Cuisinart flat top grills are designed for versatility and convenience, offering compact, easy-to-clean models perfect for small spaces and casual home cooks. In contrast, Blackstone specializes in large, durable, high-heat griddles built as outdoor workhorses for serious enthusiasts who need ample cooking space and rugged performance. The key differences lie in Cuisinart's focus on portability and user-friendly features versus Blackstone's emphasis on size, heat retention, and heavy-duty construction.
Let's compare everything you need to know to choose the right flat top grill for your needs.
Cuisinart: The Versatile & Compact Griddle
Cuisinart is a well-known name in kitchen appliances, and their outdoor cooking line extends this legacy of quality and user-friendly design. Their flat top grills are aimed at home cooks who want a versatile, reliable griddle without the commitment of a massive, permanent outdoor setup. These grills are often praised for their even heating, sleek look, and features designed for convenience.
- Product mix: A range of portable and freestanding flat top grills, often featuring non-stick surfaces, adjustable heat controls, and integrated grease management.
- Style/vibe: Sleek, modern, and compact. Cuisinart's designs are clean and minimalist, making them suitable for patios, balconies, or even tabletop use for some models.
- Price point: Generally falls in the mid-range. Smaller, portable models start around $150, while larger freestanding units can go up to $400.
- Quality & Materials: Typically constructed with heavy-gauge steel or aluminum non-stick cooking surfaces for even heating and easy cleanup. Burners and housings often feature stainless steel components for durability.
- Fit & Sizing: Cuisinart offers a good variety of sizes, with popular portable models around 22 inches and larger freestanding options up to 36 inches. They are a great fit for small households or those with limited outdoor space.
- Key Features: Many models include features like folding legs for portability, twist-start ignitions, and built-in paper towel holders, prioritizing a seamless user experience.
Cuisinart provides an accessible and convenient entry into flat top grilling, ideal for those who value ease of use and portability over massive cooking capacity.
Shop Cuisinart: cuisinart.com
Blackstone: The Outdoor Grilling Workhorse
Blackstone has become almost synonymous with outdoor flat top grilling, building a loyal following with its robust, powerful, and large-capacity griddles. The brand is focused exclusively on creating high-performance outdoor cooking equipment designed to handle everything from morning pancakes for a crowd to evening hibachi dinners. Their griddles are built to last and deliver consistent, restaurant-quality results in a backyard setting.
- Product mix: An extensive lineup of flat top grills and griddles, from smaller tabletop versions to massive 36-inch, four-burner models. They also offer a wide array of griddling accessories.
- Style/vibe: Rugged, utilitarian, and functional. Blackstone griddles have a distinct industrial look with black powder-coated steel frames and prominent controls, prioritizing durability over sleek aesthetics.
- Price point: Mid to upper-mid range. Smaller models start around $200, but their popular 28-inch and 36-inch griddles typically cost between $300 and $500.
- Quality & Materials: Known for its heavy-duty construction, Blackstone uses cold-rolled steel for its cooking surfaces, which provides excellent heat retention and searing capabilities. Frames are made of thick, sturdy steel.
- Fit & Sizing: While they offer smaller options, Blackstone's strength is in its larger griddles (28 to 36 inches), which provide hundreds of square inches of cooking space for large families or gatherings.
- Key Features: Blackstone's signature features include powerful H-style burners for even heat distribution, a patented rear grease management system for easy cleanup, and foldable legs or wheeled carts on most models.
Blackstone is the choice for serious outdoor cooks who need a durable, high-heat griddle capable of feeding a crowd with ease.
Shop Blackstone: blackstoneproducts.com
Cuisinart vs. Blackstone Comparison
Price Comparison
In a direct comparison, Cuisinart's entry-level models are often more affordable, making them a budget-friendly choice for beginners or casual users. A portable Cuisinart griddle can be found for under $200. Blackstone's pricing starts slightly higher, reflecting their focus on larger, more robust builds.
However, when looking at value on larger models, the price difference narrows. Blackstone often provides more cooking surface area and higher BTU output for the money, making it a better investment for those who cook outdoors frequently or for large groups. Cuisinart offers reliable performance at a great price, while Blackstone delivers heavy-duty capacity for a moderate price premium.
Style & Aesthetic
The two brands present very different styles. Cuisinart favors a polished and modern aesthetic with smooth lines, stainless steel accents, and a compact footprint. Their grills look at home on a clean, contemporary patio and are designed to be unintrusive.
