The Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker and the Breville Smart Scoop both produce delicious homemade ice cream, but they differ fundamentally in technology, convenience, and price. Cuisinart’s popular models rely on a pre-frozen bowl that’s simple and affordable, while Breville’s offering is a premium machine with a built-in compressor for on-demand dessert-making and precise texture control.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right ice cream maker for your kitchen and your budget, from the trusted appliance experts at Cuisinart and Breville.
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker
Cuisinart ice cream makers are a reliable and incredibly popular entry point into homemade frozen desserts. Known for their simplicity and affordability, these machines, particularly the freezer-bowl models, have become a staple in many home kitchens. They offer a straightforward way to create ice cream, sorbet, or frozen yogurt with minimal fuss.
- What it is: A line of ice cream makers best known for models that use a double-insulated freezer bowl that must be frozen solid before use.
- Key features: Requires pre-freezing the bowl for 12-24 hours. The process is simple: freeze the bowl, add your mixture, and turn it on to churn for 20-30 minutes. Most models have a single on/off switch.
- Price: $50 to $200. Freezer-bowl models are typically under $100, while their less common compressor models are more expensive.
- Style: Functional and practical with a clean, utilitarian aesthetic. Usually available in neutral colors like white, black, or red that fit into any kitchen decor without standing out.
- Materials/Construction: Durable, BPA-free plastics for the housing and dasher, with a metal and gel-filled freezer bowl. The build is solid and designed for casual-to-regular home use.
- Pros: Extremely affordable and a great value. Very intuitive and easy to operate, even for beginners. The base is compact and easy to store. Consistent results for classic ice cream recipes.
- Cons: Requires significant pre-planning to freeze the bowl. The large bowl takes up considerable freezer space. You can only make one batch at a time before having to refreeze the bowl.
The Cuisinart is perfect for families, beginners, or anyone who enjoys making ice cream occasionally and values an affordable, easy-to-use appliance.
Shop this product: cuisinart.com/shopping/appliances/ice_cream_sorbet_makers/
Breville Smart Scoop
The Breville Smart Scoop is a high-end, feature-packed ice cream maker designed for the dessert enthusiast who craves control, convenience, and quality. Its built-in compressor eliminates the need for a freezer bowl, allowing for spontaneous batch testing and back-to-back creations. It's an investment piece that brings professional-level customization to your countertop.
- What it is: A premium, self-refrigerating ice cream maker with a built-in compressor and smart technology for customizing frozen dessert textures.
- Key features: No pre-freezing required. It offers 12 hardness settings for sorbet, frozen yogurt, gelato, and ice cream. Includes a pre-cool function to speed up the process and a keep-cool function that holds the dessert at the right temperature for up to 3 hours.
- Price: Around $500, positioning it in the premium appliance category.
- Style: Sleek, modern, and professional. The brushed stainless steel housing and digital interface make it a statement piece for contemporary kitchens.
- Materials/Construction: High-grade stainless steel body with sturdy plastic and metal components. Feels substantial and is built for durability and long-term performance.
- Pros: Makes ice cream on demand - no planning ahead. Highly flexible for making different types of desserts. Exceptional control over the final texture, a feature unavailable at this quality on any other type of machine. Ability to make multiple batches consecutively. Premium look and feel.
- Cons: Significant financial investment. Larger and heavier than Cuisinart models, requiring dedicated counter space. May be overly complex for a casual user who just wants simple vanilla ice cream.
The Smart Scoop is for the serious home cook or ice cream hobbyist who wants precise dessert customization and loves the ease of making things to exact user specifications.
Shop this product: breville.com/us/en/products/ice-cream/bci600.html
Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker vs. Breville Smart Scoop Comparison
Technology & Convenience
The main difference lies in their core technology. Most Cuisinart models use a freezer bowl that you must freeze for at least 12 hours. This workflow requires planning and uses valuable freezer space. It also means you can't make a second batch right away.
The Breville Smart Scoop's built-in compressor is a complete departure from this. Like a mini-freezer, it chills the mixture as it churns, meaning you can decide to make ice cream and be eating it an hour later. This convenience allows for spontaneity and making multiple, different-flavored batches for parties or gatherings.
Customization & Features
Cuisinart prioritizes simplicity. Its machines typically have a single switch: on. The machine churns until the ice cream reaches a standard soft-serve consistency, and then you're done. While you can make great sorbet and frozen yogurt, the machine doesn't differentiate between them.
