The IKEA Billy Bookcase and the Walmart Mainstays Bookcase are two of the most popular budget shelving units available, but they cater to different needs and priorities. The famous Billy Bookcase from IKEA provides superior durability, greater customization options, and a more refined Scandinavian style, making it a better long-term investment. The Mainstays bookcase from Walmart is the undisputed winner on upfront cost, offering basic, functional storage at an incredibly low price point.
Here is a detailed comparison to help you decide which of these budget-friendly bookcases is right for your home.
IKEA Billy Bookcase
The Billy bookcase is one of IKEA's most iconic products, having sold in the millions since its debut in 1979. It's known for its clean, simple aesthetic, surprising sturdiness for the price, and a modular system that allows for extensive customization. This versatility has made it a favorite for everything from home libraries and display shelving to famous "built-in" DIY hacks.
- What it is: A highly popular and versatile particleboard bookcase system known for its Scandinavian design.
- Key features: Adjustable shelves, multiple height and width options, and the ability to add height extension units, panel-and-glass doors, or combine multiple units for a custom look.
- Dimensions: Most common model measures 31.5" W x 11" D x 79.5" H. Also available in a narrow 15.75" width.
- Price: Starts at around $50-$60 for the standard full-height model.
- Style: Clean, minimalist, and modern. Fits seamlessly into contemporary, Scandinavian, and traditional decor styles.
- Materials/Construction: Made of particleboard and fiberboard with a paper foil or plastic veneer finish. The back panel is a thin fiberboard, engineered for stability when properly assembled and anchored.
- Pros: Excellent value for the price, far more durable than most competitors in its price range, highly customizable with add-ons, timeless design, available in several finishes like white, black, and birch.
- Cons: Assembly is required, the standard particleboard construction is susceptible to water damage, and the simple design can feel generic if not styled well.
The Billy is ideal for those who want a long-lasting, customizable bookcase that blends seamlessly into most decor styles without a high price tag.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/cat/billy-series-28112/
Walmart Mainstays Bookcase
The Mainstays bookcase from Walmart's in-house brand is designed with one primary goal: to be an exceptionally affordable storage solution. It offers basic, no-frills functionality that is perfect for students, first-time apartment dwellers, or for use in secondary spaces like closets and basements where aesthetics aren't a top priority.
- What it is: A straightforward, budget-friendly particleboard bookcase aimed at the cost-conscious shopper.
- Key features: Typically features 3 or 5 shelves (some adjustable), a simple rectangular design, and a compact footprint.
- Dimensions: Common sizes include a 5-shelf model measuring around 24.5" W x 11.5" D x 71" H.
- Price: Extremely affordable, often available for $30-$40.
- Style: Purely functional and utilitarian. It isn't designed to be a style statement but rather to blend into the background.
- Materials/Construction: Constructed from particleboard with a paper laminate finish. It's generally less dense and robust than the Billy, making it better for lighter loads.
- Pros: Incredibly low price, widely available for immediate online order or in-store pickup, assembly process is typically very simple.
- Cons: Lacks long-term durability, shelves can be prone to sagging under heavy weight, limited size and finish options, materials can chip or damage easily during moves.
This bookcase is a great choice for shoppers on the tightest budget needing an immediate, temporary, or light-duty storage solution where function wins over form.
Shop this product: walmart.com/cp/mainstays-bookcases/2157500
IKEA Billy vs. Walmart Mainstays Comparison
Dimensions & Sizing Options
The IKEA Billy series offers a much wider range of sizes. You can choose from two standard widths (approx. 15" and 31") and several heights, plus height extension units to take the bookcase all the way to the ceiling if you wish. This modularity makes it easy to create a wall-to-wall library look or fit a specific nook in your home.
The Walmart Mainstays line tends to have fewer options, typically offering a standard 3-shelf and 5-shelf model in a single width. While this covers basic needs, it doesn't provide the semi-custom fit that the Billy system allows.
Materials & Durability
While both bookcases are made from laminate-covered particleboard, there's a noticeable difference in quality. IKEA's Billy bookcases are constructed with denser materials, giving them more heft and rigidity. The shelves are less prone to bowing under the weight of heavy books, and the overall construction feels more solid once assembled.
