The HexClad pan features a modern, patented hybrid construction combining a stainless steel structure with a non-stick surface, creating a durable and low-maintenance piece of cookware. A carbon steel pan is a traditional, single-layer piece of high-carbon steel alloy that requires seasoning to develop a natural, slick patina through use.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you decide which cookware option is the right fit for your kitchen.
HexClad Cookware
HexClad is a modern cookware brand known for its innovative hybrid design that merges the searing power of stainless steel with the convenience of non-stick. The unique hexagon-patterned surface is designed to be scratch-resistant, allowing for the use of metal utensils while offering easy cleanup. It's a popular choice for home cooks who want professional-grade results without complex maintenance routines.
- What it is: Hybrid cookware featuring a tri-ply construction with a laser-etched hexagon pattern that combines PFOA-free non-stick valleys with stainless steel peaks.
- Key features: Hybrid stainless/non-stick surface, scratch-resistant, dishwasher and oven safe, compatible with all cooktops including induction.
- Price: Mid-to-premium, with individual pieces ranging from $100 to $200 and sets costing several hundred dollars.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and professional. The distinct silver hexagon pattern gives it a high-tech, contemporary appearance.
- Materials/Construction: Three-layer construction with an aluminum core for even heating, sandwiched between two layers of stainless steel. The cooking surface is a hybrid of steel and a non-stick coating.
- Pros: Combines good searing capabilities with easy cleanup. Extremely durable and scratch-resistant for a non-stick product. Low maintenance - no seasoning required. Handles are comfortable and stay cool on the stovetop.
- Cons: High price point compared to traditional cookware. Not as "non-stick" as pure Teflon pans, still requires oil or fat. Heavier than carbon steel.
This cookware excels for those who prioritize convenience, durability in a non-stick pan, and a modern aesthetic and are prepared to invest in a premium product.
Shop this product: hexclad.com
Carbon Steel Cookware
Carbon steel is a classic cookware material beloved by professional chefs for its exceptional heat control, durability, and ability to develop a naturally non-stick surface over time. Composed of about 99% iron and 1% carbon, these pans are lighter than cast iron but offer similar searing power. They require an initial seasoning and ongoing maintenance, rewarding the user with a unique, slick patina that only improves with age.
- What it is: Traditional cookware made from an alloy of carbon and iron, favored in professional kitchens for its performance and longevity.
- Key features: Excellent heat responsiveness and retention, suitable for very high temperatures, develops a natural non-stick patina with use.
- Price: Generally affordable, with quality pans ranging from $30 to $150.
- Style: Utilitarian and classic with a rustic charm. The surface darkens from a silvery-gray to a deep black as its seasoning builds.
- Materials/Construction: A single, stamped sheet of high-carbon steel alloy.
- Pros: Superb heat control and searing capability. Becomes increasingly non-stick over time. Extremely durable and can last for generations. Relatively lightweight compared to cast iron. Affordable price point.
- Cons: Requires an upfront seasoning process and disciplined maintenance. Prone to rust if left wet or not oiled properly. Not dishwasher safe. Acidic foods can strip the seasoning.
Carbon steel is perfect for cooking enthusiasts who enjoy hands-on maintenance and want superior, high-heat performance for searing and browning.
Shop this product: mauvielusa.com/collections/m-steel-carbon-steel-cookware
HexClad vs. Carbon Steel Comparison
Materials & Construction
The core difference is in the construction. HexClad uses a modern, multi-layered approach: an aluminum core for even heat distribution is bonded between stainless steel layers, with a non-stick coating applied to the recesses of its signature hexagon pattern. This hybrid design seeks to provide the best of both worlds - durability and convenience.
Carbon steel's construction is simple and traditional: a single piece of carbon-iron alloy. It has no synthetic coatings or bonded layers. Its performance relies entirely on the quality of the base material and the seasoning layer built up by the user, creating a natural cooking surface that is part of the pan itself.
