The Ninja Creami and the KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker both promise homemade frozen desserts, but they operate on fundamentally different principles. The Creami is a compact, all-in-one appliance that "shaves" pre-frozen solid bases into incredibly smooth treats in minutes, ideal for single servings and variety. The KitchenAid model is a classic-style attachment that churns liquid bases inside a large, frozen bowl, designed for making bigger batches of traditional ice cream.
Here's everything you need to know to choose the right ice cream maker for your kitchen.
Ninja Creami
Part of the Ninja Kitchen family, the Creami has become a viral sensation for its unique approach to making frozen treats. Instead of churning a liquid, you freeze a solid block of ingredients in its special "pint" containers. When you're ready, the machine's high-speed blade shaves and blends the block into everything from creamy ice cream and sorbet to milkshakes and smoothie bowls.
- What it is: A countertop appliance that transforms pre-frozen ingredient bases into single-serving frozen desserts.
- Key features: Dedicated presets for Ice Cream, Lite Ice Cream, Sorbet, Gelato, Milkshake, Smoothie Bowl, and Mix-in. Comes with one or more single-serving "pints" with lids for freezing and storage.
- Price: Around $199 - $229, depending on the model and included accessories.
- Materials/Construction: Primarily made of durable, lightweight plastics with a sleek and modern design. Parts are generally easy to clean and top-rack dishwasher safe.
- Style: Modern, compact, and vertical. It has a small footprint that fits well on most countertops without taking up too much space.
- Pros: Extremely versatile with multiple dessert functions. Fast processing time (under 5 minutes from freezer to spoon). Creates uniquely smooth and creamy textures. Excellent for creating customized, single-serving portions. Easy to clean up.
- Cons: Requires you to pre-freeze your mixture for a full 24 hours. Small batch size is not ideal for serving a crowd. The machine can be quite loud during operation.
The Creami is ideal for individuals, couples, or small families who love experimenting with different flavors and value the convenience of creating on-demand, single-serving treats.
Shop this product: ninjakitchen.com/products/ninja-creami-ice-cream-gelato-and-sorbet-maker-zidNC301
KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker Attachment
From the iconic KitchenAid brand, this ice cream maker is not a standalone machine but an attachment for their legendary stand mixers. It uses a traditional churning method, where a large, pre-frozen insulated bowl works with a special moving dasher (or paddle) powered by the mixer's motor to slowly freeze and aerate a liquid ice cream base into a rich, classic dessert.
- What it is: A freezer bowl attachment designed to fit and work with KitchenAid stand mixers to make traditionally churned ice cream and sorbet.
- Key features: Large 2.0-quart capacity freezer bowl. A rotating dasher connects to the mixer's motor. Can make large batches suitable for families or parties.
- Price: The attachment typically costs around $99, but this requires an investment in a KitchenAid stand mixer (which costs $300+).
- Materials/Construction: Built with sturdy, heavy-duty insulated metal for the freezer bowl and high-quality plastic for the dasher and drive assembly, reflecting KitchenAid's reputation for durability.
- Style: Classic and functional, designed to seamlessly integrate with the iconic look of KitchenAid stand mixers. It shares the same timeless, durable aesthetic.
- Pros: Produces large batches perfect for families and entertaining. Creates a classic, rich, and dense churned ice cream texture. Extremely durable and built to last. Leverages the powerful and reliable motor of the stand mixer.
- Cons: Requires owning a compatible KitchenAid stand mixer. The bulky two-quart bowl needs to be pre-frozen for at least 15-24 hours and takes up significant freezer space. Less versatile in the types of desserts it can make compared to the Creami.
The KitchenAid attachment is perfect for those who already own a stand mixer, love making traditional ice cream, and need the capacity to serve a family or guests.
Shop this product: kitchenaid.com/countertop-appliances/stand-mixers/attachments/ksmicm.html
Creami vs. KitchenAid Comparison
Process & Batch Size
This is the most significant difference. The Creami works with single-serving "pints" that you freeze solid for 24 hours. The machine then processes a pint in about 2-5 minutes. This model is perfect for making one or two servings at a time, but it's inefficient for serving a large group as you would need to prep and freeze multiple separate pints in advance.
