The Emile Henry pie dish and the Le Creuset pie dish are both high-end French bakeware staples, but they differ primarily in material, price, and thermal properties. Emile Henry's dishes are crafted from a proprietary Burgundy clay prized for its thermal shock resistance, allowing it to go from freezer to oven safely. Le Creuset dishes are made from dense, enameled stoneware, celebrated for extreme durability against chipping and staining, and featuring the brand's iconic vibrant colors.
Here’s a detailed comparison to help you choose the best pie dish for your kitchen and baking style.
Emile Henry Pie Dish
Known for its elegant craftsmanship, the Emile Henry pie dish is made in Marcigny, France, from a special Burgundy clay formula perfected over generations. Its standout feature is its ability to withstand extreme and sudden temperature changes, making it incredibly versatile. This dish is designed for both outstanding baking performance and beautiful table presentation, embodying a classic French country aesthetic.
- What it is: A high-quality ceramic pie dish made from French Burgundy clay, celebrated for being resistant to thermal shock.
- Key features: Can go directly from the freezer to a hot oven without cracking, highly resistant to chipping and scratches, diffuses heat evenly for uniform baking, microwave, oven, freezer, and dishwasher safe.
- Price: ~$45 - $55
- Style: Timeless and elegant with a ruffled or smooth edge. Available in a wide range of rich, often earthy colors like burgundy, slate, and olive.
- Materials/Construction: Made from a proprietary, high-fired Burgundy clay with a smooth glaze that won't absorb odors or stain.
- Pros: Excellent thermal shock resistance offers incredible versatility. Even heat distribution prevents hot spots for a perfectly browned crust. Lightweight compared to enameled stoneware. Highly resistant to chipping and crazing over time. Typically more affordable than Le Creuset.
- Cons: The glaze, while durable, may not be as completely impervious to scratches from sharp knives as Le Creuset's dense enamel. The color palette is beautiful but might be considered more classic or subtle than Le Creuset's bright, iconic hues.
The Emile Henry pie dish is perfect for bakers who value versatility and want a dish that can handle temperature extremes, all while delivering consistent, even baking results.
Shop this product: emilehenry.com/products/pie-dish
Le Creuset Heritage Pie Dish
From the iconic cookware maker Le Creuset, this pie dish is crafted from ultra-durable stoneware. It excels at heat retention, keeping your pie warm at the table long after it comes out of the oven. Known for its durable exterior enamel and a non-stick glazed interior, it resists chips, stains, and scratches, ensuring it looks beautiful for years. The Heritage Pie Dish combines traditional design with modern performance.
- What it is: A premium enameled stoneware pie dish from an iconic French brand, designed for superior heat retention and durability.
- Key features: Dense stoneware provides even heat distribution and exceptional heat retention. The exterior enamel is highly chip-resistant, and the interior glaze prevents sticking and staining. Oven, microwave, broiler, freezer, and dishwasher safe.
- Price: ~$55 - $75
- Style: Features the signature vibrant and contemporary colors Le Creuset is known for, with a glossy finish and a traditional waved or "heritage" style rim.
- Materials/Construction: Crafted from dense, high-fired stoneware with a smooth exterior enamel and a nonporous, glazed interior.
- Pros: Virtually nonstick interior releases food easily and cleans up quickly. Top-tier durability against chipping and staining. Exceptional heat retention keeps desserts warm for serving. A beautiful statement piece that matches other Le Creuset cookware.
- Cons: A higher price point reflects its premium branding. It is not designed to withstand extreme thermal shocks, so you shouldn't take it directly from the freezer to the oven. Can be heavier than comparable ceramic dishes.
The Le Creuset pie dish is ideal for the dedicated home cook who sees their bakeware as a long-term investment and values iconic style, maximum durability, and superior heat retention.
Shop this product: lecreuset.com/heritage-pie-dish
Emile Henry vs. Le Creuset Pie Dish Comparison
Materials & Construction
The core difference lies in their materials. Emile Henry uses a proprietary Burgundy clay that results in a lighter ceramic dish. This clay is specifically engineered to handle thermal shock, a key differentiator. The glaze is durable and fused directly to the clay, making it highly resistant to cracking.
Le Creuset uses a very dense stoneware, fired at extremely high temperatures and coated with a hard enamel finish. This process creates a heavier, more substantial dish with a nearly indestructible surface that's fantastic at resisting scratches from serving utensils and preventing stains from berry or tomato-based fillings.
