While both IKEA and Kmart offer popular storage solutions for homes, their approaches are fundamentally different. The IKEA Trofast system is a modular, customizable storage solution known for its durable, kid-friendly Scandinavian design, whereas Kmart provides basic, utilitarian units that prioritize low upfront cost over everything else. The key difference lies in long-term value: Trofast is a durable system designed to adapt, while Kmart's offerings are typically for more immediate, budget-focused needs.
Let's compare these two brands to help you decide which storage solution is the right fit for your home and family.
IKEA: The Modular, Kid-Friendly Storage System
IKEA is a global staple for affordable, Scandinavian-designed home furnishings. The Trofast series is one of its most popular products, embodying the brand's commitment to functional, stylish, and family-friendly solutions. It's a highly modular storage system specifically designed for organizing kids' toys, clothes, and supplies in a way that is both accessible and tidy, appealing to parents who want a long-term, customizable solution that complements a modern home.
- Product mix: The Trofast system consists of various frame sizes and materials (wood or laminate) that can be fitted with a wide range of plastic bins and shelves in different sizes and colors.
- Style/vibe: Clean, minimalist, and distinctly Scandinavian. Frames are typically available in neutral finishes like white or natural pine, while the bins add pops of playful color. The overall look is modern and cohesive, integrating smoothly into playrooms and bedrooms.
- Price point: Mid-range and value-driven. A small storage frame starts around $30, with bins costing $3-$5 each. A complete, medium-sized unit typically costs between $60 and $120, depending on the configuration.
- Quality & Construction: Trofast frames are made from solid pine or durable particleboard, while the lightweight plastic bins are sturdy and easy for children to handle. The system is designed to withstand a playroom's wear and tear, with a focus on safety features like rounded edges.
- Customization: This is Trofast's biggest strength. You can mix and match shallow and deep bins, add flat shelves, and combine different frame sizes to create a storage wall perfectly tailored to your space and needs. The bins can be easily moved or swapped out as your child's toy collection changes.
- Assembly: Like all IKEA furniture, the Trofast system comes flat-packed and requires self-assembly. Instructions are visual, and assembly is generally straightforward.
- Sustainability: IKEA has strong sustainability goals, using renewable materials like wood from more sustainable sources (FSC-certified) and creating durable products meant to last for years.
IKEA's Trofast system provides a durable, highly adaptable, and stylish storage solution that grows with your child, making it a valuable long-term investment for family organization.
Shop IKEA: ikea.com
Kmart: The Budget-Friendly and Functional Choice
Kmart is a retailer focused on providing an extensive range of goods at highly competitive prices. Their home storage and furniture lines are designed for cost-conscious shoppers who need a quick and simple solution without a significant financial commitment. These functional pieces are ideal for temporary storage, organizing a closet on a budget, or for situations where longevity and design sophistication are not the primary concerns.
- Product mix: Kmart offers various standalone storage items, including plastic drawer towers, simple cube shelving units, fabric bins, and basic bookshelves. They do not offer an integrated, modular "system" like IKEA's Trofast.
- Style/vibe: Purely functional and utilitarian. Designs are very basic, often using simple plastic or particleboard in standard colors like white or black. The aesthetic is straightforward and does not aim to be a design feature in a room.
- Price point: Very low. Many cube storage units are priced under $50, and plastic multi-drawer units can often be found for under $25, making them extremely accessible.
- Quality & Construction: Materials are chosen for cost-effectiveness, typically involving particleboard, MDF, and lighter-gauge plastic. These units are suitable for light to moderate use but are more prone to chipping, sagging, or breaking than more robustly built furniture.
- Customization: Customization is minimal. Products are sold as-is with fixed dimensions and configurations. You can choose different colored fabric bins for a cube unit, but you cannot alter the structure itself.
- Assembly: Assembly is required for most shelving units and is typically simple. However, the hardware and components are often less substantial than what you'd find with a brand like IKEA.
- Shopping Experience: Primarily an online experience complemented by some physical stores. The focus is on convenience, low prices, and frequent promotions rather than in-store inspiration or design services.
Kmart offers practical, no-frills storage that solves an immediate organizational problem at the lowest possible price point.
Shop Kmart: kmart.com
IKEA vs. Kmart Comparison
Price Comparison
This is the most significant difference between the two. Kmart is the undeniable winner for upfront cost. You can purchase a functional storage unit for as little as $20-$40. An IKEA Trofast setup will start around $40 for the most basic frame and a few bins, with larger, more complex configurations easily exceeding $100.
