Choosing between buying a mattress from IKEA or Amazon comes down to one key difference: curated selection versus endless variety. IKEA offers a focused range of affordable, functional mattresses that you can often test in-store, while Amazon is a massive online marketplace with hundreds of brands, ranging from ultra-budget options to premium luxury models.
Here's everything you need to know to decide whether the simplicity of IKEA or the vast selection of Amazon is the right choice for you.
IKEA Mattresses
IKEA is a go-to for affordable and stylish home goods, and their mattress collection follows the same principle. Known for their Scandinavian simplicity, IKEA mattresses offer practical sleep solutions with foam, spring, and hybrid options designed to provide solid comfort without a high price tag. Their key advantage is the ability to test mattresses in their showrooms before committing.
- What it is: A curated collection of foam, innerspring, and hybrid mattresses from a single, trusted brand known for affordability and minimalist design.
- Key features: Mattresses are often roll-packed for easy transport, designed to fit IKEA bed frames perfectly, and come with a 90-day sleep trial and a 10-year limited warranty.
- Price: Generally ranges from $200 for basic foam models to around $1,000 for their more advanced hybrid options.
- Style: Clean, simple, and functional. Covers are typically neutral whites or grays, fitting their Scandinavian design aesthetic.
- Materials/Construction: IKEA uses a combination of high-resilience polyurethane foam, memory foam, and individually wrapped pocket springs in their mattresses.
- Pros: Affordable and great value for the price. Ability to test in a physical store. Straightforward product line makes choosing easier. Designed to perfectly fit popular IKEA bed frames.
- Cons: Limited selection compared to a marketplace like Amazon. Fewer options for specialized features like advanced cooling or organic materials. Primarily focused on the budget to mid-range market.
An IKEA mattress is perfect for shoppers on a budget who prefer to test a mattress in person and appreciate a simple, functional design that gets the job done.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/mattresses-our-basics-10609/
Amazon Mattresses
Amazon is the world's largest online retailer, offering an almost limitless selection of mattresses from its own private labels and hundreds of third-party brands. The platform allows you to compare different materials, firmness levels, and features side-by-side, relying heavily on extensive customer reviews to guide purchasing decisions for its entirely online shopping experience.
- What it is: A vast online marketplace featuring mattresses from countless brands, including their in-house Amazon Basics line and well-known "bed-in-a-box" companies.
- Key features: Massive variety of materials (memory foam, latex, hybrid, innerspring), price points, and features (cooling gel, pillow tops, adjustable-base compatibility). Customer reviews and ratings are a central part of the shopping experience.
- Price: Extremely wide range, from under $150 for basic twin mattresses to well over $2,000 for premium, high-tech king size models.
- Style: Highly varied. You can find everything from simple, utilitarian designs to luxurious-looking mattresses with plush, quilted covers.
- Materials/Construction: The quality and materials depend entirely on the brand you choose, ranging from basic foam layers to CertiPUR-US certified foams, natural latex, and complex hybrid spring systems.
- Pros: Unmatched selection of brands, prices, and features. Competitive pricing with frequent sales and deals. Convenient and fast shipping, especially for Prime members. Huge library of customer reviews.
- Cons: Cannot test mattresses before buying. Quality can be inconsistent between brands. Overwhelming number of options can make choosing difficult. Return policies and trial periods vary by seller.
Amazon is the ideal choice for shoppers who are comfortable buying online, want to compare dozens of options at every price point, and rely on user reviews to find the perfect fit.
Shop this product: amazon.com/s?k=mattress
IKEA vs. Amazon Mattresses Comparison
Price & Value
IKEA excels in the budget-friendly and mid-range categories. Their mattresses offer dependable quality at a consistently low price, making it a predictable and safe bet for value. You know you're getting a decent product without spending a fortune, with most options falling between $200 and $1,000.
Amazon's pricing is a wild west of options. You can find incredibly cheap mattresses for under $200, but you can also find luxury models that cost thousands. While this provides more choice, it also means you have to do more research. The value on Amazon is found by carefully reading reviews to distinguish the hidden gems from the low-quality duds, especially at the lower end of the price spectrum.
