The IKEA Billy and Hemnes bookcases serve the same function, but they are built for entirely different customers. The Billy is a lightweight, minimalist, and highly affordable bookcase made from particleboard, while the Hemnes is a heavier, traditional-style bookcase crafted from solid wood for a much higher price. Brand-wise, both are staples from IKEA, but one prioritizes versatility and budget, while the other focuses on durability and classic design.
Here's everything you need to know to decide between these two iconic storage solutions for your home.
IKEA Billy Bookcase
The Billy bookcase is arguably IKEA's most famous product, celebrated for its simple design, modularity, and rock-bottom price. It's a go-to for apartments, dorm rooms, and first homes thanks to its clean lines and an endless number of configurations and "hacks." If you need functional, no-frills storage that can adapt to any space, the Billy is the default choice.
- What it is: A highly versatile and budget-friendly modular bookcase system.
- Key features: Adjustable shelves, lightweight construction, available in numerous heights and widths, and can be customized with glass doors or height extension units.
- Price: Ranges from about $50 to $100 depending on the size and finish.
- Dimensions: The standard size is 31 1/2" wide x 11" deep x 79 1/2" tall, but narrower and shorter versions are also available.
- Materials/Construction: Made primarily from particleboard with a paper foil or plastic veneer finish.
- Style: Minimalist, modern, and highly adaptable. Its clean, sharp lines allow it to blend into the background of almost any room.
- Pros: Extremely affordable and an excellent value. Lightweight and easy to move. Highly customizable and hackable. Slim profile fits well in small spaces. Simple, quick assembly.
- Cons: Particleboard construction is less durable and can be damaged by moisture. Shelves can sag over time if overloaded with heavy books. The foil finish can scratch or peel. Does not have a premium look or feel.
The Billy is perfect for students, renters, and anyone needing a flexible storage solution on a tight budget where ease of moving and cost are the main concerns.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/billy-bookcase-white-00263850/
IKEA Hemnes Bookcase
The Hemnes bookcase represents a step up in quality and style, using solid wood to create a more substantial, traditional piece of furniture. Part of a larger collection of matching furniture, the Hemnes has a timeless look with detailed molding and a robust frame. It's designed for those who want a more permanent, classic piece that will stand the test of time and support heavier items without issue.
- What it is: A durable bookshelf crafted from solid wood with a classic, traditional aesthetic.
- Key features: Made from solid pine, a natural and renewable material. Features sturdy, adjustable shelves and decorative top and bottom moldings.
- Price: Typically ranges from $200 to $250.
- Dimensions: A common size is 35 3/8" wide x 14 5/8" deep x 77 1/2" tall, making it wider and deeper than a standard Billy.
- Materials/Construction: Made from sustainably-sourced solid pine with a stain and clear acrylic lacquer finish.
- Style: Traditional, Scandi-country, or classic. Its solid construction and detailed edges give it a warm, substantial presence in a room.
- Pros: Excellent durability and longevity due to solid wood construction. Feels premium and sturdy. Shelves can hold heavy loads without bowing. Made from sustainable materials. Timeless design that won't go out of style.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than the Billy. Heavy and difficult to move, especially on your own. Larger footprint requires more floor space. Less versatile style might not fit in ultra-modern interiors.
The Hemnes is an excellent choice for homeowners looking for a long-term furniture investment that offers classic looks and reliable durability.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/hemnes-bookcase-white-80282145/
Billy vs. Hemnes Comparison
Dimensions & Scale
The difference in stature is immediately noticeable. The Billy bookcase is sleeker and more compact, with an 11-inch depth that makes it easy to tuck into tight corners, hallways, or smaller rooms. Its lightweight build makes it an ideal pick for apartments and spaces where furniture might be rearranged often.
In contrast, the Hemnes is larger and more commanding. With a depth over 14 inches and a wider frame, it has a more substantial physical presence. This scale makes it a better fit for larger living rooms, home offices, or bedrooms where it can act as a more permanent fixture. Its weight and size make it less practical for frequent moves or small spaces.
