased during a sale.
Quality Grade: A-
Balsam Hill earns a top grade for its commitment to realistic design and durable materials. The use of injection-molded PE tips sets an industry standard for appearance, and their sturdy steel frames ensure longevity. The minus is for minor but consistent issues noted by customers, such as flock shedding and occasional wiring problems that prevent a perfect score.
Value Grade: B+
The value proposition is strong but depends on long-term use. A $1,200 tree that lasts 12 years costs $100 per season, which compares favorably to buying a new $250 tree every 2-3 years. The high initial cost is the biggest barrier, but the product's lifespan, warranty, and stunning appearance deliver solid value for those who can make the investment.
More Quality Brands Like Balsam Hill
If you love Balsam Hill's commitment to quality and realism, here are other premium brands that share a similar standard of excellence:
Frontgate
Frontgate competes directly with Balsam Hill, offering ultra-premium artificial trees known for their dense foliage and robust construction. Their trees often feature slightly warmer, more traditional lighting and are priced similarly, making them an excellent high-end alternative.
Shop now at frontgate.com
King of Christmas
King of Christmas offers a fantastic middle ground, providing beautiful, realistic trees at a more accessible price point (typically $400-$800). While they might not have the same degree of hyper-realism as Balsam Hill's top-tier models, they deliver exceptional quality and style for the cost.
Shop now at kingofchristmas.com
Neuman Tree
A favorite among professional decorators, Neuman Tree is known for commercial-grade durability and classic designs. Their trees are built to withstand annual takedowns for many years and feature realistic branch structures, though they come with a high-end price tag similar to Balsam Hill.
Shop now at neumanntree.com
Frequently Asked Questions
Why are Balsam Hill trees so expensive?
Balsam Hill trees are expensive due to the high-quality materials, such as individually crafted PE tips molded from real trees, and the robust steel construction designed for longevity. You are also paying for research and development that creates hyper-realistic tree species, as well as features like easy-to-connect lighting systems.
How long do Balsam Hill trees last?
With proper care and storage in the provided bags or original box, a Balsam Hill Christmas tree can easily last for 10-15 years or even longer. The LED lights are typically rated for tens of thousands of hours, ensuring they will last for many holiday seasons.
Do Balsam Hill trees shed?
Standard Balsam Hill trees shed very minimally, usually just a few loose tips during the first unboxing and setup. However, their flocked (snow-covered) trees are known to shed their flocking material, which can be messy during setup and storage.
How difficult is it to set up a Balsam Hill tree?
Setup is generally very straightforward. Most trees come in 2-4 sections with hinged branches that fold down into place. Their pre-lit models often feature "Easy Plug" technology, where the electrical connections are made through the center pole as you assemble the sections, eliminating the need to find and connect multiple strands of wires.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