Quality & Materials
When you buy an IKEA mattress, you're buying a product made with their specific quality standards in mind. While not premium, their materials - high-density foams and pocket springs - are reliable and designed for everyday use. The quality is consistent across their lineup, meaning what you see online or in-store is what you get.
On Amazon, quality is highly variable. You have access to top-rated brands known for high-quality materials like CertiPUR-US certified memory foam and natural latex, but you also have access to less-proven brands using basic foams. The responsibility falls on you, the shopper, to vet the materials and brand reputation through reviews and product descriptions.
Shopping Experience
The shopping experience is the biggest differentiator. IKEA offers a hybrid model where you can research online and then go to a physical store to lie down on different models. For many people, this tactile experience is a non-negotiable part of buying a mattress. Once you decide, you can either take it home yourself or arrange for delivery.
Shopping on Amazon is a purely digital experience. There is no way to physically try the mattress beforehand. Instead, you rely on a combination of detailed product pages, Q&,A sections, and - most importantly - thousands of customer photos and reviews. The major advantage is convenience: you can order from your couch and have a mattress at your door in a couple of days, with sleep trials (typically 30-100 nights) offering a safety net if it isn't right.
Best For
- IKEA is best for: Budget-conscious shoppers, first-time apartment dwellers, or anyone who wants to physically test a mattress before buying. It's a great choice if you already own an IKEA bed frame or prefer a straightforward, no-fuss selection process.
- Amazon is best for: Shoppers who prioritize variety and convenience. It's perfect for those who have a specific need (e.g., extra cooling, specific firmness, organic materials) and are willing to research reviews to find the best option in a given category.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both IKEA and Amazon are excellent sources for mattresses, but they cater to very different shopping preferences.
Choose an IKEA Mattress if:
- You want to test out a mattress in a physical store before you buy it.
- You are on a strict budget and want predictable, solid quality for the price.
- You appreciate a simple, curated selection and get overwhelmed by too many choices.
- You own an IKEA bed frame and want a mattress guaranteed to be a perfect fit.
Choose an Amazon Mattress if:
- You want a huge selection of brands, materials, and features to choose from.
- You are comfortable making purchase decisions based on customer reviews and ratings.
- You value the convenience of fast, direct-to-your-door shipping.
- You're looking for either a very specific feature (like advanced cooling) or a mattress in a premium, high-end category that IKEA doesn't offer.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between IKEA and Amazon mattresses?
The primary difference is brand vs. marketplace. IKEA sells a small, curated selection of its own branded mattresses with consistent quality and the option for in-store testing. Amazon is a vast marketplace selling hundreds of different brands with widely varying quality, prices, and features, all based on an online-only model.
Which one is cheaper?
Both offer very affordable options. Amazon has mattresses at a lower starting price point (under $150), but IKEA is more consistently affordable across its entire range. If you're looking for the absolute cheapest option, you'll likely find it on Amazon, but with potentially more risk regarding quality.
Can I try an IKEA mattress before I buy it?
Yes. This is one of the biggest advantages of buying from IKEA. You can visit any of their stores and test out the different models in their showroom before making a decision.
What is the return policy for mattresses on Amazon?
It varies. Most mattresses sold on Amazon come with a sleep trial period offered by the manufacturer, typically ranging from 30 to 100 nights. It is crucial to check the specific return policy for the mattress you're considering before purchasing, as procedures can differ between sellers.
Which has better quality?
This depends on how much you spend and what you choose. IKEA offers good, consistent quality for its price range. On Amazon, the quality is variable. You can find mattresses that are higher quality than IKEA's best offering, but you can also find products that are much lower quality. It requires more research on your part.
Are IKEA mattresses only designed for IKEA bed frames?
While IKEA mattresses are designed to fit their bed frames perfectly, they also come in standard North American sizes (Twin, Full, Queen, King). This means they will fit any standard bed frame, not just those from IKEA.
What should I look for when buying a mattress on Amazon?
Pay close attention to the number of reviews and the overall rating. Read both positive and negative recent reviews to get a balanced view. Check the product specifications for foam certifications (like CertiPUR-US), confirm the trial period and return process, and look for answers to common questions in the Q&,A section.
How long do IKEA mattresses last?
IKEA mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty, which suggests they are built to last for a significant period with normal use. Most users find they offer good durability for their price, typically providing comfortable sleep for 5-8 years.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
