The IKEA Billy and Gersby are both popular, budget-friendly storage options from IKEA, but they cater to different needs. The iconic Billy bookcase is an open-shelf system celebrated for its versatility and customizability, perfect for displaying books and decor. The Gersby series focuses more on enclosed storage, offering a sleek, contemporary look with cabinets and doors designed to hide clutter.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which storage solution is the right fit for your home.
IKEA Billy Bookcase
Introduced in 1979, the Billy bookcase is one of IKEA's most successful and recognizable products. It is the go-to choice for simple, functional, and endlessly adaptable open shelving. Its classic design allows it to work in nearly any room, from home offices and living rooms to bedrooms and closets.
- What it is: A classic and highly customizable open-shelf bookcase system.
- Key features: Adjustable shelves, available in numerous heights and widths, and an extensive ecosystem of compatible add-ons like corner units and doors.
- Price: Ranges from $50 to $150, depending on the size and chosen finish.
- Dimensions: The standard unit is approximately 31 ½" wide, 11" deep, and 79 ½" tall, but it comes in various sizes to fit different spaces.
- Materials/Construction: Made from particleboard and fiberboard with a paper foil or veneer finish.
- Style: Timeless and minimalist Scandinavian design that blends seamlessly with most decor styles.
- Pros: Extremely affordable and versatile. The huge range of sizes ensures a perfect fit for almost any space. Its simple design is a blank canvas for styling. It is consistently in stock and easy to find.
- Cons: The particleboard construction is not as durable as solid wood. The thin back panel can feel flimsy. Its simple look may be too basic for some interiors without styling.
The Billy bookcase is ideal for anyone who needs functional, low-cost shelving to display books, photos, and collectibles in a clean and organized way.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/billy-bookcase-white-00263845/
IKEA Gersby Series
The Gersby series offers a more modern and polished take on storage, focusing on enclosed options like cabinets with doors. While built with similar budget-friendly materials, Gersby pieces are designed to provide a cleaner, more streamlined look by concealing contents rather than displaying them. They work well in living rooms, dining rooms, or offices where a zero-clutter appearance is desired.
- What it is: A collection of contemporary storage units, often featuring enclosed cabinets with doors.
- Key features: Enclosed storage doors to hide clutter, sleek surfaces, and a more polished, furniture-like appearance.
- Price: Generally ranges from $60 to $200.
- Dimensions: Varies by piece, but a typical cabinet might measure around 23 ⅝" wide, 15 ¾" deep, and 31 ½" high.
- Materials/Construction: Utilizes particleboard with veneer or laminate finishes, often with simple metal hardware.
- Style: Contemporary and utilitarian with clean lines, smooth surfaces, and a focus on function.
- Pros: A great option for hiding clutter and maintaining a tidy space. The contemporary design offers a sleek alternative to open shelving. Solid doors provide a "finished furniture" feel.
- Cons: Less versatile for displaying items compared to open shelves. Fewer customization options than the Billy system. The enclosed design can feel bulkier in small rooms.
The Gersby series is a solid choice for those who prioritize a tidy, minimalist aesthetic and need functional, hidden storage for miscellaneous items.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/search/?q=storage+cabinet
IKEA Billy vs. Gersby Comparison
Dimensions & Versatility
The Billy bookcase is the clear winner when it comes to versatility. Its modular system includes multiple heights, widths, and even corner units, allowing you to create a custom-fit wall of storage for any room. The relatively shallow 11" depth is perfect for books without taking up too much floor space.
The Gersby series offers more standard furniture dimensions. Its cabinet pieces are often deeper, providing more substantial enclosed storage, but the range of sizes is far more limited. Gersby units are best used as standalone pieces or in small groups rather than as a wall-to-wall integrated system.
Materials & Construction
Both the Billy and Gersby lines are constructed from IKEA's standard particleboard and fiberboard with a finish foil or veneer. This construction keeps them lightweight and affordable but means neither offers the longevity of solid wood. The main construction difference is functional: Billy is designed for adjustable open shelves, while Gersby incorporates doors, hinges, and hardware for its enclosed design.
Price & Value
Both product lines represent excellent value, but the Billy is typically the most economical option. A standard Billy bookcase remains one of the most affordable storage units you can buy. For pure open shelving, its value is unmatched.
Gersby units are slightly more expensive due to the addition of doors and hardware. However, they provide the value of concealed storage, which can make a room feel calmer and less cluttered. The choice comes down to whether you value open-display shelves or the clean look of hidden storage more.
Style & Aesthetic
The Billy bookcase has a timeless, chameleon-like quality. Its minimalist look can blend into almost any decor style effortlessly, from Scandinavian to traditional. It's a neutral backdrop for whatever you place on its shelves.
The Gersby series has a more distinctively contemporary and utilitarian style. With its flat-front doors and clean lines, it presents a more monolithic, polished appearance. It works very well in modern or minimalist interiors where concealing items is part of the aesthetic.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Billy and Gersby are practical storage solutions, but they serve different users and style preferences.
Choose the Billy bookcase if:
- You have a collection of books, records, or decorative objects you want to display.
- You're working with a tight budget and need maximum shelving for your money.
- You need a fully customizable system to fit a specific wall or corner.
- You enjoy styling shelves and changing up your decor displays.
Choose the Gersby series if:
- Your primary goal is to hide clutter and miscellaneous items behind doors.
- You prefer a clean, sleek, and contemporary aesthetic.
- You want an enclosed cabinet for a living room, dining area, or home office.
- You like the look of finished furniture rather than open utility shelving.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Billy and Gersby?
The primary difference is open versus closed storage. The Billy is an open-shelf system for displaying items, while the Gersby series focuses on enclosed cabinets with doors to hide them.
Which IKEA bookcase is cheaper?
The Billy bookcase is generally cheaper, offering one of the lowest costs-per-shelf available and making it a top choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Can you add doors to a Billy bookcase?
Yes, IKEA sells doors, like the OXBERG series, that are designed to fit the Billy bookcase. This is a great way to get a customized combination of open and closed storage within the same unit.
Are Gersby and Billy made from real wood?
No, neither series is made from solid wood. They are both constructed from particleboard and fiberboard with decorative finishes, which is how IKEA keeps them so affordable.
Which one is easier to assemble?
Both are classic IKEA flat-pack products designed for straightforward assembly. Their difficulty is very similar, with most people able to build one in under an hour.
Which is better for heavy books?
Both are rated to handle standard book loads. However, for a very large and heavy book collection, the Billy's modular system allows you to build a wider, more structurally integrated unit. For either unit, it is critical to anchor it to the wall for safety, especially when heavily loaded.
Will the shelves sag over time?
Sagging is a risk with any particleboard shelf if it's overloaded. Both Billy and Gersby shelves perform well when kept within their specified weight limits. If you have particularly heavy items, place them closer to the sides where the shelves are supported.
Which one is more durable?
Durability is comparable, as both use similar materials. The Billy's open design may be more susceptible to surface scratches, while the Gersby's doors offer more protection for the contents inside. Proper care and avoiding moisture exposure will extend the life of either one.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
