Cuddledown offers handcrafted, ultra-luxurious bedding with a classic aesthetic, focusing on premium materials like Egyptian cotton and ethically sourced down. In contrast, Brooklinen is a modern, direct-to-consumer brand known for stylish, high-quality bedding at more accessible price points with a sleek, minimalist vibe.
Let's break down everything you need to know to choose the right bedding for your space.
Cuddledown: The Handcrafted Luxury Bedding Brand
Cuddledown is an established brand that has built a reputation for meticulous craftsmanship and exceptional natural materials. Catering to shoppers who seek timeless elegance and long-lasting quality, Cuddledown specializes in high-end essentials like down comforters and high-thread-count sheets that are designed as long-term investments in sleep comfort.
- Product mix: Their core focus is on luxury sleep essentials, including high-thread-count sheets, ethically sourced down comforters, pillows, and mattress toppers. The offerings feel curated and specialized.
- Style/vibe: Classic, timeless, and understated elegance. Their designs feature subtle patterns and solid colors that prioritize texture and quality over fast-moving trends, fitting well with traditional or sophisticated decor.
- Price point: Premium to luxury. Sheet sets typically start around $200 and can go much higher, while their renowned down comforters often cost over $300.
- Quality & Materials: This is where Cuddledown excels. They use high-end natural fibers like authentic Egyptian cotton and Belgian linen, and are known for ethically sourced, high-fill-power down.
- Customization: Cuddledown offers custom sizing and tailored bedding options, a significant benefit for anyone with a non-standard mattress or specific requests.
- Sales: Sales are typically less frequent than mainstream brands, often centering around major holidays.
- Sustainability & Ethics: Emphasizes responsible sourcing with certifications like the Responsible Down Standard (RDS) to ensure animal welfare.
Cuddledown is the choice for shoppers who prioritize premium materials, heritage craftsmanship, and long-lasting quality and are willing to invest in a superior sleep experience.
Shop Cuddledown: cuddledown.com
Brooklinen: The Modern Bedding Disruptor
Brooklinen exploded onto the scene as a direct-to-consumer brand with a mission to make luxury-quality bedding more accessible. By cutting out the middleman, they offer stylish, comfortable, and well-made home essentials at a mid-range price point, appealing to modern consumers who value both quality and smart design.
- Product mix: A wide range of home goods centered on comfort. This includes their famous sheets, comforters, and pillows, but extends to loungewear, towels, bathrobes, and even home accessories.
- Style/vibe: Modern, sleek, and minimalist. They favor neutral color palettes, simple patterns, and clean lines that complement contemporary decor styles.
- Price point: Accessible-premium. Their popular sheet sets generally range from $100 to $200, with value-driven bundles and frequent sales lowering the cost.
- Quality & Materials: Brooklinen uses high-quality materials like long-staple cotton for their signature percale and sateen weaves, as well as linen and down alternatives. The quality is excellent for the price.
- Sales: The brand is known for its frequent sales events, making their products even more affordable. Black Friday and their anniversary sale are major events.
- Shipping & Returns: Offers a streamlined online shopping experience with fast shipping and a generous return policy, making it easy and risk-free to try their products.
- Sustainability & Ethics: The brand is committed to sustainability through responsible material sourcing, minimizing waste, using eco-friendly packaging, and offering carbon-neutral shipping options.
Brooklinen delivers a fantastic balance of a modern aesthetic, dependable quality, and value, making it ideal for shoppers who want beautiful, long-lasting bedding without paying traditional luxury markups.
Shop Brooklinen: brooklinen.com
Cuddledown vs. Brooklinen Comparison
Price Comparison
The price difference is one of the most significant factors separating the two brands. Cuddledown positions itself as a luxury brand, and its prices reflect that. Shoppers should expect to pay a premium for their handcrafted products, with percale sheet sets starting over $200. This is an investment in top-tier materials and durability.
Brooklinen offers a much more accessible entry point to high-quality bedding. Their best-selling Classic Percale sheet sets are often priced under $170 for a queen size. Combined with frequent sales and bundle deals, Brooklinen provides exceptional value and makes premium materials attainable for a wider audience.
Quality & Materials
Cuddledown's main selling point is its use of exceptionally high-end and specialty materials. Their use of genuine Egyptian cotton, fine Belgian linen, and Responsible Down Standard (RDS) certified down is a clear indicator of their focus on uncompromising quality. The emphasis on handcrafted details ensures a durable product that's made to last for many years.
