Ikea is a global leader in highly affordable, Scandinavian-style flat-pack furniture, ideal for those seeking modern, space-saving designs. In contrast, Bed Bath & Beyond operates as a comprehensive home goods retailer, offering a broader range of traditional and transitional styles alongside an extensive selection of bedding, kitchenware, and decor.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right home retailer for your space.
Ikea: The Affordable Scandinavian Style Leader
Ikea is renowned worldwide for its budget-friendly, minimalist furniture that combines functionality with a distinct modern Swedish aesthetic. Famous for its flat-pack model, the brand appeals to students, young professionals, and families who need stylish, practical solutions without a large investment. Shopping at Ikea is an experience, from navigating its large warehouse showrooms to enjoying its iconic Swedish meatballs.
- Product mix: A complete offering of home furnishings, including sofas, beds, desks, storage systems (like KALLAX and BILLY), lighting, textiles, kitchen cabinets, and housewares.
- Style/vibe: Quintessentially Scandinavian - minimalist, modern, and practical with clean lines and neutral color palettes. Designs are focused on simplicity and maximizing small spaces.
- Price point: Extremely affordable. Sofas often start around $300, bed frames can be found for under $200, and iconic POÄNG armchairs are around $100.
- Quality: Primarily uses engineered wood, particleboard, and MDF with foils or veneers to keep costs low. Quality is consistent for the price point, but it's not designed to be heirloom furniture.
- Sustainability: Ikea is a leader in sustainability in the retail space. The brand makes significant investments in responsible wood sourcing (FSC-certified), renewable energy, and programs aimed at making its business climate-positive.
- Delivery & Assembly: This is Ikea's signature challenge. Most items come in a flat box and require self-assembly. Delivery and assembly services are available for an additional fee.
- Shopping Experience: Large, warehouse-style stores with inspirational "room sets" that guide you through a one-way path. The online experience includes helpful planning tools for kitchens and storage systems.
- Return policy: Relatively generous, offering 365 days for the return of new and unopened products and 180 days for opened products. Mattresses come with a "love it or exchange it" policy.
Ikea is the go-to choice for modern, functional design on a strict budget, especially for those comfortable with a little DIY assembly.
Shop Ikea: ikea.com
Bed Bath & Beyond: The Convenient Home Essentials Hub
Bed Bath & Beyond is a one-stop-shop for a wide variety of home goods, extending well beyond a typical furniture store. It caters to a broad audience looking for convenience, variety, and reliable household essentials for every room. While it does offer furniture, its main strength lies in its vast selection of bedding, bath accessories, kitchen appliances, and decor from many different brands.
- Product mix: Extensive inventory of bedding, towels, kitchenware, small appliances, home decor, cleaning supplies, and some furniture like bedroom sets, sofas, and dining tables.
- Style/vibe: Broad and accessible, leaning toward traditional, transitional, and casual contemporary styles. It focuses more on comfort, function, and popular trends rather than a single design aesthetic.
- Price point: Affordable to mid-range. Sofas typically begin in the $400–$600 range, while bed frames can range from $200 to over $800. The brand is famous for its frequent coupons and sales events.
- Quality: Materials for furniture include a mix of MDF, solid wood, and metal frames. Bedding and textiles are a key focus, with many well-known brands available, offering reliable quality and durability.
- Customer Service: Historically a strong point for the brand, with flexible return policies and helpful in-store staff being major draws for shoppers.
- Shopping Experience: Offers a more traditional retail setup with smaller stores that are easy to navigate for specific items. The online platform is robust and easy to use, with options for home delivery or convenient in-store pickup.
- Sustainability: The company has made some efforts in sustainable sourcing and eco-friendly packaging, but its public initiatives and commitments are not as comprehensive or central to the brand identity as Ikea.
- Return policy: Known for being exceptionally flexible, which has long been a key benefit for its loyal customer base.
Bed Bath & Beyond is ideal for those who prioritize convenience and a vast selection to furnish and accessorize their entire home in one place.
Shop Bed Bath & Beyond: bedbathandbeyond.com
Ikea vs. Bed Bath & Beyond Comparison
Price Comparison
Ikea is the undisputed winner on price, particularly for large furniture items. Its business model is built around high-volume, low-cost manufacturing, which translates to unmatched affordability. For example, you can furnish an entire living room or bedroom for under $1,000.
While Bed Bath & Beyond offers products at good prices, its furniture generally starts at a higher price point. A sofa at Bed Bath & Beyond might start at $400 or more, while Ikea often has options under $300. However, Bed Bath & Beyond shoppers can find significant savings through the brand's ever-present coupons and sales events.
