Ethan Allen is known for its classic American heritage, offering high-end, customizable furniture with a focus on heirloom-quality craftsmanship and traditional design. In contrast, Crate & Barrel caters to a more modern audience with contemporary, clean-lined, and functional furniture at a more accessible mid-range price point.
Let's compare these two popular furniture retailers to help you decide which is the right fit for your home, style, and budget.
Ethan Allen: The Classic American Heritage Brand
With over 85 years in business, Ethan Allen has cemented its reputation as a premier American brand for high-quality, timeless home furnishings. The brand is a top choice for those seeking investment pieces, offering extensive customization options that allow shoppers to tailor fabrics, finishes, and configurations to create truly bespoke furniture. Their design aesthetic leans towards traditional elegance but incorporates contemporary sensibilities for a versatile, refined look.
- Product mix: A comprehensive selection of furniture for every room, including living, dining, bedroom, and home office, plus lighting, rugs, and decor.
- Style/vibe: Rooted in classic, transitional, and traditional designs. Expect rich woods, polished finishes, detailed craftsmanship, and a sophisticated feel.
- Price point: Mid-to-luxury. Sofas typically start around $2,000, dining tables from $1,500-$4,000, and comprehensive bedroom sets often exceed $5,000.
- Quality: Known for superior craftsmanship using high-quality solid woods, traditional joinery, and premium upholsteries designed for longevity.
- Customization: A key strength. A vast majority of their furniture can be customized with dozens of fabrics, leathers, wood finishes, and hardware options.
- Services: Offers complimentary interior design services through in-store and virtual consultations, helping customers plan their spaces with expert guidance.
- Delivery & Assembly: Provides a premium white-glove delivery service that includes assembly, placement, and removal of packaging materials.
- Sustainability: Strong commitment to responsible sourcing, using sustainably harvested wood and eco-friendly finishes, with many pieces crafted in their North American workshops.
Ethan Allen is ideal for homeowners who view furniture as a long-term investment and appreciate timeless design and bespoke quality over fleeting trends.
Shop Ethan Allen: ethanallen.com
Crate & Barrel: The Modern, Versatile Retailer
Founded in 1962, Crate & Barrel is a go-to retailer for contemporary furniture and home goods that balance style, function, and value. The brand is celebrated for its clean, modern aesthetic that fits seamlessly into a variety of interiors, from urban apartments to spacious family homes. In addition to furniture, they offer a massive selection of kitchenware, tableware, and decor, making it a one-stop shop for furnishing an entire home.
- Product mix: Extensive range of home furnishings, with a notably strong selection of living room and dining room furniture. Also famous for its expansive collection of kitchen goods, tableware, and wedding registry items.
- Style/vibe: Modern, minimalist, and contemporary with some Scandinavian and industrial influences. Designs feature clean lines, neutral palettes, and natural materials like wood and metal.
- Price point: Accessible mid-range. Sofas generally run from $1,200-$3,500, with bedroom furniture often in the $1,500–$3,500 range.
- Quality: Good, reliable quality for the price. Uses materials like solid wood, engineered wood, steel, and performance fabrics, with construction suited for modern production.
- Customization: Offers some customization on upholstered items like sofas and chairs, but with a more limited set of fabric and leg finish options compared to Ethan Allen.
- Shopping Experience: Modern and convenient, with a user-friendly website featuring customer reviews and virtual design tools. Their physical stores offer an inspiring, easy-to-browse layout.
- Delivery & Assembly: Provides multiple delivery options, including white-glove service for large furniture items. Many smaller items can be shipped directly.
- Sustainability: Prioritizes sustainability through responsible sourcing of materials like FSC-certified wood and collaborations with suppliers committed to eco-friendly practices.
Crate & Barrel is perfect for design-conscious shoppers seeking stylish, functional, and on-trend furniture at a reasonable price.
Shop Crate & Barrel: crateandbarrel.com
Ethan Allen vs. Crate & Barrel Comparison
Price Comparison
There is a clear difference in price between the two brands. Ethan Allen occupies a premium, mid-to-luxury position. Their prices reflect detailed craftsmanship, high-grade materials, and extensive customization, making it an investment. For example, a standard Ethan Allen sofa can easily cost over $3,000, while a solid wood bed frame could be $2,500+.
Crate & Barrel is considerably more budget-friendly, operating in the accessible mid-range market. A stylish fabric sofa from Crate & Barrel can often be found for under $2,000, and a comparable bed frame might be in the $1,500-$2,000 range. While still a step up from entry-level brands, Crate & Barrel offers excellent style and quality for a lower overall cost.
Style & Aesthetic
The design direction of each brand is a primary differentiator. Ethan Allen's aesthetic is rooted in classic American design, offering pieces that are traditional, transitional, and timeless. Their furniture often features elegant details, graceful proportions, and rich finishes, making it perfect for formal living rooms, distinguished dining rooms, and serene, classic interiors.
