The main difference between a Firm and an Extra Firm mattress from IKEA is the level of support and how much you sink into the surface. An IKEA Firm mattress provides solid support with minimal sinkage, making it a balanced choice for many back and stomach sleepers, while an Extra Firm option is built with denser materials to be exceptionally rigid, offering maximum support primarily for stomach sleepers or those who need a very hard surface for back pain.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which firmness level is right for your sleeping style and comfort preferences.
IKEA Mattress Firm
IKEA's Firm mattresses are designed for shoppers who want solid support without an extremely hard feel. They sit on the higher end of the firmness scale, providing a stable surface that discourages sinking and promotes spinal alignment. Popular with a wide range of sleepers, especially back and stomach sleepers, these mattresses balance support with a touch of surface cushioning.
- What it is: A supportive mattress option that minimizes sinkage, providing a stable and even sleeping plane.
- Key features: Constructed with high-density foam or supportive innerspring systems, often featuring a removable and washable cover for easy cleaning.
- Price: Ranges from approximately $200 (Twin) to $600 (King), depending on the specific model and materials.
- Materials/Construction: Typically made from high-density polyurethane foam, memory foam, latex, or a pocketed spring system aimed at providing consistent, all-over support.
- Pros: Good for many back and stomach sleepers, affordable price point, durable for the cost, often comes rolled in a box for easy transport, wide availability online and in-store.
- Cons: Can be too firm for side sleepers or lightweight individuals, may lack the advanced features of premium brands, initial off-gassing smell is common.
An IKEA Firm mattress is a great choice for budget-conscious individuals who prefer a supportive, "on-top-of-the-bed" feeling rather than a plush, sinking sensation.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/mattresses-our-mattresses-guide-10651/
IKEA Mattress Extra Firm
The Extra Firm option from IKEA is for sleepers who require the highest level of support possible. These mattresses are engineered to be extremely rigid, preventing any noticeable sinkage and keeping the spine completely straight. Extra Firm models are often recommended for heavier individuals, strict stomach sleepers, or those with specific back issues that benefit from a hard, unyielding surface.
- What it is: A mattress with maximum firmness, designed to offer a very stable and hard sleeping surface with virtually no contouring.
- Key features: Utilizes the densest foams or most robust innerspring systems in IKEA's lineup, designed for longevity and to maintain its firmness over many years.
- Price: Generally priced slightly higher than the Firm version, typically between $250 and $650 depending on the size and collection.
- Materials/Construction: Built with ultra-high-density foam core or a sturdy coil system with minimal comfort layers on top to maintain a hard feel.
- Pros: Provides maximum support for stomach sleepers, promotes spinal alignment for those with certain types of back pain, highly durable construction, excellent value for its support level.
- Cons: Almost always too hard for side sleepers and can cause pressure buildup on hips and shoulders. Can feel uncomfortably rigid for many people. Limited cushioning.
The Extra Firm mattress works best for individuals who specifically need an unyielding surface for alignment purposes, particularly stomach sleepers who need to prevent their hips from sinking.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/mattresses-our-mattresses-guide-10651/
IKEA Mattress Firm vs. Extra Firm Comparison
Comfort & Support
Comfort is subjective, but support is about spinal alignment. A Firm mattress provides excellent support by keeping your spine in a neutral position, especially when sleeping on your back or stomach. There's very little sinkage, but just enough "give" to prevent feeling like you're sleeping on the floor. It offers a solid, stable foundation favored by a large percentage of sleepers.
An Extra Firm mattress takes this a step further. It has a non-plush, rigid feel designed solely for support. There is virtually no contouring to the body's curves. This is essential for some stomach sleepers who must keep their hips elevated to prevent lower back strain. However, for most other sleepers - especially side sleepers - this lack of contouring can create uncomfortable pressure points at the shoulders and hips.