Blackstone, on the other hand, embraces a rugged, industrial design. Their grills are large, functional-looking machines built for performance. The black steel and prominent controls signal that this is a serious piece of cooking equipment. Your choice here depends entirely on personal preference: sleek and modern or rugged and functional.
Quality & Construction
Both brands produce quality grills, but their material choices reflect their target user. Cuisinart often uses non-stick cooking surfaces made from aluminum or coated steel, which heat up quickly and are incredibly easy to clean. This is great for convenience but may not offer the same longevity or high-heat searing capabilities as other materials.
Blackstone's signature is its cold-rolled steel cooktop. This material behaves similarly to cast iron - it requires seasoning but offers unparalleled heat retention and distribution, creating a naturally non-stick surface over time that can handle extremely high temperatures. The frame and body are also built from thicker gauge steel, making a Blackstone grill feel more substantial and durable for purely outdoor life.
Fit & Sizing
Sizing is a major differentiator. Cuisinart excels in the compact to mid-size category. Their tabletop and portable models, like the popular 22-inch griddle, are perfect for camping, picnics, or small balconies where a full-size grill won't fit.
Blackstone is the leader in large-format griddles. Their 28-inch and 36-inch models are standards in backyard cooking, providing enough space to cook multiple types of food simultaneously for a large group. If you're imagining hosting pancake breakfasts or making Philly cheesesteaks for a party, Blackstone's size is a clear advantage.
Shopping Experience
Both brands are widely accessible. You can find Cuisinart and Blackstone grills at major retailers like Amazon, Walmart, Target, Home Depot, and Lowe's, as well as on their respective direct-to-consumer websites. Both offer clear product information online and good customer support.
Blackstone has fostered a stronger community around its brand, with numerous online groups, recipe forums, and a vast ecosystem of first-party accessories. This can enhance the new owner's experience. Warranties for both are typically in the 1 to 3-year range, which is standard for the category.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both brands make excellent flat top grills, but they cater to different outdoor chefs and their specific needs.
Choose Cuisinart if:
- You have limited space on a small deck, patio, or balcony.
- Portability is a top priority for camping, tailgating, or RV trips.
- You value quick and easy cleanup with a non-stick surface.
- You are new to griddling and want a user-friendly, affordable starter model.
Choose Blackstone if:
- You regularly cook for a large family or host backyard parties.
- You want maximum heat output for achieving a perfect sear on steaks and burgers.
- Durability and a heavy-duty, outdoor-ready build are most important.
- You want to join a large community of fellow griddlers for tips and recipes.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cuisinart or Blackstone cheaper?
Cuisinart's smaller, portable models generally have a lower entry price, making them more affordable upfront. While Blackstone starts at a slightly higher price point, their larger models often provide better value in terms of cost per square inch of cooking space.
Which has better quality flat top grills?
Both have good quality for their price points, but they emphasize different things. Blackstone is known for its heavy-duty cold-rolled steel tops and rugged frames, making it more durable for heavy outdoor use. Cuisinart offers reliable performance and quality components with a focus on convenience and easier-to-clean materials.
Which flat top grill is easier to clean?
Cuisinart is typically easier to clean for day-to-day use, as many of its models feature non-stick surfaces that can be quickly wiped down. Blackstone's steel surface requires seasoning and a specific scraping and oiling process after each use, similar to caring for a cast iron skillet.
Which is better for beginners?
Many beginners find Cuisinart grills more approachable. Their smaller size, simpler ignition systems, and non-stick surfaces reduce the initial learning curve. Blackstone requires learning how to properly season and maintain the cooktop, which can be a new skill for some.
Can you use a Cuisinart flat top grill indoors?
Gas-powered Cuisinart grills are strictly for outdoor use due to carbon monoxide emissions. However, the brand may offer specific electric indoor/outdoor models. Always check the product manual to confirm whether a specific grill is safety-rated for indoor use.
Which brand offers more cooking space?
Blackstone is the clear winner for cooking space. Their 36-inch models offer over 700 square inches of griddling real estate, which is significantly more than most comparable models from other brands.
What are Blackstone griddles made of?
Blackstone griddle tops are made from heavy-duty cold-rolled steel. This material is excellent for heat distribution and retention, which helps create an even, consistent cooking surface perfect for searing and getting great crusts on food.
How portable are these grills?
While both brands offer "portable" models, Cuisinart's tabletop designs and smaller grills with folding legs are generally lighter and more compact, making them easier to transport for camping or picnics. Blackstone's models, even those with folding legs, are heavier due to their robust construction.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