Breville excels at customization. Its 12 hardness settings let you tell the machine exactly what you're making, from a soft sorbet to a dense gelato or hard-packed ice cream. The digital screen shows the temperature and progress, and the pre-cool and keep-cool functions add another layer of effortless control that makes the process feel more professional.
Materials & Construction
Cuisinart uses sturdy, food-safe plastics for its housing and parts. It's well-built for its price point and is known to last for years with proper care, but it has the look and feel of a standard kitchen appliance.
Breville uses high-grade brushed stainless steel for the machine's body, giving it a premium, durable feel. Everything from the buttons to the digital display feels substantial and is designed to complement other high-end appliances, reflecting its much higher price tag.
Price & Value
There's a massive price gap here. A Cuisinart freezer-bowl model is an impulse buy for many, often costing under $100. It offers incredible value for someone new to homemade ice cream or who only makes it a few times a year.
At around $500, the Breville is a serious investment. Its value lies in its convenience, precision, and build quality. For someone who makes frozen desserts weekly or is a passionate food hobbyist, a feature-loaded machine makes the money well worth it, given how long a machine from Breville usually lasts.
Who Each One Works Best For
Your ideal machine comes down to your priorities, budget, and kitchen habits. For the casual dessert maker, the Cuisinart brand has proven reliable for a whole generation now with no one questioning its place at its price point.
If you see homemade ice cream as a culinary hobby rather than just an occasional treat, the premium features and spontaneous convenience of the Breville Smart Scoop would make it a joy to use on a regular basis, providing a wide level of flexibility you may eventually decide you can't live without.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are great at what they do, but they are built for entirely different users and budgets.
Choose the Cuisinart Ice Cream Maker if:
- You're new to making your own ice cream and want an affordable, no-risk starting point.
- Budget is your top priority.
- You have plenty of freezer space and don't mind planning your dessert-making in advance.
- You make ice cream occasionally for special occasions or family treats.
- You prefer simple appliances with straightforward, one-button operation.
Choose the Breville Smart Scoop if:
- You're a passionate home cook or dessert hobbyist who values precision.
- You want the ability to create frozen desserts spontaneously, whenever the mood strikes.
- You entertain often and want to create multiple batches or flavors back-to-back.
- Long-term durability in addition to a suite of features is your main buying consideration.
- Your kitchen aesthetic favors sleek, modern, stainless steel appliances you may choose to leave out proudly when not in active use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between Cuisinart and Breville ice cream makers?
The primary difference is the cooling method. Most Cuisinart models use a freezer bowl that you must freeze solid for 12-24 hours beforehand. The Breville Smart Scoop has a built-in compressor, so it chills itself and requires no pre-freezing, allowing you to churn another batch immediately upon finishing.
Do I really need a compressor ice cream maker?
A machine with a compressor is not necessary for everyone. Many users make excellent use of the more affordable freezer bowl models. However, these require meticulous attention to procedure to ensure quality results.
How much ice cream does each machine make?
The capacity can vary slightly between models, but a Cuisinart machine often makes a batch equivalent to one or two quarts (32-64 ounces). The real deciding factor between models is not capacity, but other features and convenience.
Is a Cuisinart machine more work because it requires freezing its churning bowl?
While using a Cuisinart does require some advance planning due to the need to freeze the bowl, the process is straightforward. If you can manage to place the bowl in the freezer a few hours before use, the machine itself is very easy to operate, with churning typically taking 10 to 30 minutes.
Is the Breville Smart Scoop noisy during operation?
The Breville Smart Scoop is somewhat noisier than the Cuisinart due to its powerful compressor and feature set. However, this is a minor inconvenience that most users become accustomed to over time.
Can I make gelato and sorbets with the Cuisinart?
Yes, the Cuisinart can make gelato and sorbet. It may require slight technique adjustments for optimal results. The Breville, with its preset options and precise control, simplifies this process further.
How long does it usually take to make a batch of ice cream?
For both machines, churning typically takes under 45 minutes, based on most users' experiences. The additional time is mostly for preparation steps like freezing the bowl (for Cuisinart) or setting up ingredients.
Is the price of the Breville justified?
The Breville Smart Scoop is a high-end purchase, offering many advanced features for dedicated ice cream enthusiasts. It is built to last and can pay for itself over time through the enjoyment and homemade desserts it enables.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
