Yes, Amerisleep is worth it for shoppers seeking a high-quality, eco-friendly memory foam or hybrid mattress with a responsive feel. Their proprietary plant-based foam and US-based manufacturing offer a step up from entry-level online mattresses in both comfort and durability. However, their all-foam models can be pricey for the performance, and hybrid models deliver better long-term value.
The brand sits comfortably in the mid-to-premium online mattress market, offering better materials than budget brands but without the heirloom quality of luxury competitors. Here’s what you need to know before you buy.
How Is Amerisleep's Quality?
Amerisleep's quality is consistently good, with a focus on durable, domestically-sourced materials. They prioritize comfort and longevity over flashy design, resulting in reliable mattresses that perform well for years. Here’s a breakdown:
- Materials: Their signature material is Bio-Pur® foam, a plant-based memory foam that is more breathable and responsive than traditional petroleum-based foams. Support cores use high-density polyfoam (1.8-2.0 PCF) or pocketed steel coils in their hybrid models, both of which are markers of a durable mattress.
- Construction: Mattresses are manufactured in the USA, contributing to better quality control. Stitching is clean and the covers, made from breathable polyester and Tencel blends, are well-finished and designed to last without pilling or fraying.
- Durability and Longevity: An Amerisleep mattress can be expected to last 7-10 years with proper care. Hybrid models generally offer superior longevity and sagging resistance compared to the all-foam versions due to their reinforced steel coil cores.
- Common Complaints: Some users of the softer, all-foam models report that the foam can soften and develop body impressions after 5+ years of use, especially if not rotated regularly. This is less of an issue with their firmer models and hybrids.
Is Amerisleep Good Value for the Price?
Amerisleep offers good, but not exceptional, value. You are paying a slight premium for their proprietary foam technology and eco-friendly marketing, but the quality generally justifies the cost, especially during a sale.
Price Positioning
Amerisleep mattresses typically range from $999 to $2,199 for a queen size, placing them in the same price bracket as other premium online brands like Casper and Tuft & Needle's higher-end models. However, they frequently run sales offering 20-30% off, which significantly improves their value proposition and brings prices closer to the mid-range market. At full price, they are expensive, on sale, they are competitive.
What You're Paying For
The price reflects several key factors: the proprietary Bio-Pur® foam technology, eco-conscious materials, USA-based manufacturing, and a direct-to-consumer model that eliminates retail markups. You're also paying for a generous 100-night sleep trial and a 20-year limited warranty, which adds peace of mind.
Where You Get Good Value
- Hybrid Models: The hybrid mattresses combine responsive foam with a durable coil system, offering the best combination of comfort, support, and longevity the brand offers. They are a solid long-term investment.
- Eco-Conscious Shoppers: If buying a mattress made with plant-based materials and manufactured in the USA is important to you, Amerisleep provides good value.
- During Sales: Buying an Amerisleep mattress during a major holiday or promotional event makes the price-to-quality ratio much more favorable.
Where You Don't Get Good Value
- Softer All-Foam Models at Full Price: The brand's softer foam mattresses may not hold up as long as their firmer or hybrid counterparts, making them a less compelling value if purchased at full retail price.
- Budget Shoppers: If your priority is simply getting a durable foam mattress for the lowest price, brands like Tuft & Needle's Original offer similar longevity for less cost, albeit without the plant-based foam.
Amerisleep Quality by Category
Quality and value can differ between Amerisleep's all-foam and hybrid lines. Here’s how they compare.
All-Foam Mattresses
Ranging from firm to soft, these models feature a comfort layer of Bio-Pur® foam over a high-density polyfoam support core. Priced from roughly $999-$1,899 for a queen, they provide excellent pressure relief and motion isolation. While durable, their lifespan is around 7-8 years, with softer models being more prone to developing impressions over time. Verdict: A good choice for side sleepers and couples who prioritize motion isolation, but hybrids offer better longevity for a similar price.
