A dedicated standalone ice cream maker from a brand like Cuisinart and the popular KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment offer two different paths to the same delicious destination. The key differences come down to convenience, cost, and counter space: standalone models are all-in-one machines, with premium options that don't require pre-freezing, while the KitchenAid attachment is a budget-friendly, space-saving accessory for those who already own the brand's iconic stand mixer.
Here's everything you need to know to decide which frozen dessert maker is the right addition to your kitchen.
Standalone Ice Cream Maker
A standalone ice cream maker is a dedicated countertop appliance built for one purpose: creating ice cream, gelato, sorbet, and frozen yogurt. They come in two main types: those with a freezer bowl that needs to be frozen solid before use, and more advanced compressor models that have a built-in freezer, allowing for spontaneous batch-making without any prep time.
- What it is: A dedicated, all-in-one appliance for making frozen desserts.
- Key features: Available in pre-freeze bowl or built-in compressor models. Typically includes a motor, churning paddle, and insulated bowl. Most have simple one-touch operation.
- Price: Ranges from ~$50 for basic pre-freeze models to $300+ for high-end compressor units.
- Style: Varies by brand, with many offering sleek stainless steel or colorful modern designs that sit directly on the counter.
- Capacity: Typically ranges from 1 to 2.5 quarts, suitable for small to large families.
- Pros: A complete, plug-and-play solution. Compressor models require zero pre-freezing. Consistent, smooth results. Can often make back-to-back batches (compressor models). Doesn't require any other appliances.
- Cons: A separate appliance that takes up dedicated counter or storage space. Can be expensive, especially for compressor models. Pre-freeze models still require 15-24 hours of freezer prep time.
This appliance works best for the frequent ice cream maker who values convenience and wants the ability to produce larger batches or multiple flavors in one day.
Shop this product type: cuisinart.com/shopping/appliances/ice_cream_sorbet_makers/
KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Attachment converts an existing stand mixer into a fully functional ice cream maker. The set includes a specially designed freezer bowl that locks onto the mixer base, a churning paddle (dasher) that attaches to the motor head, and a drive assembly. It leverages the powerful motor of your stand mixer to do all the churning work.
- What it is: An accessory set for KitchenAid stand mixers that includes a pre-freeze bowl and churning paddle.
- Key features: Double-walled insulated freezer bowl. Dasher rotates to spread, scrape, and mix ingredients. Connects seamlessly to the mixer's power hub.
- Price: Typically between $50 and $100. (Requires a KitchenAid Stand Mixer, which costs $200-$500+).
- Style: Designed to match the classic aesthetic of KitchenAid mixers, creating a cohesive look.
- Capacity: The standard bowl makes up to 2 quarts of dessert.
- Pros: Far more affordable if you already own a mixer. Saves significant cabinet and counter space compared to a standalone machine. Leverages the powerful and reliable motor of your stand mixer.
- Cons: Requires you to own a compatible KitchenAid mixer. Bowl needs to be frozen for at least 15-24 hours before use, eliminating spontaneity. Only one batch can be made before the bowl must be re-frozen.
The attachment is an excellent choice for a current KitchenAid owner who makes ice cream occasionally, wants to save money, and has limited storage.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/countertop-appliances/stand-mixers/attachments/p.ice-cream-maker-attachment.ksmicm.html
Standalone Ice Cream Maker vs. KitchenAid Attachment Comparison
Price & Value
The KitchenAid attachment is the clear winner on upfront cost if you already own the mixer, typically coming in under $100. A standalone machine starts around $50 but can easily exceed $300 for a powerful compressor model. The value proposition depends on your needs. For the occasional user, the attachment provides amazing value by expanding the functionality of an existing appliance. For serious dessert makers, the higher price of a compressor model pays for itself in convenience and the ability to make ice cream on a whim.
Convenience & Prep Time
This is the biggest point of difference. High-end standalone compressor models are the most convenient, allowing you to pour in your mixture and have fresh ice cream in under an hour with zero forethought. Basic pre-freeze models and the KitchenAid attachment are tied here - both require you to freeze the double-walled bowl for at least 15 hours. This means you can't satisfy a sudden craving, making ice cream becomes a planned activity. If you want on-demand frozen treats, a compressor model is unbeaten.
Performance & Consistency
Both options can produce excellent, creamy ice cream. The KitchenAid attachment benefits from the powerful, consistent torque of the stand mixer's motor, which can adeptly churn even thick mixtures. However, standalone machines are purpose-built for freezing. Compressor models, in particular, excel at maintaining even, intensely cold temperatures throughout the churning process, which can lead to smaller ice crystals and an even smoother final texture.
Storage & Footprint
For those tight on space, the KitchenAid attachment is the easy winner. It's essentially just a large bowl and a small paddle that can be tucked away in a cabinet or stored in the freezer, ready for use. A standalone ice cream maker is a whole other appliance to make room for on the countertop or in a pantry. Compressor models are particularly bulky due to their internal freezing components.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the dedicated machine and the mixer attachment make delicious homemade ice cream, but they cater to different kitchens and cooks.
Choose the Standalone Ice Cream Maker if:
- You make ice cream frequently and want the ultimate convenience (get a compressor model).
- You don't currently own a kitchen stand mixer.
- You love to entertain and want to make multiple batches of different flavors in one day.
- You have adequate counter or cabinet space for another appliance.
Choose the KitchenAid Attachment if:
- You already own and love your KitchenAid stand mixer.
- Your kitchen storage space is limited.
- You're on a budget and want to maximize the use of your existing tools.
- You make ice cream a few times a season and don't mind planning ahead to freeze the bowl.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between an ice cream maker and the KitchenAid attachment?
A standalone ice cream maker is an all-in-one appliance with its own motor and freezing mechanism. The KitchenAid attachment is an accessory that relies on the stand mixer's motor to churn and requires a separate pre-frozen bowl.
Do I really need a compressor ice cream maker?
If you want the ability to make ice cream spontaneously without planning a day ahead, yes. Compressor models have built-in freezers, eliminating the 15-24 hour wait time for freezing the bowl. For less frequent or more planned uses, a standard pre-freeze model works perfectly well.
How long does the KitchenAid bowl need to freeze?
KitchenAid recommends freezing the bowl for at least 15 hours, but for best results, a full 24 hours is ideal. It needs to be completely frozen solid to properly freeze the ice cream base as it churns.
Which one makes better tasting ice cream?
Both can make exceptional ice cream, and the quality of your ingredients is the biggest factor. However, compressor models often produce a slightly smoother texture because they freeze the mixture faster and more evenly, which creates smaller ice crystals.
Will the KitchenAid attachment fit any stand mixer?
It's compatible with most modern KitchenAid tilt-head and bowl-lift stand mixers, but it's always best to check your specific model number against the attachment's product page before purchasing.
How much counter space does a standalone ice cream maker take up?
The footprint is similar to that of a blender or small food processor, typically around 12x12 inches, though compressor models can be larger and heavier. It's a noticeable addition to a countertop.
Which option is easier to clean?
Both are quite easy to clean. The bowls, paddles, and lids are usually removable and just require hand washing with warm, soapy water. They are typically not dishwasher safe, especially the freezer bowl.
Is the KitchenAid attachment loud?
The noise level will be equivalent to your stand mixer's noise when running on its slowest "Stir" speed, which is its designated speed for ice cream making. This is generally a manageable, low hum.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
