The IKEA Billy Byom doors are an affordable, flat-pack solution specifically designed for the iconic Billy bookcase system, while Oxford Doors offers premium, custom-sized internal and wardrobe doors made from high-quality materials. The core difference comes down to application, price, and quality: IKEA provides a budget-friendly DIY upgrade for its furniture, whereas Oxford Doors delivers long-lasting, bespoke solutions for home renovations.
Here's everything you need to know to decide between these two very different door options for your home project.
IKEA Billy Byom Doors
The Billy Byom is a specific door option designed for the world-famous IKEA Billy bookcase series. As a key part of IKEA's modular storage system, these doors offer a simple and extremely cost-effective way to conceal clutter and give a standard open bookshelf a more polished, cabinet-like appearance. It's the go-to choice for renters, students, and DIY enthusiasts on a budget.
- What it is: A panel and glass door duo designed exclusively to fit specific dimensions of the IKEA Billy bookcase.
- Key features: Flat-pack design for self-assembly, pre-drilled holes for easy installation onto Billy bookcases, minimalist aesthetic.
- Price: Typically around $50-$150 per door set, depending on size and finish.
- Dimensions: Made in standard sizes to fit Billy bookcase widths (e.g., 15 3/4" width to fit the narrow bookcase).
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made of particleboard or fiberboard with a paper foil or laminate finish and a glass insert.
- Style: Simple, modern Scandinavian design that matches IKEA's other furniture lines. Available in standard finishes like white or black.
- Pros: Extremely affordable upgrade. Designed for a perfect fit on Billy bookcases. Easy for one person to assemble and install. Instantly transforms open shelving into concealed storage.
- Cons: Lower-quality particleboard construction is prone to chipping. Limited to standard IKEA sizes and colors. Not suitable for any application other than a Billy bookcase. Less durable over the long term.
This is the clear choice for anyone looking to affordably customize their existing Billy bookcase without spending a lot of money or time.
Shop this product: ikea.com/us/en/p/byom-panel-glass-door-white-50531627/
Oxford Doors
Oxford Doors is a specialist door manufacturer providing high-end internal doors, wardrobe doors, and customized cabinetry solutions. Unlike mass-produced furniture, their products are built with a focus on craftsmanship, longevity, and superior materials like solid wood and premium veneers. These doors are intended as a permanent architectural feature for homeowners and designers undertaking renovations or new builds.
- What it is: Premium-quality internal and wardrobe doors available in standard and bespoke sizes.
- Key features: Custom sizing capabilities, wide array of styles and finishes, professional-grade craftsmanship, robust build quality.
- Price: A premium option, generally ranging from $200 to $600+ per door.
- Dimensions: Available in custom sizes tailored to your specific architectural needs, ensuring a perfect fit for any opening.
- Materials/Construction: Built using solid wood cores, high-quality veneered MDF, and durable lacquers or paints for a refined finish.
- Style: Offers a vast catalog of styles, from traditional shaker to modern minimalist, with options for custom hardware and detailing.
- Pros: Superior material quality and durability. Fully customizable size, style, and finish. Adds significant aesthetic and monetary value to a home. Built to last for decades.
- Cons: Significantly more expensive than any big-box alternative. May require professional measurement and installation. Longer lead times for bespoke orders.
Oxford Doors is for the homeowner or interior designer who needs a durable, perfectly fitted, and high-end door solution for a wardrobe or room opening.
Shop this product: oxforddoors.co.uk
IKEA Billy Byom vs. Oxford Doors Comparison
Materials & Construction
The materials divide these two products completely. An IKEA Billy Byom door is made from particleboard with a thin paper foil finish. While perfectly functional for light use on a bookshelf, this construction can be susceptible to moisture damage, peeling, and chipping over time. It's a lightweight, cost-effective material designed for affordability and easy assembly.
In contrast, an Oxford Door is built for longevity. Using solid wood cores and high-quality MDF with thick veneers or durable paint finishes, their doors have the weight, feel, and resilience of a permanent architectural feature. This robust construction ensures they won't easily warp, dent, or show wear, making them suitable for high-traffic areas like wardrobes and main doorways.
Dimensions & Customization
IKEA operates on a system of standard sizing. The Billy Byom doors are manufactured to fit the metric dimensions of the Billy bookcase perfectly, and cannot be used for any other purpose. There is no option for customization, you get what fits their system.