Hybrid Mattresses
These mattresses top the Bio-Pur® foam comfort layer with a zoned system of individually pocketed steel coils. This construction provides better edge support, improved airflow for cooling, and superior durability. A queen hybrid costs between $1,299 and $2,199 and can easily last 8-10+ years without significant sagging. Verdict: Worth the upgrade for most sleepers, especially back, stomach, or heavier individuals who need enhanced support and maximum durability.
Our Verdict: Is Amerisleep Worth It?
Amerisleep is a solid choice for anyone looking for an advanced foam mattress that is comfortable, responsive, and made with eco-conscious materials. Their hybrid models in particular offer excellent durability and support that justifies their price point, especially when purchased on sale.
Quality Grade: B+
Amerisleep earns a B+ for quality due to its use of high-quality proprietary foam, durable support cores, and reliable US-based manufacturing. The construction is solid, and mattresses provide supportive comfort for years. Points are deducted for the potential of softer foam models to develop body impressions or soften prematurely compared to their more robust hybrid counterparts.
Value Grade: B
The value proposition is good but not unbeatable, leading to a B grade. The direct-to-consumer pricing is fair for the materials and technology you receive, and the 20-year warranty is generous. However, the premium price for their "eco-friendly" foam means that more budget-conscious brands can offer similar durability for less, making Amerisleep a good, but not class-leading, value.
Better Alternatives to Amerisleep
If you're looking for different features or a better price-to-performance ratio, here are some alternatives that offer strong quality and value.
Tuft & Needle
Tuft & Needle offers CertiPUR-US certified foam mattresses at lower prices ($750-$1,200 for a queen). Their proprietary T&N Adaptive® foam delivers comparable durability and responsive comfort without the premium cost of plant-based materials, making it a better value for budget-focused shoppers.
Shop now at tuftandneedle.com
Casper Wave Hybrid
For those prioritizing cooling and zoned support, the Casper Wave Hybrid is an excellent choice, though typically more expensive ($1,999+). It combines high-quality foams and coils with targeted ergonomic zones, offering robust support and long-term durability similar to Amerisleep's hybrids.
Shop now at casper.com
Saatva Classic
Saatva offers a luxury innerspring hybrid experience for a similar price ($1,500-$2,200 for a queen). With a high-durability dual-coil system, organic cotton cover, and free white-glove delivery, it is a superior choice for those who want a traditional mattress feel with premium, long-lasting construction.
Shop now at saatva.com
Helix Midnight Luxe
Helix offers customizable hybrid mattresses designed for specific sleep positions. The Midnight Luxe model provides excellent pressure relief with high-quality foam and coil construction and is a favorite among side sleepers. Its durability and quality are on par with Amerisleep's hybrids, often at a similar price point.
Shop now at helixsleep.com
Loom & Leaf
Made by Saatva, Loom & Leaf is a direct Amerisleep competitor in the premium memory foam space. It uses high-density memory foam and an organic cotton cover, offering exceptional durability and deep contouring comfort for those who want a high-end, classic memory foam feel backed by a lifetime warranty.
Shop now at loomandleaf.com
Frequently Asked Questions
How long does an Amerisleep mattress last?
With proper care, an Amerisleep mattress should last between 7 and 10 years. Hybrid models tend to have a longer lifespan (8-10+ years) than all-foam models (7-8 years) due to the added durability of their steel coil support system.
Is Amerisleep's Bio-Pur foam actually better?
Compared to traditional, dense memory foam, Bio-Pur® foam is better in a few key ways. Its open-cell structure, derived from plant-based materials, makes it more breathable and temperature-neutral. It's also more responsive, so you won't feel "stuck" in the mattress.
Is Amerisleep's 20-year warranty legitimate?
Yes, but it's a limited, prorated warranty like most in the industry. For the first 10 years, it covers repairs or replacements for defects like sagging greater than 0.75 inches at no cost. For the second 10 years, you would be responsible for a portion of the replacement cost. It does not cover normal wear or softening of the foam.
Are Amerisleep's hybrid or all-foam mattresses better?
For most people, the hybrid mattresses are better. They offer superior durability, better edge support, and improved airflow. All-foam models are a good choice if your top priority is motion isolation for couples or if you prefer the deep-cradling feel of an all-foam bed.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