Crate & Barrel is firmly planted in the modern and contemporary space. Their collections are defined by clean lines, minimalist silhouettes, and a focus on functionality and simplicity. The overall feel is lighter, more casual, and well-suited for urban lofts, Scandinavian-inspired homes, and anyone who prefers an uncluttered, modern look.
Quality & Construction
Both brands offer quality products, but they approach it from different angles. Ethan Allen prides itself on heirloom-level quality. They use high percentages of solid wood, proven construction methods like traditional joinery, and hand-finished details. This results in incredibly durable, heavy furniture made to last for generations.
Crate & Barrel produces well-made, durable furniture designed for modern life. They use quality materials like solid hardwoods and performance fabrics, but their construction methods are geared more towards efficient, large-scale production. While their furniture is built to last for many years of normal use, it doesn't typically have the same heritage-level build quality as Ethan Allen.
Fit & Sizing
Ethan Allen’s furniture collections often feature generous, traditional proportions. Their sofas, sectionals, and dining tables are well-suited for larger, more spacious homes where scale is important. While they offer solutions for smaller rooms, their strength lies in filling a standard or large-sized space with stately pieces.
Crate & Barrel, with its focus on modern urban living, excels at providing options for smaller spaces. Many of their sofas have more compact footprints, and they offer a variety of modular and multi-functional pieces designed for apartments, condos, and open-concept layouts. Their furniture is often scaled to feel proportional in a wider variety of room sizes.
Shopping Experience
Shopping with Ethan Allen is a highly personalized, service-oriented experience. Their showrooms, known as Design Centers, are staffed by professional design consultants who offer complimentary services to help you plan your space, select fabrics, and coordinate pieces. It’s a hands-on, consultative approach.
Crate & Barrel offers a more streamlined, modern retail experience. Their website is robust and easy to navigate, with helpful filters, detailed product information, and customer reviews. Their physical stores are bright and inviting, encouraging customers to browse freely. While design help is available, the experience is generally more self-directed.
Sustainability & Ethics
Both brands show a strong commitment to sustainability. Ethan Allen has a long-standing initiative focused on responsible manufacturing within its own North American workshops, using sustainably harvested timber and promoting workplace safety. They are transparent about their vertical integration and sourcing practices.
Crate & Barrel also prioritizes responsible sourcing, using FSC-certified reclaimed and sustainable woods in many of their products. They work with artisan communities and ensure their global supply chain partners adhere to ethical labor and environmental standards.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your personal style, budget, and priorities. Both retailers offer excellent furniture, but they cater to very different needs.
Choose Ethan Allen if:
- You are looking for heirloom-quality furniture that is a long-term investment.
- Your home decor style is classic, traditional, or transitional.
- You want extensive customization options to create a unique piece.
- You value a personalized shopping experience with professional design guidance.
- You have a more generous budget to work with.
Choose Crate & Barrel if:
- Your home style is modern, minimalist, or contemporary.
- You need stylish, on-trend furniture at a more accessible mid-range price point.
- You are also shopping for kitchenware, tableware, or small decor items.
- You are furnishing a smaller space like an apartment or condo and need appropriately-scaled pieces.
- You prefer a straightforward online shopping experience with plenty of customer reviews.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Ethan Allen or Crate & Barrel more expensive?
Ethan Allen is significantly more expensive. It positions itself in the mid-to-luxury market, with prices reflecting its high-quality materials and customization options. Crate & Barrel is an accessible mid-range brand that offers stylish furniture at a more moderate price.
Which brand has better quality furniture?
Ethan Allen is generally considered to have superior, heirloom-level quality due to its focus on solid wood construction, traditional craftsmanship, and durable materials meant to last for decades. Crate & Barrel offers very good quality for its price point and is durable enough for everyday life, but it is not typically considered investment-grade furniture in the same way.
What style is Ethan Allen furniture?
Ethan Allen's signature style is classic, timeless, and transitional. Their collections blend traditional American and European design elements in a sophisticated and polished way.
What style is Crate & Barrel furniture?
Crate & Barrel's style is primarily modern and contemporary. Their furniture is characterized by clean lines, simple forms, neutral colors, and functional designs that suit modern living spaces.
Does Ethan Allen ever go on sale?
Yes, Ethan Allen holds sales events throughout the year, often centered around holidays. However, the discounts may be more modest compared to other retailers. Signing up for their newsletter is a good way to stay informed about promotions.
Is Crate & Barrel furniture good for first apartments?
Yes, Crate & Barrel is a great choice for a first apartment or starter home. It offers a significant step up in quality and style from budget brands without the high cost of luxury furniture, and many pieces are scaled for smaller living spaces.
Which brand is better for customization?
Ethan Allen is the clear winner for customization. They offer a vast array of fabric, leather, wood finish, and hardware options, allowing you to create a piece that is truly tailored to your home and tastes.
Can I get design help from these brands?
Absolutely. Ethan Allen is famous for its complimentary design service, where consultants can help you plan entire rooms free of charge. Crate & Barrel also offers free design services and virtual tools, providing mood boards and 3D renderings to help you visualize your space.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