The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker produces up to two quarts in one go, enough for about 8-10 servings. Its bowl must be frozen for about 15-24 hours beforehand, and the churning process itself takes 20-30 minutes. While it requires the same planning for freezing, it excels at producing a large volume for parties or stocking the freezer.
Materials & Construction
The Creami is a self-contained unit constructed primarily of durable plastic. It's relatively lightweight and designed with a modern aesthetic and countertop convenience in mind. It feels solid enough for daily use, but not as heavy-duty as traditional KitchenAid products.
KitchenAid builds its attachment for longevity, a hallmark of the brand. The freezer bowl is heavy and robust with its metal and insulated construction. The entire mechanism feels substantial and is designed to handle frequent, high-volume use by relying on the stable power of the stand mixer base.
Price & Value
Priced at around $200, the Ninja Creami is an all-in-one system. For that price, you get everything you need to start making desserts. It offers tremendous value through its versatility, allowing you to create smoothies, milkshakes, and sorbets in addition to ice cream.
The KitchenAid attachment is more affordable at around $99, but its true cost is higher as it’s useless without a stand mixer. If you already have one, it's a fantastic value add-on. If you don't, the combined cost makes it a much larger investment. Its value lies in its large capacity and durability.
Style & Versatility
The Creami sports a slim, modern, vertical design that fits easily into contemporary kitchens and small spaces. Its true strength is functional versatility. With multiple presets, it can tackle a wide range of frozen treats far beyond simple ice cream, which is a major draw for creative home cooks.
The KitchenAid attachment inherits the classic, timeless style of its parent appliance. It's more of a specialist tool - it makes traditionally churned ice cream, gelato, and sorbet extremely well, but lacks the multi-functionality of the Creami. Its focus is on perfecting one task and doing it at scale.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both machines are excellent, but they are built for entirely different users and situations.
Choose the Creami if:
- You want to make single servings perfect for one or two people.
- You have limited kitchen or freezer space.
- You love experimenting with mix-ins, different bases (like protein shakes), and a variety of dessert types (sorbet, milkshakes, etc.).
- You value speed and want a frozen treat ready within five minutes (after the 24-hr prep freeze).
Choose the KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker if:
- You already own and love your KitchenAid stand mixer.
- You regularly need to make large batches of ice cream for family, friends, or parties.
- You prefer the taste and texture of classic, slow-churned ice cream.
- You prioritize durability and build quality for long-term use.
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the main difference between the Creami and KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker?
The main difference is the method. The Creami takes a fully frozen block of ingredients and "shaves" it into a dessert. The KitchenAid takes a liquid base and churns it while freezing it, the traditional way ice cream is made. This results in different textures, batch sizes, and preparation processes.
Do I need a KitchenAid stand mixer to use the ice cream maker?
Yes. The popular and widely available KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker is an attachment. It has no motor and relies entirely on the power of the stand mixer to operate.
Which one is faster?
Both require at least 15-24 hours of advance freezing. On serving day, the Creami is much faster, processing a pint in about 2-5 minutes. The KitchenAid takes 20-30 minutes of churning to produce its final product.
Which one makes better ice cream?
This is subjective. The Creami makes an exceptionally smooth, soft, and creamy product. The KitchenAid creates a traditional, dense, and rich churned texture that many people associate with premium store-bought ice cream. Your preference for texture will determine which is "better" for you.
Can the Creami make a large batch of ice cream?
No, the Creami is designed for single-serving containers called "pints." To serve multiple people, you have to prepare, freeze, and process each pint individually, which can be time-consuming.
How much freezer space does the KitchenAid bowl need?
It needs a significant amount of freezer space. The 2-quart bowl is bulky and measures approximately 7" tall by 8.5" in diameter. You'll need to ensure you have a flat, stable spot in your freezer where it can sit undisturbed for up to 24 hours before use.
Which one is easier to clean?
The Creami is generally considered easier to clean. The pints, lids, and blade assembly are all top-rack dishwasher safe. The large KitchenAid bowl must be hand-washed after it has fully thawed, which can be a more cumbersome process.
What are the dimensions and weight of each product?
The Ninja Creami is about 16.5" H x 6.5" W x 12" D and weighs around 13 lbs. The KitchenAid Ice Cream Maker attachment bowl is roughly 7" H x 8.5" D and weighs about 6 lbs, though this doesn't include the weight and size of the required stand mixer.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