However, the value conversation shifts when considering longevity. The Trofast system is built to last through years of childhood play, while a Kmart unit may need to be replaced much sooner, potentially costing more in the long run. IKEA often provides better long-term value, whereas Kmart provides immediate savings.
Style & Aesthetic
IKEA Trofast offers a deliberate and cohesive Scandinavian design aesthetic. Its clean lines, neutral frame options, and thoughtfully chosen bin colors allow it to blend seamlessly into modern home decor. It's designed to look good in a living space, not just hidden away in a closet.
Kmart's style is purely utilitarian. Its designs are basic and functional, prioritizing practicality over visual appeal. While perfectly fine for organizing a garage or closet, they generally lack the design refinement to be a centerpiece in a child's bedroom or playroom.
Quality & Construction
IKEA Trofast is built with durability in mind. The wood frames are solid and sturdy, while the polypropylene plastic bins are flexible enough to resist cracking and rugged enough to hold heavy toys like blocks and cars. IKEA products also undergo rigorous safety testing, a crucial factor for children's furniture.
Kmart's storage units typically use lower-cost materials like particleboard with a thin laminate finish and more brittle plastics. These are perfectly adequate for storing lightweight items but are more susceptible to damage from moisture, heavy loads, or the rough-and-tumble of active play.
Product Selection & Customization
IKEA excels here. The Trofast is a true storage system. You buy the components separately - frames, shelves, and bins - to build a solution that perfectly fits your space and organizational needs. This modularity allows the system to change as your child's needs evolve.
Kmart offers a selection of individual storage items. You buy a pre-configured 3-drawer tower or a 6-cube bookshelf. There is no interchangeability between products and very little room for customization beyond choosing a paint color or buying different fabric bins.
Sustainability & Ethics
IKEA has made sustainability a core part of its mission, with public commitments to using responsibly sourced wood, reducing waste, and designing for a circular economy. They are transparent about their materials and supply chain.
Kmart, as a value-focused retailer, does not place the same public emphasis on sustainability. Information regarding material sourcing and eco-friendly practices is less prominent, with the primary focus remaining on affordability for the consumer.
Which One Should You Choose?
The choice here hinges on your priorities. Both retailers offer useful products, but they serve different needs entirely.
Choose IKEA Trofast if:
- You want a durable storage solution that will last for many years.
- Customization is important, you need to fit a unique space or organize various types of items.
- You value a clean, modern aesthetic that complements your home's decor.
- Safety and sustainability are key factors in your purchasing decisions.
Choose Kmart if:
- Your primary concern is the lowest possible upfront cost.
- You need a quick and simple fix for a temporary storage problem.
- The unit will be used for light-duty storage in a low-traffic area (like a closet or guest room).
- A basic, functional design is all you need.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is IKEA Trofast or Kmart cheaper?
Kmart is significantly cheaper for an initial purchase. You can often buy a complete storage unit from Kmart for less than the cost of just an IKEA Trofast frame. However, IKEA is widely considered to offer better long-term value due to its superior durability.
Which has better quality furniture for kids' rooms?
IKEA has significantly better quality for kids' furniture. The Trofast system is specifically designed to be sturdy, safe, and withstand active use by children, using more robust materials and construction methods.
Can you customize the IKEA Trofast system?
Yes, intensive customization is the Trofast system's primary feature. You can select different frame sizes and then mix and match bins of various depths and shelves to create hundreds of possible combinations to suit your specific needs.
Is the IKEA Trofast hard to assemble?
Assembly is required, but it is generally considered straightforward. IKEA provides picture-based instructions that are clear for most users. It may take some time, but it doesn't typically require special skills or tools beyond what is provided.
What is the IKEA Trofast made of?
Trofast frames are made of solid pine or particleboard with a foil finish, depending on the model. The bins are made from a durable and flexible polypropylene plastic that is easy to clean and safe for children.
Which brand is better for a playroom?
For a playroom that sees daily, active use, the IKEA Trofast is the far superior choice because of its durability, safety features, and easy-to-use bins that empower kids to clean up after themselves.
Are IKEA's products more sustainable than Kmart's?
Yes. IKEA has a well-publicized and deeply integrated sustainability program that influences its material sourcing, product design, and corporate operations. This is a core part of their brand identity, which is not the case for Kmart.
Do Kmart storage units last long?
The longevity of a Kmart storage unit depends heavily on its use. For light storage of items like clothes or craft supplies in a closet, it may last for years. However, under the stress of heavy items or active use in a playroom, it is not likely to be as durable as its IKEA counterpart.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