Heat Performance & Responsiveness
Carbon steel excels here. It heats up incredibly fast and is highly responsive to changes in burner temperature, giving the cook precise control. This responsiveness, combined with its ability to hold very high heat, makes it the top choice for searing steaks, stir-frying, and achieving a perfect char on vegetables.
HexClad's aluminum core provides very even, consistent heating across the pan's surface, reducing hot spots. However, it is not as responsive as carbon steel, it takes longer to heat up and longer to cool down. It sears well for a non-stick pan, thanks to its raised steel pattern, but can't match the raw searing power of a properly heated carbon steel pan.
Durability & Maintenance
This is where the two types of cookware diverge completely. HexClad is built for convenience. It's dishwasher safe, doesn't need to be seasoned, and is highly resistant to scratches from metal utensils. Its maintenance is as simple as washing it with soap and water.
Carbon steel requires a commitment to care. It must be hand-washed (often without soap), dried immediately and completely, and coated with a thin layer of oil to prevent rust. Its natural non-stick surface is something you build and protect with every use. While it is more work, a well-maintained carbon steel pan is nearly indestructible and can easily be restored even if it gets rusted.
Price & Value
Carbon steel offers exceptional value. A high-quality pan can be bought for under $80 and, with proper care, will last a lifetime, performing at a professional level. It’s a small investment for a piece of gear that will likely outlive its owner.
HexClad sits firmly in the premium category, with prices several times higher than carbon steel equivalents. The value proposition is in its technology, dual-purpose design, and convenience. You're paying for a product that reduces the fuss of cooking and cleanup while offering better durability than typical non-stick pans.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both cookware types are excellent, but they cater to very different cooks and priorities.
Choose HexClad if:
- You prioritize convenience and easy, dishwasher-safe cleanup above all else.
- The idea of seasoning and carefully maintaining a pan sounds like a chore.
- You want the ability to use metal utensils without worrying about destroying a non-stick coating.
- You cook a wide variety of foods and want one versatile, low-maintenance pan.
Choose Carbon Steel if:
- You want professional-grade searing performance for steaks, burgers, and stir-fries.
- You appreciate the ritual of caring for your kitchen tools and building a patina over time.
- Budget is a key factor, and you want the best performance-for-dollar.
- You value highly responsive cookware that gives you precise temperature control.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between HexClad and carbon steel?
The main difference is the surface. HexClad has a manufactured hybrid surface combining stainless steel peaks and PFOA-free non-stick valleys for easy maintenance. Carbon steel has a natural surface that must be seasoned with oil and heat to create its own non-stick layer.
Which is better for searing a steak?
Carbon steel is superior for searing. It can safely reach and maintain the extremely high temperatures needed to create a deep, flavorful crust on meat far better than any pan with a non-stick component.
Can you use metal utensils on HexClad?
Yes. The patented hexagon design features raised stainless steel rings that protect the non-stick coating in the valleys below. This makes it safe to use metal spatulas, whisks, and tongs without significant risk of scratching the surface.
Is HexClad truly non-stick?
HexClad is a non-stick hybrid. It's much slicker and easier to clean than pure stainless steel, but not as friction-free as a traditional Teflon pan. You will still need a small amount of oil or fat for delicate items like eggs, especially when the pan is new.
Does carbon steel rust?
Yes, because it's mostly iron, carbon steel will rust if exposed to moisture for prolonged periods. To prevent this, always dry the pan thoroughly after washing and apply a very thin coat of cooking oil before storing.
Why do so many professional chefs use carbon steel?
Chefs love carbon steel for its lightweight feel (compared to cast iron), its quick and responsive heating, and its durability. A seasoned pan can handle the high heat and heavy use of a commercial kitchen.
Is carbon steel hard to maintain?
There is an initial learning curve for seasoning and cleaning. However, once you develop a routine, maintenance becomes second nature and takes only a minute or two after cooking. The reward is a pan that performs better with every use.
Which pan lasts longer?
Both are built for longevity. A properly cared-for carbon steel pan can last for generations and can be sanded down and re-seasoned even after serious neglect. While HexClad is very durable, its non-stick component has a finite lifespan, though it's much longer than typical non-stick coatings.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