Materials & Construction
This is the single biggest differentiator. The Billy is built from particleboard and fiberboard with a simple paper foil finish. This keeps the cost down but sacrifices long-term durability. The shelves are known to sag under the weight of heavy hardcovers, and the finish can easily be scratched or damaged by moisture.
The Hemnes is made of solid pine, a durable and natural material. This makes the entire structure far sturdier from top to bottom. The wooden shelves can support much more weight without bowing, and the entire piece is designed to withstand a decade or more of use. This construction gives it a premium feel that particleboard simply can't match.
Style & Versatility
The Billy bookcase is a blank canvas. Its design is so simple and minimalist that it can either blend into the background or be used as a base for creative "IKEA hacks." It works equally well in a modern condo, a colorful kids' room, or a functional home office. Its versatility is its greatest strength.
The Hemnes has a distinct personality. Its traditional molding and solid wood look lean into classic, farmhouse, or rustic aesthetics. While it's beautiful in the right setting, its defined style makes it less adaptable. It stands out as a piece of decorated furniture rather than neutral storage, so it needs to match the room's overall vibe.
Price & Value
On price alone, there's no contest: the Billy bookcase is the clear winner for shoppers on a budget. You can often buy three or four Billys for the price of a single Hemnes. This accessibility is what has made it an enduring bestseller for decades.
However, when it comes to long-term value, the Hemnes makes a strong case. Its solid wood build means it won't need to be replaced after a few years of heavy use. If you view furniture as a long-term investment, the Hemnes offers superior quality and durability that justifies its higher initial cost.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both IKEA bookcases are excellent products, but they are designed for very different needs and priorities.
Choose the Billy bookcase if:
- You're furnishing a dorm, rental, or a temporary space.
- Your budget is the most important factor in your decision.
- You need a lightweight piece that's easy to move by yourself.
- You love a minimalist aesthetic or plan to customize and "hack" your furniture.
- You primarily need storage for paperbacks, small decor, or lighter items.
Choose the Hemnes bookcase if:
- You are looking for a permanent piece of furniture that will last for years.
- Durability and sturdiness are top priorities.
- You plan to store heavy hardcover books, binders, or collections.
- You prefer a classic, traditional, or farmhouse design aesthetic.
- You prioritize furniture made from natural, sustainably-sourced solid wood.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Billy and Hemnes bookcase?
The two primary differences are material and style. The Billy is made of budget-friendly particleboard with a minimalist, modern design. The Hemnes is made of more durable and expensive solid pine with a traditional, classic style.
Can the Billy bookcase hold a lot of heavy books?
While functional, the particleboard shelves of the Billy can sag over time if consistently loaded with heavy hardcover books. For large, heavy collections, the Hemnes or reinforcing the Billy shelves is a better option.
Is the Hemnes bookcase real wood?
Yes, the Hemnes bookcase is made from solid pine, which contributes to its durability and higher price point. It's a natural, renewable material that adds character to the furniture.
Which bookcase is easier to assemble?
The Billy bookcase is generally easier to assemble for one person because its components are much lighter. The Hemnes, being solid wood, is significantly heavier and may require a second person to safely move and construct.
Can you paint or customize a Hemnes bookcase?
Yes. Because it's solid wood, the Hemnes can be sanded, primed, and repainted to match your decor. This makes it quite customizable for DIY enthusiasts who want a specific color.
Which is better for small apartments?
The Billy bookcase is hands-down the better choice for small apartments. Its slimmer profile, lighter weight, and modularity make it much more suitable for tight spaces and frequent moves.
Does the Hemnes bookcase need to be anchored to the wall?
Yes, it's critical to anchor both the Hemnes and the Billy bookcases to the wall to prevent tipping. IKEA includes the necessary safety hardware with both products for this purpose.
Why is the Hemnes so much more expensive than the Billy?
The cost difference comes down to materials. Solid wood (Hemnes) is significantly more expensive to source and process than particleboard (Billy). The Hemnes also involves more detailed construction in its moldings and frame.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