Materials & Construction
Both firmness levels use similar core materials like foam or innersprings, but the density and composition differ. An Extra Firm mattress achieves its feel by using higher-density foam or a higher gauge (thicker) steel in its springs, reducing flexibility. The comfort layers on top are also thinner and denser. A Firm mattress will still use robust materials, but they are engineered to have slightly more compression and responsiveness, providing a 'supportive' feel rather than a 'rigid' one.
Price & Value
Across the IKEA mattress range, both Firm and Extra Firm options deliver outstanding value. They are priced very competitively, usually much lower than specialty mattress-in-a-box brands. Typically, the Extra Firm version of a specific model will cost slightly more than the Firm version due to the denser, often more substantial materials. However, the price difference is usually minimal, making the choice about comfort preference rather than budget.
Who Each One Works Best For
A Firm IKEA mattress is a versatile choice for a wide audience. It is an excellent match for primary back sleepers and many stomach sleepers who want to avoid the "stuck" feeling of softer beds. It can also work for heavier individuals who might find a medium-firm mattress too soft. It's often the safest bet if you know you prefer a supportive surface but don't want anything extreme.
An Extra Firm mattress serves a more specific need. It is ideal for individuals who are strict stomach sleepers, as it prevents the hips and abdomen from bowing into the mattress and misaligning the spine. Some people with chronic back pain also find relief from sleeping on a board-like surface. It's not a great choice for couples with different sleep preferences or for anyone who sleeps on their side.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both firmness levels are great in their own right, but they are built for very different sleep needs.
Choose an IKEA Mattress Firm if:
- You primarily sleep on your back and need solid spinal support.
- You are a stomach sleeper but appreciate a tiny bit of surface cushioning.
- You weigh over 230 lbs and find medium-firm mattresses feel too soft.
- You want a reliable, supportive bed without it feeling overly hard.
Choose an IKEA Mattress Extra Firm if:
- You are a dedicated stomach sleeper and need to keep your hips perfectly aligned.
- Your doctor or physical therapist has recommended a very hard sleeping surface for back pain.
- You are used to extremely firm beds and find standard "firm" options too soft.
- You plan to use a thick, plush mattress topper and want the most supportive base possible.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between an IKEA Firm and Extra Firm mattress?
The main difference is the feel and rigidity. A Firm mattress offers strong support with very little sink, while an Extra Firm mattress is designed to be almost completely unyielding, offering the absolute maximum level of support for spinal alignment.
Which IKEA mattress is better for back pain?
This depends on the cause of your back pain. Many find relief on a Firm mattress because it promotes neutral spine alignment without creating pressure points. An Extra Firm mattress might be better if your pain is caused by hip sinkage (common for stomach sleepers), but it can worsen pain for others by being too hard.
Is Firm or Extra Firm better for side sleepers?
Neither is typically recommended for side sleepers. Both options are often too hard to allow the shoulders and hips to sink in properly, which can lead to spinal misalignment and discomfort. Side sleepers should generally look for a Medium or Medium-Firm mattress.
Will an IKEA firm mattress get softer?
Yes, all mattresses have a break-in period. A new Firm or Extra Firm mattress will feel its hardest straight out of the packaging. Over the first 30-60 days, the materials will soften slightly to their intended feel. However, an Extra Firm mattress will always remain significantly harder than a Firm one.
What are IKEA mattresses made of?
IKEA uses a variety of materials including polyurethane foam, memory foam, latex, and pocketed or Bonnell spring systems. The construction varies from model to model, but Extra Firm versions will always use the densest and most resilient versions of these materials.
Which firmness is more durable?
The Extra Firm models, due to their higher-density foams and stronger coils, tend to be slightly more resistant to sagging over time. Denser materials are generally more durable, making the Extra Firm a good long-term investment for those who enjoy its feel.
Do I need a box spring with an IKEA mattress?
No, IKEA mattresses are designed to work on a slatted bed base or a solid platform. A box spring could make a firm mattress feel too bouncy and is not necessary for support.
How long is IKEA’s mattress warranty?
Most IKEA mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty that covers defects in materials and workmanship, including significant sagging. Be sure to check the details for the specific mattress you purchase.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
