The Crate & Barrel Aspen and Essential Dinnerware collections both offer simple, clean-lined plates and bowls, but they differ significantly in their materials, price, and target audience. The Aspen collection is a more premium porcelain or stoneware set with a refined, modern aesthetic designed for style-conscious homeowners, while Essential Dinnerware is a budget-friendly and highly practical option built for everyday durability and value.
Here’s everything you need to know to decide which dinnerware set is the right fit for your table.
Crate & Barrel Aspen Dinnerware
Crate & Barrel's Aspen collection is known for its modern, minimalist appeal and high-quality construction. It's designed for those who appreciate a clean aesthetic and are looking for a versatile set that works equally well for a weeknight dinner or a special occasion. Its timeless design and durable materials make it a popular choice for wedding registries and homeowners investing in long-lasting tableware.
- What it is: A modern dinnerware collection crafted from high-quality porcelain or stoneware, known for its clean lines and minimalist style.
- Key features: Bright white finish, sleek and simple silhouettes, durable construction suitable for regular use, and a timeless design that complements various table settings.
- Price: Typically ranges from $50 to $150 for a 16-piece set (service for four).
- Style: Contemporary and minimalist. The clean, unembellished style fits seamlessly into modern, Scandinavian, or transitional home decor.
- Materials/Construction: Often made from high-grade porcelain or stoneware, giving the pieces a substantial feel and a more refined, polished look. They are typically dishwasher and microwave-safe.
- Pros: Elegant and timeless design elevates any meal. High-quality materials resist chipping and wear. Versatile enough for both daily use and formal entertaining. Carries the trusted Crate & Barrel brand reputation.
- Cons: Comes with a higher price tag. The minimalist style might be too plain for those who prefer more decorative dinnerware.
The Aspen collection is ideal for someone looking to invest in a versatile, stylish dinnerware set that will last for years and adapt to changing tastes and dining occasions.
Shop this product: crateandbarrel.com
Essential Dinnerware
Essential Dinnerware focuses on delivering practical, durable, and exceptionally affordable tableware for everyday life. The brand is geared toward budget-conscious consumers, first-time homeowners, and families who need reliable pieces that can withstand the rigors of daily meals, dishwashers, and microwaves without a fuss. Their designs are simple, classic, and built for function over flair.
- What it is: A value-oriented brand offering durable stoneware and ceramic dinnerware sets designed for everyday use.
- Key features: Simple, classic shapes, microwave and dishwasher safe, highly affordable price point, often sold in complete 16-piece sets.
- Price: Generally priced between $30 and $80 for a service for four.
- Style: Functional and classic simplicity. The designs are straightforward and meant to blend into any casual table setting without distraction.
- Materials/Construction: Made from durable stoneware or ceramic designed to handle daily use. The finish is practical, although it may lack the polished refinement of more expensive brands.
- Pros: Extremely budget-friendly. Reliable durability for everyday family use. Simple, classic look is easy to mix and match with other pieces. An excellent value for the price.
- Cons: Lacks a premium or "special occasion" feel. The finish and craftsmanship are less refined than Crate & Barrel's. Potentially more prone to chipping with rough handling compared to high-end porcelain.
This brand is the perfect match for families, students, and budget-conscious individuals who prioritize practicality, durability, and affordability in their dinnerware.
Shop this product: essentialhome.com
Crate & Barrel Aspen vs. Essential Dinnerware Comparison
Materials & Quality
The most significant difference lies in the materials and overall feel of the two collections. Crate & Barrel's Aspen dinnerware is typically made from porcelain or high-quality stoneware, giving it a solid feel, a smoother glaze, and greater resistance to everyday wear. The attention to detail in finishing results in a more elegant product that looks and feels premium.
Essential Dinnerware uses functional stoneware and ceramic designed for endurance at a lower cost. While perfectly durable for daily use, the pieces may have a slightly heavier, less refined finish. You might notice minor imperfections in the glaze or shape that you wouldn't find in a higher-priced set from a brand like Crate & Barrel.
Style & Aesthetic
Both brands favor a simple, clean aesthetic, but their design intent is different. The Aspen collection embodies intentional minimalism - its clean lines and bright white color create a modern, restaurant-quality canvas for food. It’s designed to be subtly stylish and sophisticated.
Essential Home's dinnerware style is born from simplicity and function. The designs are classic, familiar, and created to be as practical as possible. The focus isn't on making a design statement but on providing a reliable, unobtrusive set of dishes for everyday meals.
