Gotham Steel offers widely available, budget-friendly cookware known for its durable titanium and ceramic non-stick surface, making it an accessible choice for everyday cooking. In contrast, Caraway is a premium, design-focused brand that sells direct-to-consumer, emphasizing minimalist aesthetics and a non-toxic, eco-friendly ceramic coating that comes at a higher price point.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right cookware for your kitchen.
Gotham Steel: The Affordable All-Purpose Cookware
Gotham Steel is a household name known for its practical, non-stick cookware that prioritizes function and affordability. Its signature ceramic coating infused with titanium appeals to home cooks looking for easy cleanup and reliable performance without a significant financial investment. The brand's widespread availability in major retail stores and online makes it a convenient option for quickly outfitting a new kitchen or replacing worn-out pieces.
- Product mix: A comprehensive range of cookware, including frying pans, stockpots, saucepans, griddles, and complete multi-piece sets. They also offer bakeware and kitchen accessories.
- Style/vibe: Functional and utilitarian. The design is straightforward, typically featuring black or metallic finishes with simple, practical handles built for performance rather than looks.
- Price point: Very budget-friendly. Individual pieces often cost between $20 and $50, while full cookware sets can be found for $50 to $150.
- Quality: The cookware is built with aluminum cores for even heating and features the brand's signature Ti-Cerama non-stick coating. While durable for its price, some users find the non-stick coating may wear down over time, especially with frequent use.
- Availability: Widely accessible through major retailers like Amazon, Walmart, and Bed Bath & Beyond, as well as on their own website.
- Assembly: Most pieces come fully assembled and ready to use. Lids may occasionally need their handles screwed on.
With its low cost and dependable daily performance, Gotham Steel is the choice for budget-conscious consumers who need functional, easy-to-clean cookware.
Shop Gotham Steel: gothamsteel.com
Caraway: The Stylish, Non-Toxic Choice
Caraway has quickly become a standout brand in the cookware market by combining modern, minimalist design with a commitment to health and sustainability. Its products feature a ceramic non-stick surface that is completely free of toxic materials like PTFE and PFOA. Marketed toward design-savvy and health-conscious consumers, Caraway cookware is sold as both a high-performance kitchen tool and a beautiful design element.
- Product mix: A curated selection of essentials, including a Fry Pan, Sauté Pan, Sauce Pan, and Dutch Oven, available individually or as a part of their iconic cookware set. They have since expanded to bakeware and linens.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and sleek with a clear Scandinavian influence. They are known for their signature color palette, which includes shades like cream, slate, and terracotta, making the cookware countertop-worthy.
- Price point: Premium. Individual pieces start around $145, and the flagship cookware set costs about $395, which includes magnetic pan racks and a canvas lid holder for storage.
- Quality: Built with an aluminum core for excellent heat conduction and finished with a durable, non-toxic ceramic coating. The construction feels substantial and is designed for long-term use and performance.
- Availability: Primarily sold direct-to-consumer through the Caraway website to maintain a premium shopping experience, though they are also available at select retailers like Crate & Barrel.
- Sustainability: This is a core part of the brand's identity. Caraway uses non-toxic materials, ships its products in eco-friendly packaging with no single-use plastics, and follows ethical manufacturing practices.
Caraway is ideal for those who are willing to invest more for beautiful design, health-safe materials, and a sustainably-minded brand.
Shop Caraway: carawayhome.com
Gotham Steel vs. Caraway Comparison
Price Comparison
The price difference between these two brands is the most significant factor. Gotham Steel is an entry-level, budget brand. You can outfit an entire kitchen with a 10-piece set for around $100. It offers fantastic value for students, first-time home cooks, or anyone who needs functional cookware without a large outlay.
Caraway operates in the premium space. A single pan can cost more than an entire set from Gotham Steel. Their flagship four-piece set costs around $395. This price reflects the non-toxic materials, superior construction, beautiful design, and thoughtful additions like the included storage organizers.
Style & Aesthetic
Gotham Steel’s design philosophy is purely utilitarian. The cookware is designed to perform its function efficiently, but it isn't meant to be a statement piece. It’s practical, simple, and blends into the background of a working kitchen.
Caraway’s aesthetic is one of its primary selling points. The clean lines, matte finishes, and exclusive colors are designed to be displayed. For those who curate their kitchen's visual appeal, Caraway cookware is an intentional design choice that complements a modern, minimalist home. Each set also comes with custom-fit magnetic pan racks and a lid holder, reinforcing the brand's focus on an organized and beautiful kitchen.
