The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer and Breville's range of juicers represent two different approaches to home juicing, primarily differing in price, materials, and motor performance. The Hamilton Beach is a budget-friendly juicer made mostly of plastic, designed for casual users who prioritize convenience and low cost, while Breville offers powerful, heavy-duty machines made with stainless steel and premium components aimed at serious juicers who want maximum yield and long-term durability.
Here's a detailed comparison to help you choose the right juicer from Hamilton Beach or Breville for your kitchen.
Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer
The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer is one of the most popular entry-level juicers on the market, known for its straightforward design and affordability. Its main selling point is the 3-inch wide feed chute, which drastically cuts down on prep time by allowing you to juice whole fruits and vegetables without much chopping.
- What it is: A centrifugal juicer designed for beginners and budget-conscious users seeking quick and easy operation.
- Key features: Large 3-inch feed chute, dishwasher-safe parts, powerful 800-watt motor, large pulp bin, and simple on/off operation.
- Price: Around $70-$100, making it highly accessible.
- Style: Functional and practical with a standard kitchen appliance look. Typically comes in black or with stainless steel accents.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made of durable, BPA-free plastic with a stainless steel micromesh filter and cutter.
- Pros: Very affordable, "Big Mouth" feed chute saves preparation time, parts are easy to find and dishwasher-safe for simple cleanup, straightforward assembly, and operation is great for beginners.
- Cons: The powerful motor can be loud, construction is not as durable as premium models, can struggle with leafy greens, and the juice yield is lower compared to high-end machines.
This juicer is an excellent choice for anyone new to juicing or those who juice occasionally and want a no-fuss machine without a significant financial commitment.
Shop this product: hamiltonbeach.com/easy-clean-big-mouth-2-speed-juice-extractor-67850
Breville Juicers (e.g., Juice Fountain Plus)
Breville juicers, like the popular Juice Fountain series, are considered a benchmark in the home juicing world for their performance, build quality, and sleek design. They are built for efficiency, extracting a high percentage of juice and leaving behind very dry pulp, which is a sign of a high-performance machine. Breville sets a standard with powerful motors, sharp cutting discs, and premium materials.
- What it is: A line of premium centrifugal juicers for serious home users who value efficiency, durability, and a professional-grade experience.
- Key features: High-power motors (up to 1200 watts), multiple speed settings for hard and soft produce, sophisticated pulp filtering, titanium-reinforced cutting discs, and heavy-duty die-cast metal or stainless steel construction.
- Price: Ranges from $200 to $400 or more, depending on the model.
- Style: Modern and sleek with a signature brushed stainless steel finish that looks at home in premium, contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: High-grade stainless steel body, titanium cutting blades, and high-quality, impact-resistant plastics for parts like the pulp bin and pitcher.
- Pros: Superior juice yield means less waste, powerful motors handle a wide variety of produce easily, durable construction ensures a long lifespan, multiple speeds offer better control and yield from leafy greens, and has a premium look and feel.
- Cons: High upfront cost, can be bulky on smaller countertops, can still be loud due to the powerful motors, and more parts can mean a slightly more involved cleaning process.
A Breville juicer is suited for the dedicated juicing enthusiast who wants to get the most nutrients and juice from their produce and is willing to invest in a machine that will last.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/juicers.html
Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer vs. Breville Comparison
Performance & Efficiency
The primary performance difference is juice yield. Breville juicers are engineered for maximum extraction, their juicing systems produce a noticeably higher volume of juice and leave behind much drier pulp compared to the Hamilton Beach. The powerful motors and multi-speed controls on Breville models also allow you to juice tricky items like leafy greens more effectively.
The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer does a fine job with hard produce like apples and carrots, but its single-speed, 800-watt motor is less efficient. You will notice wetter pulp and may need to use more produce to get the same amount of juice as you would from a Breville.
Durability & Materials
This is a clear win for Breville. Its juicers are constructed with a heavy-duty stainless steel housing, titanium-reinforced blades, and durable, high-quality polymers. This build quality is designed for frequent, heavy use and contributes to a much longer lifespan. Breville's premium materials also resist staining and odors better over time.