Price & Value
There's a clear winner in the price department. Essential Dinnerware offers an incredible value, with a complete service for four often costing less than half the price of a comparable set from Crate & Barrel. This makes it an accessible choice for anyone on a tight budget or those who don't want to worry about breaking an expensive plate.
Crate & Barrel Aspen provides a different kind of value. The higher price reflects better materials, more sophisticated design, and durability that makes it a long-term investment. While it costs more upfront, its timeless appeal and sturdy construction mean you won't need to replace it for a very long time.
Who Each One Works Best For
The Crate & Barrel Aspen collection resonates with homeowners who see their dining setup as an extension of their home’s decor. It’s perfect for individuals and couples who enjoy entertaining and want a single, high-quality dinnerware set that serves beautifully for both casual weeknight meals and more formal dinner parties. If you appreciate clean design and are willing to invest in quality, Aspen is a fantastic choice.
Essential Dinnerware is built for practicality. It’s the ideal solution for large families with kids, college students, people furnishing their first apartment, or anyone who just needs a solid, no-frills set of dishes that gets the job done. If your primary concerns are durability, ease of care, and an unbeatable price, Essential Dinnerware is the clear winner.
Which One Should You Choose?
Both the Aspen and Essential dinnerware collections are great options, but they cater to very different needs and budgets.
Choose the Crate & Barrel Aspen if:
- You want a stylish, sophisticated look that elevates your everyday dining experience.
- You are looking for a versatile set that works for both casual meals and dinner parties.
- You view your dinnerware as a long-term investment in your home.
- You appreciate the refined feel of high-quality porcelain or stoneware.
Choose Essential Dinnerware if:
- You have a strict budget or need to furnish your home affordably.
- You need durable, no-stress dishes for a busy family with children.
- Functionality and practicality are far more important to you than high-end design.
- You prefer simple, basic tableware that is easy to replace if a piece breaks.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the main difference between Crate & Barrel Aspen and Essential Dinnerware?
The core difference is quality and intent. The Crate & Barrel Aspen is a design-forward, premium collection made from higher-quality materials for a more elevated aesthetic. Essential Dinnerware is a value-focused brand that prioritizes durability and affordability for everyday use.
Is the Crate & Barrel Aspen set worth the extra cost?
If style, feel, and long-term versatility are important to you, then yes. The higher cost reflects superior materials, a more refined finish, and a timeless design that you'll be happy using for years for all kinds of occasions.
Which dinnerware set is better for a family with children?
For most families, Essential Dinnerware is the more practical choice. Its lower price point means you won’t worry as much about accidental chips or breaks, and its durable build is designed to handle the wear and tear of daily family meals.
Are both brands' dinnerware sets dishwasher and microwave safe?
Yes, both the Crate & Barrel Aspen collection and Essential Dinnerware sets are designed for modern convenience and are typically safe for use in both the dishwasher and microwave.
Which is more durable and resistant to chipping?
Generally, the high-quality porcelain used in collections like Crate & Barrel Aspen offers better chip resistance and overall longevity than standard everyday stoneware. However, Essential Dinnerware is still quite durable and perfectly suitable for daily use.
Do these collections offer serving pieces and additional items?
Crate & Barrel almost always offers a full suite of matching pieces for its collections, including serving platters, bowls, and other accessories. Essential Home’s collections are more basic, typically focusing on the core dinner plate, salad plate, bowl, and mug set, with fewer add-ons available.
Can starter sets from either brand be expanded?
Yes, both brands typically sell pieces open stock (individually), which allows you to replace a broken piece or add to your collection. This is a common feature on the websites for both Crate & Barrel and Essential Home.
Which brand has a better return policy?
Crate & Barrel is known for its customer-friendly return policy, often allowing returns on non-furniture items within 30 days. You should check the current return policy for Essential Dinnerware on their website, as it can vary, but most online brands offer a similar window for returns of unused products.
At Interior Insider, we're dedicated to curating the best in home decor, interior design, and home essentials to help you discover brands we think you'll love. Every brand we feature is independently selected by our editorial team based on quality, design, and craftsmanship. When you make a purchase through our links, Interior Insider may earn a commission - which helps support our small team and allows us to continue bringing you inspiration and expert advice for creating your perfect space.
Looking for more inspiration? Explore our curated design guides to find your next favorite piece.