Durability & Performance
Both dishes are incredibly durable, but they shine in different areas. The Emile Henry's main performance advantage is its ability to handle temperature changes seamlessly. This makes it a practical choice for assembling a pie and freezing it for later, then baking it directly from frozen.
The Le Creuset dish excels in heat retention. Its dense stoneware holds temperature exceptionally well, keeping your pie hot all through dessert. Its enamel coating also gives it a slight edge in resisting deep scratches and colorful stains over the long term, making it look new for decades.
Style & Aesthetics
Choosing between these two often comes down to personal style. Emile Henry offers a refined, French country aesthetic. Its colors are rich and sophisticated, with designs like the classic ruffled edge that feel both timeless and rustic. It blends beautifully into a kitchen that values elegant, understated quality.
Le Creuset provides a bold pop of color that is instantly recognizable. Pieces are designed to be shown off and are available in a huge spectrum of vibrant, glossy colors. For cooks looking to build a coordinated set of iconic cookware, Le Creuset is the clear choice.
Price & Value
Emile Henry generally offers better value from a pure price perspective, often costing $10-$20 less than its Le Creuset counterpart. For the price, you get an exceptionally high-quality, versatile French-made dish. Le Creuset commands a premium price for its brand legacy, iconic design, and supreme durability. If you view cookware as a lifetime investment and appreciate its status, the higher price is often considered justifiable.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both dishes are exceptional pieces of bakeware that outperform standard glass or metal pie plates, but they are built for slightly different priorities.
Choose Emile Henry if:
- You want to prepare and freeze pies, then bake them directly from the freezer.
- You appreciate a lighter-weight dish that's easier to handle.
- You're looking for premium French bakeware at a more accessible price point.
- You prefer a classic, understated French country style in your kitchen.
Choose Le Creuset if:
- You prioritize maximum durability against scratches, chips, and stains.
- You want your pie to stay as hot as possible when serving it at the table.
- Matching bakeware with your iconic Le Creuset Dutch oven is important to you.
- You love a bold color statement and view your bakeware as part of your kitchen decor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Emile Henry and Le Creuset pie dishes?
The main difference is the material and its properties. Emile Henry is made of Burgundy clay and is prized for its resistance to thermal shock (freezer-to-oven safe). Le Creuset is made of heavier enameled stoneware, known for extreme durability, chip resistance, and superior heat retention.
Is Emile Henry as good as Le Creuset?
Yes, Emile Henry is considered to be of the same high quality as Le Creuset, but with different strengths. It's a matter of preference: choose Emile Henry for thermal versatility and a classic look, or Le Creuset for iconic colors and ultimate durability.
Which pie dish bakes a better crust?
Both bake excellent crusts due to their even heat distribution. Because ceramic and stoneware heat gently and evenly, either dish will help you achieve a well-browned, flaky bottom crust without hot spots. Neither one is definitively "better," and both are a significant upgrade over metal or standard glass.
Can I put an Emile Henry dish from the freezer directly into the oven?
Yes. This is the standout feature of Emile Henry's "High Resistance" ceramic. It's designed to withstand extreme temperature changes without cracking, making it safe to go from freezer to a preheated oven (up to 520°F / 270°C).
Is Le Creuset stoneware worth the money?
For many home cooks, yes. Its price reflects immense durability, scratch and stain resistance, fantastic heat retention, and the prestige of the brand. If you bake frequently and want a beautiful piece that will last a lifetime, it's a worthy investment.
Which brand is easier to clean?
Both are very easy to clean thanks to their smooth, nonporous glazes. Food releases easily, and both are completely dishwasher safe. Le Creuset's dense enamel is particularly effective at resisting tough stains from things like baked-on berries over many years.
Do these pie dishes chip or scratch easily?
No. Both brands create products that are highly resistant to chipping and scratching under normal use. Le Creuset's hard enamel is particularly tough and less likely to show marks from metal serving utensils.
Which one is more durable long-term?
While both are built to last, Le Creuset's dense stoneware and tough enamel glaze give it a slight edge in long-term resilience against chipping, scratching, and staining. However, Emile Henry's resistance to crazing (small hairline cracks in the glaze) is also a strong mark of its durability.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
