The IKEA Finnby and the classic Billy bookcase serve a similar purpose, but differ in flexibility, design, and price. The Billy is a simple, standalone bookcase series known for its rock-bottom price and timeless style, while the Finnby is a slightly more contemporary and modular storage system designed for customizable configurations that can adapt to different spaces and needs.
Here’s everything you need to know to choose the right IKEA storage solution for your home.
IKEA Finnby storage system
The Finnby is one of IKEA's more recent storage solutions, designed with modularity and space-efficiency in mind. It's a system of simple, functional units that can be combined to create tailored storage walls, making it great for everything from entryways to living rooms. Because of its component-based design, it offers a more customizable approach than traditional single-piece bookcases.
- What it is: A modular storage system featuring open shelving and cabinets that can be combined in various configurations.
- Key features: Modular design allows for horizontal and vertical stacking, adjustable shelving, and a simple, functional Scandinavian aesthetic.
- Price: Most combinations range from $60 to $200.
- Style: Modern, utilitarian, and clean. Its minimalist design is meant to be functional and blend in easily.
- Materials/Construction: Made from engineered wood and particleboard with a plastic foil finish. It's lightweight and designed for straightforward self-assembly.
- Pros: Highly customizable for unique or small spaces, modular design can grow with your needs, combines open and closed storage, offers a built-in look on a budget.
- Cons: Quality is on par with other basic IKEA furniture and not intended for heavy-duty use. Requires more planning to configure than a standalone unit. Limited historical data on long-term durability compared to the Billy.
The Finnby suits anyone who needs a flexible, space-efficient storage solution that can be tailored to fit specific dimensions or organizational requirements in a small home or apartment.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/finnby-storage-combination-30416407/
IKEA Billy bookcase
The Billy bookcase is arguably IKEA's most iconic product - a simple, effective, and extremely affordable champion of home organization. Since its introduction decades ago, it has become a staple in millions of homes worldwide. Its appeal lies in its straightforward design, variety of sizes and finishes, and its role as a blank canvas for books, decor, and more.
- What it is: A classic, standalone bookcase series available in various heights, widths, and finishes.
- Key features: Simple, clean lines, adjustable shelves, options for adding glass doors or height extension units.
- Price: Ranges from around $50 to $150 depending on size and finish.
- Style: Timeless and versatile. Its minimalist design works just as well in a traditional home office as it does in a modern living room.
- Materials/Construction: Made from particleboard and fiberboard with a foil or veneer finish. Sturdy enough for books and everyday items.
- Pros: Extremely affordable and exceptional value. Time-tested durability and design. Available in many sizes and colors. Easy and quick to assemble. Extensive ecosystem of hacks and customizations available online.
- Cons: Particleboard construction can sag over time if shelves are overloaded. The veneer finish can chip or peel if damaged. The simple design can feel less premium than other options.
The Billy bookcase is ideal for anyone needing simple, reliable, and seriously budget-friendly shelving for books, media, or decor.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/billy-bookcase-white-50263838/
Finnby vs. Billy Comparison
Dimensions & Sizing Options
The primary difference here is fixed versus flexible. The Billy bookcase comes in a set of standard heights and widths. This makes planning easy - you just pick the size that fits your space. It's a straightforward approach that works well for predictable spaces.
The Finnby, on the other hand, is a modular system. It's designed to be combined, allowing you to create custom-width or custom-height solutions that fit tricky corners, go wall-to-wall, or wrap around furniture. This makes it a superior option for maximizing storage in small apartments or unusually shaped rooms where a standard bookcase won’t work.
Materials & Construction
Both the Finnby and Billy systems are constructed from IKEA's standard materials: particleboard and fiberboard with a foil finish. From a quality perspective, they are very similar and are intended for light to moderate home use. They are not heirloom-quality solid wood pieces and should be treated accordingly.