The Hamilton Beach is built primarily from plastic. While it's a durable plastic that's suitable for regular home use, it can't match the long-term sturdiness of Breville’s metal construction. Over years of use, the plastic parts are more susceptible to wear, scratches, and potential stress fractures.
Price & Value
At under $100, the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer offers incredible value. For a casual user who juices a few times a month, it's hard to justify spending four times as much on a premium machine. It provides a simple and effective entry into juicing without any financial risk.
Breville juicers are an investment. Starting at around $200, the price reflects superior performance, build quality, and design. For someone who juices daily, the higher juice yield can lead to cost savings on produce over the life of the machine, justifying its higher price tag. The value for a Breville user comes from its efficiency and longevity.
Style & Footprint
Breville excels in design. Its juicers feature a professional, brushed stainless steel finish that acts as a modern statement piece on any kitchen counter. They are designed to be seen. Hamilton Beach has a more utilitarian, functional design. It's not unattractive, but its plastic body and basic aesthetic prioritize function over form.
In terms of size, both brands offer models with similar footprints designed to fit on a standard kitchen counter. Both feature wide 3-inch feed chutes, making them comparable in day-to-day convenience for prepping produce.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both juicers serve their respective audiences very well, but your choice will depend entirely on your budget, juicing frequency, and priorities.
Choose the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth Juicer if:
- You are new to juicing and want an affordable way to start.
- You're on a tight budget and want the best value under $100.
- You plan to juice occasionally, perhaps a few times per week or month.
- You prioritize quick prep and easy cleanup over getting the absolute maximum juice yield.
Choose a Breville juicer if:
- You juice regularly (daily or multiple times per week) and see it as a long-term habit.
- You want the most efficient juice extraction to save on produce costs over time.
- Durability and premium, long-lasting materials like stainless steel are important to you.
- You care about aesthetics and want an appliance that looks sleek and professional in your kitchen.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Hamilton Beach Big Mouth and a Breville juicer?
The main differences are material quality, price, and juicing efficiency. The Hamilton Beach is a plastic-bodied, affordable ($70-$100) juicer for beginners, while Breville juicers are premium, stainless steel machines ($200+) with superior motors that extract more juice.
Which juicer is better for a beginner?
The Hamilton Beach Big Mouth is almost always the better choice for a beginner. Its low price point, simple operation, and easy-to-clean parts provide a perfect, low-risk introduction to juicing without the commitment of a more expensive machine.
Is the Breville really worth the extra money?
For a serious or daily juicer, yes. The higher initial cost is offset by better juice yield (you buy less produce over time), greater durability (it will last for years), and the ability to more effectively handle a wider range of produce, including soft fruits and leafy greens.
How easy are they to clean?
Both are designed for easy cleaning. Most removable parts on both the Hamilton Beach and Breville are dishwasher-safe. The process is similar for both: disassemble, rinse components, and clean the filter basket with the included brush. Breville’s filter baskets can sometimes be tighter, requiring a bit more effort to scrub clean.
Does the 3-inch "Big Mouth" chute save a lot of time?
Absolutely. Both brands often feature this size chute, which lets you add whole small-to-medium apples, peeled oranges, or large carrots with minimal or no chopping. This feature significantly reduces overall prep time compared to juicers with smaller chutes.
Which one produces juice with less foam?
Breville models generally produce less foam. Many come with pitchers that have a built-in foam separator, allowing you to pour juice while leaving most of the froth behind. More efficient extraction technology also contributes to a smoother juice texture.
Can they both juice leafy greens like spinach or kale?
Both can, but Breville juicers are much more effective. Their multi-speed settings allow you to use a slower speed for leafy greens, which increases the juice yield. Centrifugal juicers like the Hamilton Beach can struggle with leafy greens on a single high speed, often ejecting them into the pulp bin before fully extracting their juice.
How long do these juicers typically last?
With proper care, a Hamilton Beach Big Mouth can last for a few years of regular use. A Breville juicer is built as a long-term appliance and can easily last five to ten years or more, even with frequent use.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