Oxford Doors' main selling point is customization. They can manufacture doors to precise measurements, down to the millimeter, to fit any non-standard opening, sloped ceiling, or unique built-in design. This bespoke approach is essential for home renovations where you're working with existing, often irregular spaces.
Style & Aesthetic
The Billy Byom door reflects IKEA's minimalist, Scandinavian design ethos. It’s clean, simple, and functional, available in a few basic colors like white to match the bookcases. The style is versatile in its simplicity but offers no unique character.
Oxford Doors provides a broad spectrum of aesthetic options. From classic paneled wardrobe doors to sleek, handleless contemporary doors, their catalog is extensive. Customers can choose from dozens of finishes, paint colors, and wood veneers to match a specific interior design scheme, making it a tool for designers rather than just a functional product.
Price & Value
There is a massive price difference here. A set of Billy Byom doors can cost under $100, providing incredible value for someone simply wanting to upgrade their storage. For the price, you get a clean look and added functionality instantly.
An Oxford Door is an investment, with prices starting at several hundred dollars. The value here is not in its low cost but in its long-term durability, perfect custom fit, and the premium look it brings to an interior space. It's built to last for the life of the home, not just until your next move.
Who Each One Works Best For
The IKEA Billy Byom is tailor-made for the massive market of Billy bookcase owners. It’s for renters who can't make permanent changes, students on a tight budget, young homeowners setting up their first space, or anyone who enjoys a good DIY project. It solves a simple problem: how to hide the clutter on your shelves cheaply and stylishly.
Oxford Doors is for homeowners, renovators, contractors, and interior designers working on projects where quality and exact fit are non-negotiable. They are ideal for custom-built wardrobes, high-end kitchen pantries, or any internal door that needs a specific look or size that off-the-shelf options can't provide. It's a choice for permanence and a premium finish.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both options serve completely different corners of the market, making the choice straightforward based on your project.
Choose the IKEA Billy Byom door if:
- You have an IKEA Billy bookcase and want an easy upgrade.
- Your budget is under $150.
- You're comfortable with basic DIY and flat-pack furniture assembly.
- You are renting or need a non-permanent storage solution.
Choose an Oxford Door if:
- You need a door for a custom-built wardrobe, a room, or another piece of cabinetry.
- Durability and high-quality materials are your top priority.
- You have a budget of $200+ per door and see it as a long-term home investment.
- You require a specific size, style, or finish that you can’t find in regular stores.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between IKEA Billy Byom and Oxford Doors?
The main difference is application and quality. The Billy Byom is a low-cost accessory exclusively for IKEA's Billy bookcase, made of particleboard. Oxford Doors are high-quality, made-to-measure doors for wardrobes and rooms, built from durable materials like solid wood and premium MDF.
Can I use an Oxford Door on an IKEA Billy bookcase?
It would be impractical and not cost-effective. Oxford Doors are much heavier and use different hinge systems than IKEA furniture. Custom-fitting such a high-quality door to a particleboard bookcase would be a difficult, expensive project that undermines the value of both products.
Are the IKEA Billy doors hard to install?
No, they are designed for easy DIY installation. The Billy bookcase frames come with pre-drilled holes, and the door packages include all the necessary hardware and instructions. All you typically need is a screwdriver.
Which brand is more durable?
Oxford Doors is far more durable. Their construction with solid cores and high-quality finishes is designed to withstand decades of daily use, while the IKEA Billy Byom's particleboard construction is suited for lighter use and is more susceptible to damage.
Do I need to hire a professional to install Oxford Doors?
While a skilled DIYer could potentially install them, professional installation is often recommended, especially for internal room doors or large wardrobe systems. This ensures a perfect fit, smooth operation, and a flawless finish, protecting your investment.
What are IKEA Billy Byom doors made of?
They are primarily made from particleboard or fiberboard with a paper foil laminate finish, along with a glass panel insert for the door window.
Can I paint IKEA Billy doors?
Yes, but it requires preparation. You would need to lightly sand the foil surface, use a high-adhesion primer designed for laminate surfaces, and then apply your desired paint. Without proper prep, the paint will not stick well and can easily scratch off.
How long does it take to get a custom door from Oxford Doors?
Lead times for bespoke products like custom doors can vary, but you can typically expect it to take several weeks from measurement confirmation to delivery. This is much longer than the instant availability of IKEA products.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