The Mainstays bookcase is designed to meet a lower price point, and this is reflected in the materials. The particleboard is often lighter, and shelves may sag over time if loaded with heavy items like textbooks or records. For light use - displaying photos, paperbacks, or decor - it holds up fine, but it is not intended for heavy-duty, long-term use.
Style & Aesthetic
The IKEA Billy wins hands-down on aesthetics. Its clean lines and balanced proportions are rooted in Scandinavian design principles, allowing it to look at home in almost any setting. The availability of multiple finishes (white, black-brown, birch, oak) provides flexibility to match existing furniture. The Billy is so popular that it has spawned an entire subculture of "IKEA hacks" where people paint them, add trim molding, and combine them to look like expensive custom built-ins.
The Walmart Mainstays bookcase is utilitarian. Its design is basic and inoffensive, intended to provide storage without drawing attention to itself. Finish options are usually limited to simple black, white, or a faux wood grain. It gets the job done but offers little in terms of design flair.
Price & Value
If your decision is based purely on the upfront cost, the Mainstays bookcase is the winner. It is consistently one of the cheapest new bookcases you can buy. For quick, temporary storage, its price is almost impossible to beat.
However, the IKEA Billy bookcase offers far better long-term value. For an extra $20-$30, you get a product that is significantly sturdier, looks better, can be customized, and will likely last many years longer. If you plan on keeping the bookcase for more than just a semester or a short-term lease, the Billy's durability makes it the more economical choice over time.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both bookcases are solid choices for their respective audiences, but they solve very different problems.
Choose the IKEA Billy Bookcase if:
- You want furniture that will last for several years and through multiple moves.
- Aesthetics are important, and you want a bookcase that enhances your decor.
- You need to store heavy items like textbooks, hardcover collections, or vinyl records.
- You might want to expand or customize your shelving unit in the future.
Choose the Walmart Mainstays Bookcase if:
- Your primary concern is the absolute lowest upfront price.
- You just need a quick and simple solution for temporary storage (e.g., student dorm, first apartment).
- It will be used in a closet, garage, or another space where looks do not matter.
- You only plan to store lightweight objects like paperbacks, DVDs, and small decorative items.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between an IKEA Billy and Walmart Mainstays bookcase?
The main difference is the balance between cost and quality. The Walmart Mainstays prioritizes being extremely inexpensive, resulting in simpler design and lighter-duty materials. The IKEA Billy costs slightly more but offers significantly better durability, superior style, and options for customization.
Is the IKEA Billy really worth the extra money?
For most people, yes. The step up in durability and aesthetic quality for a relatively small price increase provides much better long-term value. A Billy bookcase can last for a decade or more with proper care, whereas a Mainstays unit is more suited for temporary or light use.
Which bookcase is easier to assemble?
Both bookcases require assembly and use a similar cam-lock system. IKEA's instructions are famously visual (using pictures only), which some people love. Mainstays uses more traditional instructions with text and diagrams. Assembly ease largely depends on personal preference, but neither is particularly difficult for a DIY novice.
Can you paint an IKEA Billy or Mainstays bookcase?
Yes, both can be painted, but they require proper preparation because of the laminate finish. You will need to lightly sand the entire surface and use a high-quality shellac-based primer before applying your paint. Without proper prep, the paint will easily chip and peel off.
Which bookcase is stronger?
The IKEA Billy bookcase is significantly stronger. Its shelves are rated to hold around 66 lbs (for the 31" model), making them much less likely to sag under heavy loads compared to the Mainstays shelves, which are intended for lighter items.
Do these bookcases need to be anchored to the wall?
Absolutely. Both manufacturers include anti-tip hardware and strongly recommend anchoring any tall bookcase to the wall to prevent it from tipping over. This is a critical safety step, especially in households with children or pets.
Are there more finish options for the Billy or Mainstays?
The Billy series typically offers more variety in finishes. While both come in standard white and black, IKEA often offers wood-effect veneers like birch or oak, giving it more decorative versatility to match other furniture pieces.
How much weight can an IKEA Billy shelf hold?
According to IKEA, a standard shelf on the 31.5-inch wide Billy bookcase has a max load of 66 lbs. The narrower 15.75-inch model can hold up to 31 lbs per shelf. Always distribute weight evenly for best results.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