Quality & Materials
Both brands use an aluminum core for fast and even heat distribution, which is a standard choice for effective cookware. The main difference lies in the non-stick coating. Gotham Steel uses a coating made from ceramic and titanium, which is marketed for its toughness and durability against metal utensils.
Caraway utilizes a proprietary mineral-based ceramic coating that is 100% non-toxic and free of PTFE, PFOA, PFAS, and heavy metals. This makes it a great choice for health-conscious consumers. While both are effective non-stick surfaces, Caraway's build quality feels more substantial and is designed with more modern health and safety standards in mind.
Product Selection
Gotham Steel offers an enormous variety of products. Shoppers can find frying pans in every conceivable size, large multi-piece sets, griddles, specialty pans, and extensive bakeware collections. If you need a specific type of pot or pan, Gotham Steel likely makes an affordable version of it.
Caraway focuses on a much more curated model. Their core offering is a set of four essential pieces they believe covers most cooking needs: a fry pan, saucepan, sauté pan, and dutch oven. While they have expanded their line, the philosophy remains "fewer, better things." This is great for minimalists but may be limiting for cooks who want a wider assortment of specialized pans.
Sustainability & Ethics
Sustainability is a clear differentiator. Caraway’s entire brand is built around being a more thoughtful, environmentally conscious choice. From their non-toxic coatings that release less CO2 during production to their recycled cardboard packaging without any plastic bags, their commitment is evident. Gotham Steel, by contrast, does not market itself as a sustainable brand. Its focus is on mass-market production and affordability, and it doesn't offer transparency about its manufacturing or materials beyond the basics.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice depends entirely on your priorities. Both brands offer effective non-stick cookware, but they are built for very different customers.
Choose Gotham Steel if:
- You're shopping on a strict budget.
- You need a large number of pots and pans for a low price.
- You value function and ease-of-use over kitchen aesthetics.
- You prefer buying your cookware from a mass-market retailer like Amazon or Walmart.
Choose Caraway if:
- A design-forward, minimalist kitchen aesthetic is important to you.
- You prioritize cooking with non-toxic, eco-friendly materials.
- You are willing to invest in a high-quality set that is built to last.
- You appreciate thoughtful details like included storage organizers.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Gotham Steel or Caraway cheaper?
Gotham Steel is significantly cheaper. You can purchase a multi-piece cookware set from Gotham Steel for less than the price of a single frying pan from Caraway, making it the clear choice for budget-conscious shoppers.
Which has better quality cookware, Gotham Steel or Caraway?
Caraway has better overall quality. Its construction feels more premium, the non-toxic ceramic coating is designed for longevity, and the brand focuses on high-end materials. While Gotham Steel is durable for its price, Caraway is positioned as a long-term investment piece.
Is Caraway's cookware really non-toxic?
Yes. This is one of Caraway's biggest selling points. Their ceramic non-stick coating is 100% free of potentially toxic materials often found in traditional non-stick pans, including PTFE (such as Teflon®), PFOA, PFAS, lead, and cadmium.
How long does Gotham Steel's non-stick last?
The lifespan of Gotham Steel's Ti-Cerama coating depends on usage and care. While marketed as scratch-resistant, it's best to avoid metal utensils and harsh scouring pads. With proper care, it can last for several years, but some users report the non-stick properties diminishing over time.
Where can I buy Gotham Steel and Caraway?
Gotham Steel is widely available at mass-market retailers like Walmart, Target, and Amazon. Caraway is primarily sold direct-to-consumer through its own website, though it can also be found at premium retailers like Crate & Barrel.
Which brand is better for minimalist kitchens?
Caraway is the definitive choice for minimalist kitchens. Its curated set of essentials, clean aesthetic, and included organizers for neat, space-saving storage are perfectly aligned with minimalist principles.
Is Caraway worth the price?
For consumers who prioritize style, non-toxic materials, and a sustainable brand ethos, Caraway is often considered well worth the price. The investment gets you beautifully designed, high-performing cookware that’s also safer for you and the environment.
Does Caraway go on sale?
Caraway very rarely offers major discounts or sales, as it maintains its premium positioning. The brand typically holds one or two savings events per year, often around major holidays, but everyday discounts are uncommon.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
