The Herman Miller Aeron Onyx and Graphite models are functionally identical chairs, with the key difference being their color and finish. The Onyx is a deep, true matte black for a sleek and modern look, while the Graphite is the classic, slightly softer dark gray finish that Herman Miller is known for.
Here’s a detailed guide to help you decide which finish is the right aesthetic choice for your workspace.
Herman Miller Aeron Onyx
The Aeron Onyx is the chair’s all-black variant, prized for its bold, contemporary, and uniform appearance. This finish turns the iconic Aeron silhouette into a statement piece that fits perfectly within modern, minimalist, and high-contrast professional environments. It's the go-to for anyone building a sleek, dark-themed office setup.
- What it is: The true-black colorway of the iconic Aeron ergonomic office chair.
- Key features: Patented Pellicle mesh for breathability, fully adjustable arms, PostureFit SL back support, and Harmonic 2 Tilt. Available in sizes A, B, and C to fit different body types.
- Price: Approximately $1,200 - $1,500, depending on the configuration.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and minimalist. The Onyx finish is a deep, uniform matte black that absorbs light and has a strong visual presence.
- Materials/Construction: The same high-quality construction as other Aeron chairs, featuring an aluminum and reinforced plastic frame, a die-cast aluminum base, and a durable Pellicle mesh seat and back.
- Pros: A bold, striking aesthetic that creates a uniform look. The deep black color is timeless and pairs well with modern tech and minimalist decor. Functions identically to the classic Aeron.
- Cons: A matte black surface can show fine dust more readily than lighter colors. The stark look may not be as versatile in rooms with warmer, traditional color palettes.
The Aeron Onyx is for the person who wants a commanding, sleek, and cohesively modern aesthetic in their workspace.
Shop this product: hermanmiller.com/products/seating/office-chairs/aeron-chairs/
Herman Miller Aeron Graphite
The Aeron in Graphite is the original and most recognizable finish. It’s a versatile dark gray, not quite black, which allows it to blend into a wider variety of office environments seamlessly. Its softer tone offers a professional look without the starkness of a pure black, making it an adaptable and timeless choice.
- What it is: The classic dark-gray finish for the Aeron ergonomic office chair.
- Key features: Same world-class ergonomics as the Onyx version, including Pellicle mesh, PostureFit SL sacral and lumbar support, adjustable arms, and three distinct size options (A, B, C).
- Price: Approximately $1,200 - $1,500, matching the Onyx for identical configurations.
- Style: Classic, professional, and highly versatile. The Graphite finish is a textured dark gray that is less harsh than pure black, complementing both light and dark interiors.
- Materials/Construction: Identical to the Onyx model, utilizing Pellicle mesh along with a robust frame and base made from aluminum and industrial-grade plastic components.
- Pros: Extremely versatile aesthetic that fits almost any decor style. The softer color is less visually dominant in a room. Has been the industry standard for decades.
- Cons: As the most common color, it might feel less unique or distinctive to some users seeking a more-custom look.
The Aeron Graphite is perfect for those who want the proven ergonomic performance of the Aeron in a versatile, classic finish that complements any office decor without overpowering it.
Shop this product: hermanmiller.com/products/seating/office-chairs/aeron-chairs/
Aeron Onyx vs. Graphite Comparison
Style & Aesthetic
The entire choice between the Aeron Onyx and Graphite comes down to style. Onyx is a bold, modern, head-turning choice. It’s a deep, true black with a matte finish that works best in minimalist, high-contrast, or monochromatic spaces. Think a gaming setup or a sleek executive office. It makes the chair a focal point.
Graphite is the classic, understated option. As a dark gray, it feels softer and more integrated into a wider variety of settings. It doesn't command attention the way Onyx does, which allows it to blend with wood tones, bright colors, or corporate environments without clashing. If versatility is your priority, Graphite is the safe and proven choice.