Style & Aesthetic
The two brands target completely different design aesthetics. Ikea is synonymous with Scandinavian modern design - think clean lines, light wood tones, functional simplicity, and minimal ornamentation. This streamlined look is perfect for contemporary homes, urban apartments, and anyone who appreciates a minimalist feel.
Bed Bath & Beyond steers toward more traditional, transitional, and classic American styles. Their collections feature more plush upholstery, darker wood tones, and decorative details. This makes it a better fit for suburban family homes or interiors that value comfort and a cozy, familiar feel over stark modernism.
Quality & Construction
Ikea's quality is designed to match its price. Most furniture is made from affordable materials like particleboard and MDF. While perfectly functional and durable enough for daily use, it's not built to last for generations and can be susceptible to damage from moisture or frequent moves.
Bed Bath & Beyond's furniture often features a step up in materials, with a greater use of solid wood components and more robust upholstery. The overall construction often feels more substantial and durable, reflecting its slightly higher price point. This is especially true for items like bed frames and dining sets.
Product Selection
This is where the brands differ most. Ikea is a furniture-first company, its selection across sofas, beds, tables, and storage is massive and cohesively designed. Everything else - from lighting to rugs to kitchen gadgets - is created to complement that core furniture collection.
Bed Bath & Beyond is an "everything for the home" store. Its strength is in its incredible variety across bedding, bath linens, kitchen appliances from brands like KitchenAid and Cuisinart, and general home decor. While it offers furniture, the selection is much smaller and less central to its identity than Ikea's.
Shopping Experience
The in-store experience at these two retailers is night and day. Ikea provides an immersive, destination-style shopping trip through sprawling warehouse showrooms. It can be inspiring but also time-consuming, and ends with you pulling your own flat-pack boxes from shelves. A visit is often an all-day event.
Bed Bath & Beyond offers a conventional, convenient retail experience. Stores are smaller, organized by department, and easy to pop into for a specific item. Its powerful online platform, coupled with in-store pickup, makes it far more convenient for targeted shopping trips.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your project, budget, and personal style.
Choose Ikea if:
- Your budget is your top priority.
- You specifically want a modern, minimalist, or Scandinavian aesthetic.
- You're furnishing a small space like an apartment, dorm, or first home and need space-saving solutions.
- You enjoy (or at least don't mind) assembling your own furniture.
- Supporting a brand with strong sustainability practices is important to you.
Choose Bed Bath & Beyond if:
- You're looking for a one-stop-shop for everything, from towels and blenders to bedroom sets.
- You prefer traditional, classic, or cozy transitional styles over stark modernism.
- You value convenience, easy returns, and a more straightforward shopping trip.
- You want furniture that generally requires less assembly.
- You're more focused on getting quality bedding and kitchenware than ground-up-furnishing.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ikea or Bed Bath & Beyond cheaper?
Ikea is significantly cheaper across almost all furniture categories. Its entire business is structured around producing affordable, mass-market furniture, giving it a permanent price advantage over most competitors.
Which has better quality furniture?
Generally, Bed Bath & Beyond furniture is perceived to have slightly better quality, often using heavier materials like solid wood accents and more traditional construction techniques. Ikea's quality is excellent for its price but is not designed for long-term, heavy-duty use.
Which is better for small spaces?
Ikea is the definite winner for small spaces. The brand has built its global success on designing smart, modular, and compact furniture perfect for apartments, condos, and small rooms.
Do I have to assemble everything from Ikea?
Most large furniture items from Ikea require assembly. However, the store does offer assembly services through partners like TaskRabbit for an additional fee if you prefer not to do it yourself.
Can you return furniture to both stores?
Yes, both retailers have return policies for furniture. Bed Bath & Beyond's policy has historically been known for its flexibility. Ikea offers a 365-day return window for unopened items and 180 days for opened items, which is very generous.
Which store is better for a wedding registry?
Bed Bath & Beyond is a traditional powerhouse for wedding registries due to its extensive selection of kitchenware, appliances, bedding, and home essentials from a wide variety of well-known brands.
Is Ikea more sustainable than Bed Bath & Beyond?
Yes. Ikea has made sustainability a core part of its mission, with major global initiatives in renewable energy and responsible material sourcing. While Bed Bath & Beyond has taken steps toward sustainability, it is not as central to its brand identity.
Which sells items from other brands?
Ikea almost exclusively sells its own brand of products. Bed Bath & Beyond is a classic retailer, selling products from hundreds of different external brands like UGG, Casper, Cuisinart, and Dyson.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