Brooklinen also prioritizes quality, primarily using long-staple cotton, which is soft, strong, and durable. While their materials are excellent and represent a major step up from mass-market bedding, they generally don't reach the same ultra-premium, specialty level as Cuddledown. For most consumers, Brooklinen's quality is more than sufficient and feels incredibly comfortable and lasting.
Style & Aesthetic
Your style preference will be a key decider here. Cuddledown leans into a classic, traditional aesthetic. Think crisp white hotel bedding, subtle jacquards, and elegant, timeless designs. Their color palette is often soft and sophisticated, perfect for creating a serene and luxurious bedroom sanctuary that will not go out of style.
Brooklinen’s look is distinctly modern and minimalist. They utilize a mix of neutral tones and limited-edition colors and patterns that appeal to contemporary tastes. Their styling is simple, clean, and effortlessly chic, making it easy to create a layered, visually appealing bed that fits with today's trends.
Shopping Experience
Cuddledown provides a more boutique shopping experience. A key advantage is their ability to create custom-sized bedding, catering to clients with unique needs - something rarely offered by online-first brands. Their customer service is personalized, focusing on helping you find the perfect luxury product.
Brooklinen offers a modern, streamlined, and user-friendly digital experience. Their website is easy to navigate, with thousands of positive customer reviews to help guide decisions. The brand's generous and hassle-free return policy shows confidence in their products and makes purchasing feel low-risk.
Which One Should You Choose?
The right choice comes down to your budget, style preferences, and what you prioritize in bedding. Both brands excel in their respective categories.
Choose Cuddledown if:
- You are making a long-term investment in bedding and are willing to pay for top-tier quality.
- You value the superior feel of materials like authentic Egyptian cotton and high-fill-power, ethically sourced down.
- Your design style is classic, traditional, or you love the look of five-star hotel bedding.
- You need custom sizing for an antique, oversized, or non-standard mattress.
Choose Brooklinen if:
- You want a major quality upgrade from standard department store bedding at a reasonable price.
- Your home has a modern, minimalist, or contemporary aesthetic.
- You value a simple online shopping experience with free shipping and flexible returns.
- You enjoy the value that comes from shopping sales and saving on product bundles.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Cuddledown or Brooklinen cheaper?
Brooklinen is significantly cheaper than Cuddledown. Brooklinen's sheet sets typically range from $100-$200, while Cuddledown's start around $200 and go up from there, reflecting their position as a true luxury brand.
Which has better quality furniture?
While both brands offer high-quality products, Cuddledown is generally considered to be of a higher, more luxurious quality due to its use of premium materials like Egyptian cotton and its attention to handcrafted detail. Brooklinen provides excellent quality for its price point that will satisfy the vast majority of shoppers.
What is the main style difference between Cuddledown and Brooklinen?
Cuddledown embodies a classic, timeless, and elegant style ideal for traditional decor. Brooklinen offers a modern, minimalist look with clean lines and neutral tones that fit perfectly in contemporary homes.
Does Cuddledown or Brooklinen have better down comforters?
Cuddledown specializes in down products and is known for its wide range of high-quality, ethically sourced down comforters with various warmth levels and fill powers. They are the specialists in this category. Brooklinen offers very popular down and down-alternative comforters that are comfortable and well-made for the price.
Which brand is better for hot sleepers?
Both brands offer great options. Brooklinen's Classic Percale collection is famously crisp, lightweight, and breathable, making it a top choice for hot sleepers. Cuddledown also offers excellent cotton percale and linen sheets that promote airflow and help keep you cool.
Do Cuddledown and Brooklinen have physical stores?
Brooklinen is primarily a direct-to-consumer online brand, though they have a few physical storefronts in major cities. Cuddledown sells primarily through its website and catalog but can also be found in select high-end bedding retailers.
How do their return policies compare?
Brooklinen is known for its generous 365-day return policy on most items, making purchases very low-risk. Cuddledown offers a more traditional return policy, typically within 30 days, though custom-made items are often final sale.
Which brand goes on sale more often?
Brooklinen has frequent sales, bundles, and promotions throughout the year, especially around major holidays and its own anniversary sale. Cuddledown promotions are generally less frequent, which is typical for luxury brands.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