Materials & Construction
There is absolutely no difference in materials or construction quality between the Herman Miller Aeron Onyx and Graphite models. Both are built in the USA using the same Pellicle mesh, the same reinforced plastic frame components, and the same die-cast aluminum bases. Both come with Herman Miller's 12-year warranty, which covers all parts and labor. The only variables are the pigment and finish applied during manufacturing.
Functionally, ergonomically, and in terms of durability, they are the exact same best-in-class product. You are not sacrificing any performance by choosing one color over the other.
Fit & Sizing
Both the Onyx and Graphite finishes are available for all three Aeron sizes: Size A (small), Size B (medium/standard), and Size C (large). Your height and weight will determine the right size for you, per Herman Miller's sizing chart. Color has no bearing on the dimensions, adjustability, or ergonomic fit of the chair itself. Each size provides identical levels of support and customization regardless of whether you choose Onyx or Graphite.
Price & Value
For any given configuration, the price of the Aeron Onyx and Aeron Graphite is identical. A fully-loaded Size B chair in Onyx will cost the same as a fully-loaded Size B in Graphite. Because the chairs are mechanically and materially the same, they also offer the exact same long-term value. The decision is purely based on which color you prefer, with no financial advantage to either option.
Who Each One Works Best For
The choice is simpler than you might think and boils down to your room's aesthetic. The Aeron Onyx is designed for users who are intentionally building a specific style. It caters to modern offices, sleek gaming setups, and minimalist decorators who want a bold, deep black element as part of their design. It is intentionally less versatile to achieve a more powerful look.
The Aeron Graphite is for nearly everyone else. It’s for people who want an excellent ergonomic chair that will look great today and ten years from now, regardless of how their office decor changes. Its dark gray color complements wood furniture, metal desks, colorful accents, and traditional corporate settings equally well. If you want a chair that simply works everywhere, Graphite is the answer.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both chairs offer a first-class ergonomic experience, so your choice should be based entirely on visual preference and your existing workspace.
Choose the Aeron Onyx if:
- You want a bold, modern, and sleek aesthetic.
- Your workspace has a minimalist, monochrome, or high-contrast color scheme.
- You want your chair to be a visual statement piece.
- You are building a setup with other true-black hardware and electronics.
Choose the Aeron Graphite if:
- You want a versatile chair that will fit with any decor style.
- You prefer a classic, understated, and professional look.
- You want a softer look than pure black provides.
- You value timelessness and adaptability over making a bold statement.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the main difference between Herman Miller Aeron Onyx and Graphite?
The only difference is the color. Onyx is a deep, matte black finish. Graphite is a classic, slightly textured dark gray finish. All ergonomic features, materials, sizing, and the warranty are identical.
Is Onyx a true black?
Yes, the Aeron Onyx is a solid, deep matte black across the mesh, frame, and base. It's designed for users looking for a genuine all-black chair.
Which color is more expensive?
Neither is more expensive. For the same set of features and size, the Onyx and Graphite models are priced identically.
Do they feel the same to sit in?
Yes, absolutely. Since the Pellicle mesh material, frame adjustment capabilities, and PostureFit SL support are the same, the comfort and ergonomic experience are identical across both colors.
Which color is more popular?
Graphite has been the classic best-seller for decades and remains incredibly popular due to its versatility. However, Onyx has become very popular in recent years with the rise of modern, minimalist home office and gaming setups.
Can I get Onyx and Graphite finish on all Aeron sizes?
Yes, both Onyx and Graphite colorways are available for Aeron Size A, Size B, and Size C chairs, allowing you to get the correct ergonomic fit in your preferred color.
Which color might show scratches or dust more easily?
Generally, a deep matte black finish like Onyx can make fine dust more visible than a slightly lighter, textured finish like Graphite. Both are extremely durable, but minor scuffs may blend in more easily with the slightly varied tone of Graphite.
Is one more durable than the other?
No. Both Aeron models are manufactured to the same high standards and are backed by Herman Miller's 12-year warranty. The durability and lifespan are expected to be the same, regardless of color.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