The Billy series has the advantage of a decades-long track record. It’s proven to be a durable choice for its price point. Both systems are sturdy enough for a full load of paperback books, but heavy hardcovers may cause slight bowing over time without proper weight distribution.
Price & Value
The Billy bookcase is the undisputed champion of low-cost storage. A basic, full-height unit often costs less than a nice dinner out, delivering incredible value. If your number one goal is getting functional shelving for the lowest possible price, Billy almost always wins.
The Finnby is still very budget-friendly, but component-based systems can start to add up. A multi-unit Finnby configuration will likely cost more than a single Billy of a similar size. The value in the Finnby comes from its customizability - you're paying a slight premium for the flexibility to design a system perfect for your specific space.
Style & Versatility
With its clean lines and simple profile, the Billy is a style chameleon. It disappears into the background, letting your books and decor take center stage. This classic, understated look has kept it relevant for decades and ensures it won't clash with your existing furniture.
The Finnby has a similarly simple Scandinavian aesthetic, but its identity is tied to being a modular system. It looks most at home when used in combinations to create a larger, cohesive unit. While a single Finnby element can look a bit plain on its own, multiple units together create a more intentional, architectural look.
Who Each One Works Best For
The iconic Billy bookcase is a perfect fit for students, first-time renters, and anyone needing a functional, no-frills place to store books and display treasures. It is the go-to choice for filling a spare bit of wall in a home office, bedroom, or living room with something that is cheap, reliable, and looks good.
The Finnby storage system works best for those living in smaller spaces who need to be clever with storage. Its modularity is ideal for creating customized media centers, entryway catch-alls, or bedroom storage that perfectly fits an awkward nook or maximizes a small wall.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both IKEA storage systems offer excellent value, but they are designed for slightly different needs and spaces.
Choose the Finnby if:
- You're trying to fit storage into a specific or an awkwardly sized space.
- You value modularity and want a system you can add to or reconfigure later.
- You want to create a wall-long or custom-height storage unit on a budget.
- The combination of open shelves and closed cabinets in one system appeals to you.
Choose the Billy if:
- Your number one priority is the absolute lowest price for reliable shelving.
- You just need a standard, standalone bookcase without much fuss.
- You love a classic, timeless design that fits with virtually any decor style.
- You want the ability to add accessories like specific-fit glass doors.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Finnby and Billy?
The main difference is flexibility. The Billy is a classic standalone bookcase with fixed sizes, while the Finnby is a modular system made of separate components that you can combine to create a more customized storage solution.
Which is cheaper, Finnby or Billy?
For a basic, single bookcase, the Billy is almost always cheaper. However, prices become more comparable when you start creating larger combinations, where the cost of multiple Billys can add up versus a single Finnby configuration.
Are Finnby and Billy made from the same material?
Yes, both lines are primarily constructed from particleboard and fiberboard with a foil finish, which is standard for most of IKEA's affordable furniture ranges.
Which one is more durable?
They are very similar in terms of material quality and intended use. Both will hold up well to moderate use but can be damaged by moisture or heavy impact. The Billy series has a longer reputation for durability simply because it has been on the market for decades.
Is Finnby or Billy better for small spaces?
The Finnby's modularity often makes it a better choice for small or awkward spaces because you can put together a combination that precisely fits your dimensions, maximizing every inch of storage.
Which bookcase is easier to assemble?
Both are designed for straightforward self-assembly. A single Billy bookcase is likely simpler to build just because it's one unit with fewer parts. A more complex Finnby configuration will naturally take more time.
Do these bookcases need to be anchored to the wall?
Yes, IKEA strongly recommends and provides hardware for anchoring both the Finnby and Billy to a wall to prevent tipping. This is a critical safety step, especially in homes with children or pets.
Can you paint an IKEA Billy or Finnby bookcase?
Yes, both can be painted, but it requires proper preparation. Because of the slick foil finish, you must first lightly sand the surface and use a high-adhesion shellac-based primer before applying your topcoats of paint.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
